|
View Poll Results: Do you cut water?
- Voters
- 33. You may not vote on this poll
Thread: Cutting water on Friday [poll]
-
03-14-2011, 12:19 PM #31
-
03-14-2011, 02:04 PM #32
Personally I never cut water but I do change what I drink and the amounts that I drink. I've met lots of guys and girls that cut water, sometimes food as well ... days before the comp. I have no idea how they can live like that and the look on their faces is usually borderline death! From what I've seen there are few competitors that aren't taking a coaches advice so I'm sure there's still a TON of old school dogma going on with these antics.
My $0.02 is worth $0.03
-
-
03-14-2011, 03:10 PM #33
- Join Date: Apr 2009
- Location: Evansville, Indiana, United States
- Age: 54
- Posts: 17
- Rep Power: 0
Loading up on potassium is not much different than loading sodium when it comes to aldosterone levels - not going to get the effect you want. As a matter of fact, it will pull sodium and water from within the cell and that's how you'll cramp, get super flat, and muscle can't contract. Potassium is what is used to make lethal injections to get the heart to stop. You lost water for sure - from in and out of the muscle cells. Flat, soft, squishy....not the look you're after on stage : )
Joe Klemczewski, PhD
www.perfectpeaking.com
-
03-14-2011, 04:36 PM #34
- Join Date: May 2009
- Location: Tempe, Arizona, United States
- Posts: 2,423
- Rep Power: 8501
If you say carb load on foods that just so happen to be high in potassium like potatoes will that have any negative affect on things if you are keeping everything else consistant? Or is is when you force an increase/decrease on one or the other that cause negative affects?
556/325/622 - 1504 total raw @ 193
551/319/567 - 1437 total raw @ 181
Best gym lifts - 575/340/650
***Inventor of the GENESIS JACK***
WWW.KLEVABUILT.COM
IG: KLEVABUILT
-
03-14-2011, 04:41 PM #35
- Join Date: Oct 2003
- Location: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Age: 43
- Posts: 5,013
- Rep Power: 5633
Why is it so hard to believe that if you can hold more water sub-q than in the muscle and look worse that you can also hold more water in the muscle than sub-q and look better?
I appreciate that, and believe me, I know exactly what you mean. When I first started competing, I did all of the old school bro-science techniques - cut water, cut sodium, higher reps "tone" muscle, you name it. After a few years of not placing where I wanted to, that's when I hired Layne back in 2007. He had just turned pro the year before and posted some pictures up of himself and I knew I could learn a lot from him on how get to that level. And I did...I learned a lot. He was able to de-bunk a lot of the things that I had heard before about various aspects of bodybuilding, and then explain with science as to why things either work or don't. It was a huge eye-opener for me.
Now, just as I did with Layne, I continued to talk to and learn from the best of the best in this sport...simply because, I want to eventually be one of the best at this sport. Now, when I say best of the best, I am referring to the top natural bodybuilders who seem to always either be winning their classes or overalls at just about any show they show up to. I'm not going to name names here, but let's just say that when you look up the top natural shows each year, there are always the same names in each federation that always seem to be at the top of the list in either their class or the overall. What I found after talking with these people ad nauseum was that just about every one of them do quite a few more "finer detail" things during their prep, especially peak week(s). Most of them use the natural diuretic pills, taper water, control sodium/potassium, control specific food sources, etc. They don't just "hit macros" and they do manipulate water, sodium/potassium, etc. So, my thinking was that there just might be something to it if almost ALL of these top level pros that are winning shows are doing it EVEN THOUGH there might not be a research study out there backing up what they are doing (not that there ever would be anyway).
