** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread -- Round 2 **

[Jevice]

Idk man C status looking strong.



Pounded it out a month or so ago. Just didn't catch me I guess.

I really am a fan of their Sweet Cream Base but I just couldnt give this flavor higher than a C. The combination of the base and mix-ins just wasnt meant for my palate and I couldnt come to thoroughly enjoy like other flavors.

I think it's just my preference towards wafer cookies that made this one appealing to me.

[Gemuadrken]

I think it's just my preference towards wafer cookies that made this one appealing to me.

Its my go to when im craving "simple"

[MITCHAPAL00ZA]

whos next? Im contemplating giving it a shot

[nickreds3]

Picked up Ben & Jerry's Cheesecake Brownie last night with low expectations. I just felt the need to try it since it was one of the few B&J flavors I hadn't scooped yet. It has been consistently rated as one of their worst offering, but I was pleasantly surprised when I dove in.

The cheesecake base isn't overpowering, but it still has a nice, subtle cheesecake flavor. What really makes this flavor work is the multitude of brownies in every bite. The combo of cheesecake and brownies is spot on, and I have to give this one a solid B despite it being such a simple flavor.

[jaredmus]

Picked up Ben & Jerry's Cheesecake Brownie last night with low expectations. I just felt the need to try it since it was one of the few B&J flavors I hadn't scooped yet. It has been consistently rated as one of their worst offering, but I was pleasantly surprised when I dove in.

The cheesecake base isn't overpowering, but it still has a nice, subtle cheesecake flavor. What really makes this flavor work is the multitude of brownies in every bite. The combo of cheesecake and brownies is spot on, and I have to give this one a solid B despite it being such a simple flavor.

Out of ben and jerry's flavor I have tried this is my least favorite, strawberry cheesecake was not all to good IMO either,

[FattyMcTubbs]

the brownie one) were both awful. Well, as awful as eating ice cream can be.

wait, wut?
brownies is my #1
you're cray son
Only thing about it I sort of wish was better is the choco swirl, too much like hershey's syrup

again, you cray

[patroclus32]

UK BRAHS!!!! Get to Sainsburys ASAP. I had it out in the states last month and now it's here. It delivers. Best flavour out I think.

I just bought a pint of that flavor today. I was a bit disappointed. I didn't think the base was very tasty, although I have to say the huge peanut butter cups were awesome. I also got Cherry Garcia and I liked that flavor more.

I'd give peanut butter cup a 6/10, cherry garcia 8/10

[bambam601]

Im contemplating giving it a shot

when?

[usawinston]

I just bought a pint of that flavor today. I was a bit disappointed. I didn't think the base was very tasty, although I have to say the huge peanut butter cups were awesome. I also got Cherry Garcia and I liked that flavor more.

I'd give peanut butter cup a 6/10, cherry garcia 8/10

6/10 for Peanut butter cup? Ranked Cherry Garcia higher???

[kidkindacool]

whos next? Im contemplating giving it a shot

I say up him a container. If anyone goes for this I will too.
Full confidence.

[tf13]

Not bad for a store brand

[bambam601]

I say up him a container. If anyone goes for this I will too.
Full confidence.

it honestly doesnt look that hard to do.
but on the other hand, ive havent had anywhere close to that much ice cream in one sitting.

[Vendetta52]

I had a Ciao Bella Sea Salt Caramel Square tonight. After seeing Chad's review of them and checking my Whole Foods last night, I decided to pick up a box to try.





It was pretty small for 250 calories, weighing in at 3.25 ounces. When I could get a taste of the ice cream by itself I could appreciate the smooth sea salt ice cream, which tasted great. However, when I took a bite that included the cookies (aka a normal bite), they overpowered the ice cream. Despite Chad's high score for this I would avoid this one, it is nothing special unfortunately.

[tf13]

I say up him a container. If anyone goes for this I will too.
Full confidence.

Man, that's a lot of ice cream. A gallon and a half's worth just sitting in your stomach for a few days. I think 2 containers would be pretty easy, that third.... and a fourth would be insane.

[emtvstheworld]

Man, that's a lot of ice cream. A gallon and a half's worth just sitting in your stomach for a few days. I think 2 containers would be pretty easy, that third.... and a fourth would be insane.

The 375 lb former fat kid in me says this is easily achievable.

[kidkindacool]

it honestly doesnt look that hard to do.
but on the other hand, ive havent had anywhere close to that much ice cream in one sitting.

Lol tell me about it, it would need a days prep to clear out your system/stomach prior to the smash.

The 375 lb former fat kid in me says this is easily achievable.

Lol the inner calling, waiting dormant to be unleashed.

[lightweight0422]

I say up him a container. If anyone goes for this I will too.
Full confidence.

Even if calories didn't exist I wouldn't try eating that much ice cream in one sitting. Would feel like chit for hours.

[cumminslifter]

wth when did "round 2" come up?

[seamus33]

wth when did "round 2" come up?

where've you been?

