Phase 8 or Cutler Total Protein?

[DamondHull]

Both are BOGO. I havent had a MT product since 2011, and have never had a BPI/Cutler product. Which of these is more worth picking up at BOGO? And best flavors?

[DGarcia519]

Both are BOGO. I havent had a MT product since 2011, and have never had a BPI/Cutler product. Which of these is more worth picking up at BOGO? And best flavors?

Though I have not had TP, I really enjoyed the Whey-HD flavours I had. They are supposedly made in the same facility, or at least the same flavoring house, so I would expect quality on that side (also gets pretty solid reviews). Also, I believe TP is going to be certified soon for protein content (same certification as W-HD), where P8 is known to be spiked. I did enjoy the flavours of P8 I had, but will likely not buy it again. I don't see the point when there are better options at similar prices.

[shiftmx6]

Total Protein without a doubt, IMO.

[Madevilz]

Chose the one that doesn't have taurine and glycine

[carguy123]

Total Protein without a doubt, IMO.

This^^^ Banana Creme Pie is ridiculously good, honorable mention to Strawberry Graham cracker...Smores was OK.

[Anthony21]

Ask yourself if you prefer a protein that's amino spiked vs one that isn't and that should answer your question (hopefully).

BTW what's up with your lifting stats lol?

Squat/Bench/Deadlift all the same weight practically lol.

[Misctake7]

Total Protein is good stuff! Blows my mind how many times it's been on BOGO. I keep thinking I must be missing something on the label if they are trying to get rid of it so cheap.

[ajvitan]

Total Protein is good stuff! Blows my mind how many times it's been on BOGO. I keep thinking I must be missing something on the label if they are trying to get rid of it so cheap.

overstock sale from Cutler is all.

[forevertwink]

I've had both (every flavor of phase8) and 3 flavors of total protein. total protein is the 'cleaner' protein, but since im a 1 shake a day guy, who intakes more protein than i need, i go with phase8 because i love the flavoring (pbc), makes awesome sludge and i prefer thicker textures. flame away

[jlk03090]

I just picked up some Cutler on BOGO, though, and the SGC is really good too. Texture definitely better than Ph.8. Not usually a fruit flavor-lover but it's not sickly sweet and it does NOT have a nasty artificial taste whatsoever, which is usually my issue with anything berry. I also got S'mores that I can't wait to break into!

White Chocolate from Phase 8 is wicked good; though I find the texture is kind of "weird" if you drink it right after shaking it. Better if it sits for a little bit. Keep in mind I haven't been following the "protein spiking" news, though - from reading the above I'm guessing it's one that is guilty.

[QuarterTank]

I've enjoyed the TP, I have a tub of Banana and Smores on the way as well. May order a couple more tubs today.

Interesting and disappointing to hear Phase8 is spiked. I will say the P8 is by far the best tasting Chocolate I have had.


Based on these comments I would go with TP no doubt

[shiftmx6]

Jumped on the Total Protein BOGO again as soon as this thread popped up.

[danielmoo]

I would personally go with CN Total Protein. You have to try the Banana Cream Pie, along with either Strawberry Graham Cracker or Smores!

[DamondHull]

Ask yourself if you prefer a protein that's amino spiked vs one that isn't and that should answer your question (hopefully).

BTW what's up with your lifting stats lol?

Squat/Bench/Deadlift all the same weight practically lol.

Results very 1 sided. Thanks for all the responses will rep.
Yea my lifting stats are all jacked up. I never used to do leg day or deadlifts. Just started doing those about 2 months ago to try and make the 1000 pound club. lol

[Anthony21]

Results very 1 sided. Thanks for all the responses will rep.
Yea my lifting stats are all jacked up. I never used to do leg day or deadlifts. Just started doing those about 2 months ago to try and make the 1000 pound club. lol

Right on man and best of luck in that pursuit.

[Big_Spaz]

Total Protein is excellent. The Banana flavor is one of the best on the market IMO.





-Spaz

[AfroPope]

Another vote for Cutler. Tasty with zero fillers.

[OT2000]

NOT EVEN Close. Cutler Total Protein. I would never buy Phase 8.

[DamondHull]

Right on man and best of luck in that pursuit.

Thanks man! I've finally decided to listen to everyone about leg day and deadlifts lol

[DamondHull]

Will finish reps on recharge. So I'll get banana, do I get strawberry or smores with it?

[emergency]

Sounds like everyone is giving Total Protein their vote. Have yet to try it but for flavors of Phase 8 I am a big fan of Cookies and Cream and White Chocolate.

[danielmoo]

Will finish reps on recharge. So I'll get banana, do I get strawberry or smores with it?

Either is a good choice honestly.. Depends if you want another fruit tasting one or not?

[OT2000]

Will finish reps on recharge. So I'll get banana, do I get strawberry or smores with it?

I have had all 3 and banana is the best. Other 2 are equal. So fruit or chocolate flavor, your choice.

[carguy123]

Will finish reps on recharge. So I'll get banana, do I get strawberry or smores with it?

I liked the strawberry over the smores and gf agreed with me. Smores basically tasted like chocolate to me...idk maybe my tastebuds are broken.

You could always get 2 banana..its dat good

[TheFugitive]

Thanks for all the Total Protein support in this thread

[Ruckus91]

Just picked up 2 of the s'mores and it's great. Nice Chocolate and Graham Cracker flavor.

[DamondHull]

Just picked up Banana and Strawberry! Thanks again!