So believe me, I know exactly what you are saying. It was VERY hard for me to go from someone like Layne where there is a research study backing up a lot of things that he says, to start listening to pros who are consistently winning professional shows that don't have a research study backing up everything they do. But, what I have found though on not only myself, but the clients I work with is that there IS something to this way beyond what any available research study can show. The difference isn't dramatic by any means (which is why I said before that there aren't a lot of people on this level yet where I would recommend messing with it), but there IS a difference. And when you are talking about a pro level show where just about EVERYONE shows up in shape with glutes, then what is it worth to you to show up perhaps a few percent better, harder, grainy, etc. to try and place better? I know for a fact that I could not have done as well as I did had I just shown up lean with glutes, hitting macros, and not manipulating water, sodium/potassium. The other bodybuilders in my class at both of my shows were WAY bigger than me, but I was told what separated me from the rest of the pack was how hard, dry and full I was in addition to being lean with glutes.
So, I do agree with the fact that for most, not cutting (or what I would call tapering) water is the best option to minimize any mistakes on additional variables, I will also say that there most definitely IS something more to fluid balance than not doing any manipulation whatsoever. Just as you can swing the door one way to make you look worse, you can also swing it the other way to improve your look. Dramatically? No. Which, again, was why I said before that you have a lot to lose and only a little bit to gain. But, if you are competing at a high level, is the risk worth it to you to gain some placings and possible win a show you couldn't otherwise? All I can say is that is was for me...
I'll have to disagree with you here. Being extremely lean does not equal being bone dry. There were bodybuilders at both of my shows, and in my class even, that were ridiculously shredded with glutes but were NOT dry. And their placings reflected that.
I agree that the vast majority of it is the hard work over several weeks of prepping and getting to that ultra lean level. I disagree that that is all there is to it.
The key here is "slight" and also that you are doing "slight" shifts to more variables than just the water intake.
I will disagree however that the visual result is insignificant. If you are lean enough, the visual difference is quite noticeable - just as it is when you can see someone who is lean that is softening up within minutes/hours on show day depending on what approach they are using for both prejudging and the night show and what all they did the prior week or two. I've literally seen bodybuilders show up looking like Berto with just insane stuff popping everywhere and within an hour, because of their approach, soften right up and look completely different on stage. I've also seen the reverse happen Hell, Ron Parmeter can vouch for the visual change I went through that whole day of the Cape Cod show. He literally saw me blow up for pre-judging, soften back up a bit afterwards, and blow right back up again for the night show. If he sees this thread, he might even post pictures he took over his phone on the visual difference from one hour to the next (he showed me pics he still had on his phone from that day at the Arnold). He thought I was performing some sort of voodoo on myself lol.
Agreed! I think we all know that cutting water either drastically, or completely out, is a one way ticket to disaster!
Agreed - there is a delicate balance you don't want to interrupt with respect to sodium/potassium!
SportoCore Nutritionals Sponsored Athlete
IFPA Professional Natural Bodybuilder
NASM Certified Personal Trainer
-
03-14-2011, 04:55 PM #36
-
-
03-14-2011, 04:55 PM #37
- Join Date: Oct 2003
- Location: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Age: 43
- Posts: 5,013
- Rep Power: 5633
By the way, I just wanted to say that the constructive criticism you gave me on my legs looking smaller this last year lit a fire under my *ss! I will be bringing those bad boys back up over the next couple of years and every leg day where I don't feel like bringing it, I'm just gonna remember that post
SportoCore Nutritionals Sponsored Athlete
IFPA Professional Natural Bodybuilder
NASM Certified Personal Trainer
-
03-14-2011, 04:57 PM #38
-
03-14-2011, 04:59 PM #39
Tommy - i read everything you wrote. Very interesting and very good points, indeed. I hope that I can achieve the level of lean-ness where I can play around with some of those variables, notice the differences, and decide for myself. Thanks for the input.
"Who the Son sets free is free indeed....."