[cumminslifter]

where've you been?

sorry wrong thread, i thought this was fastfood thread, strong reading skills

[mcdond12]

Had a little over 1 serving left of my hand packed pint of C7LB so I decided to top that off. Personally love this flavor. Coconut flavor is very present and abundant throughout which is definitely what makes this a hit or miss for everybody. Only wish I had more :/


Then decided to fill the rest of my remaining calories with a couple flavors my mom brought home today. Not bad considering each was only 110 cal per serving. Was able to have 2 servings of each.

Edy's Slow Churned "Take the Cake"



Edy's Slow Churned "German Chocolate Cake Spectacular"

[jaredmus]

liking the edy's love and c7lb is underrated IMO one of my favorites from B and J

[kidkindacool]

Even if calories didn't exist I wouldn't try eating that much ice cream in one sitting. Would feel like chit for hours.

I think if you did some preparation and worked in some intermittent fasting you could do it without extreme discomfort. Those slow churned flavors he did are like 110cal a serv with 12 servs a container wouldn't be as dense as bnjs or something like that. The only thing I would consider is the coldness on your teeth and the sugar rush. I'd go with some warm water on the side to sip.

[payton450]

Just wondering, how quickly do you guys finish off a pint.

I feel like all these flavors are waiting to be eaten, but then all my calories are coming from ice cream for the most part past my basic protein sources. You guys have a massive amount of calories that you are taking in/ Do you guys find that ice cream fills you up? I am in the middle of ramping up my calories and seem to always be hungry still. If I eat a large amount of ice cream I get hungry pretty soon afterwards. If I eat "bro" food I tend to stay fuller a little longer.

Sorry for the non-ice cream picture related posted. Enjoy reading all the reviews though

[emtvstheworld]

Lol the inner calling, waiting dormant to be unleashed.

Dude if it weren't for my poverty ass macros I'd be all over that just to prove a point....and to enjoy delicious ice cream.

[TylerTomlinson]

I'm in! How much IC are you guys eating a meal/a day ?

[mcdond12]

liking the edy's love and c7lb is underrated IMO one of my favorites from B and J

Couldn't agree more! Would be awesome if B&J added C7LB into their selection of pints available in stores and not just a scoop shop exclusive. As for Edy's, they have some awesome flavors that I have soft spots for. (French silk, classic vanilla, caramel delight, chocolate chip/cookie dough) all solid and with the calories being so low sometimes it's great to enjoy a few extra servings!

[AlwaysTryin]

I had a Ciao Bella Sea Salt Caramel Square tonight. After seeing Chad's review of them and checking my Whole Foods last night, I decided to pick up a box to try.

It was pretty small for 250 calories, weighing in at 3.25 ounces. When I could get a taste of the ice cream by itself I could appreciate the smooth sea salt ice cream, which tasted great. However, when I took a bite that included the cookies (aka a normal bite), they overpowered the ice cream. Despite Chad's high score for this I would avoid this one, it is nothing special unfortunately.

Good to see you have the same opinion. I completely disagreed with his s'mores review by ciao Bella and mentioned that earlier in the thread

[lightweight0422]

Just wondering, how quickly do you guys finish off a pint.

I feel like all these flavors are waiting to be eaten, but then all my calories are coming from ice cream for the most part past my basic protein sources. You guys have a massive amount of calories that you are taking in/ Do you guys find that ice cream fills you up? I am in the middle of ramping up my calories and seem to always be hungry still. If I eat a large amount of ice cream I get hungry pretty soon afterwards. If I eat "bro" food I tend to stay fuller a little longer.

Sorry for the non-ice cream picture related posted. Enjoy reading all the reviews though

I usually finish a pint in like 10-15 minutes lol. I eat ice cream shortly before going to bed so hunger isn't an issue for me. You don't need to sacrifice massive amounts of calories to enjoy some ice cream. But when I eat ice cream, it's usually over 1000 cals worth! It's not a big deal when you are taking in 3000+ cals a day like I do.

[AllBizNiz]

Whats with the huge disparity in serving sizes? Ex: Blue Bell Dutch Chocolate 1/2 cup or 74 grams, Talenti Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel 1/2 cup of 100 grams, BnJ's Vanilla Heath Bar 1/2 cup or 104 grams. Do they try and figure in the
mixins into the serving size? Anyway, a couple of quicky reviews...

Talenti Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel: Im not a huge peanut butter fan, but the peanut butter base was actually pretty tasty. The chocolate swirls help add a sweet component to the pb base. The chocolate covered pretzel pieces are
this flavors downfall. While some are crunchy and delicious, others are VERY mushy and unpleasant. With more consistent pretzel pieces, this flavor would have gotten a B. Score: C

BnJ Vanilla Heath Bar: When this flavor is at its best, its one of my favorites. When its at its worst, its just blah. Ill elaborate....When you get chunks of heath bar and that delicious, liquified caramel/heath essence, it is the sh*t. Then all of
a sudden, youre just scooping up plain, rather bland vanilla base with no mixins. Ive loved this flavor for years, but its just so inconstant, I might have to look elsewhere for my heath bar fix. Still, when its good, its great. Score: B-