WNBF Pro Natural Bodybuilder
Check out my CELLUCOR Supplement log:
http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=148746693&pagenumber=
3DMJ Athlete
-
03-14-2011, 05:56 PM #40
Tommy I have to say that your reply was some of the BEST advice I have read here on this forum in quite a while. To be honest, I didn't know who you were before I commented on this thread. But I looked at your pictures and I am VERY impressed! It's obvious you know what you're talking about...especially when it comes to what works for YOU. But a lot of what you said makes a LOT of sense to me. I come from the "old school" way of doing things. My last competition was 1992 and much has changed since then. BUT I have still seen some of the "old techniques" being used in "new ways" like tapering water (not cutting). Back in the day I did a COMPLETE decarb & not a partial. I had to measure my ketone level continuously. But that's the way things were done then. Many of these guys on this forum don't understand that & when I tell them how I used to prep they think I'm nuts & that is NOT the way to prep. But in all honesty, much is still the same (at least with the TOP competitors as you mentioned) but just modified & tweaked to be safer AND more effective. The trainer I have for this show has helped me A LOT in the area of looking how I USED to prep & combine it with the current techniques the the results are so much better than 20 years ago. The combination has allowed me to be in BETTER shape earlier & having the diet doing most of the work NOT the cardio!
To be honest, I still use the high rep method for contest prep BUT as advised by my trainer, I kept the calories HIGH (3000 +/-). This has had AMAZING results allowing me to get lean yet keep most of my muscle (just the usual muscle loss expected when fat loss occurs)...so there is an example of taking the old way & modify it with the new!
Thank you for all the great information...AND that you are able to help others WITHOUT just saying they are wrong & putting them down for how they do things!
-
-
03-14-2011, 07:09 PM #41
-
03-14-2011, 07:24 PM #42
Bad move all around......cutting water way too early (late, late Friday at the earliest) + distilled water will leach ALL minerals from your body...not just sodium. No sodium=no vascularity, no pump, and ineffective carb load. I would definitely rethink your strategy.....
Athletic Xtreme Sponsored Athlete-TEAM AX
Quest Protein Bar Athlete
Nutrient Sciences/Kymera Energy Rep
2012 Team Universe MW Champion
Member Team USA 2012 IFBB Worlds-Ecuador
-
03-14-2011, 07:45 PM #43
-
03-15-2011, 09:06 AM #44
- Join Date: Apr 2009
- Location: Evansville, Indiana, United States
- Age: 54
- Posts: 17
- Rep Power: 0
Some good points - sounds like a few people get it. The bottom line is that there is no recipe. Every person is going to be different and even contest to contest, every person is in a unique metabolic context and it's not going to be the same. You have to be able to read your body and know what you need.
The problem with tapering water can be that you get flatter than you think and don't recover enough to get filled back up. I see tremendous pros lose classes or shows because they just weren't aggressive enough. Hard...detailed....lean - absolutely - but they looked 30% better the week or two before the show because the fullness increases muscle separation on top of just seeing the added size. Use carbs and minerals to control how much water is retained. You can err much better on being full and tight by having enough (which really means too much - more than your body needs) and controlling carbs better.
Natural "dieuretics" - a lot of raw, plant-based potassium - just another variable to try to control and outsmart your body's homeostatic drive. You'll lose that battle every time.
Good note on "no sodium = no vascularity." It also means no water being held in the muscle, so no fullness and a lot of shaking and cramping.Joe Klemczewski, PhD
www.perfectpeaking.com
-
-
04-10-2012, 11:37 AM #45
I read something by Hany Rambod I believe (could have been Aceto) and he doesnt believe that low sodium can diminish your carb load. I see everyone saying that sodium is essential for proper carb load. Any have any science to back this up?
I personally will be dropping sodium slightly 2 days out and 1 day out, but not cutting it. Im not natural though.Sudbury Ontario championships july june 11 2011 - 5th light heavy weight class
London Ontario championships nov 26 2011 - 2nd heavy weight class
Next shows - Missisauga championship May 19th and Ontario championship June 2nd
Similar Threads
-
Creatine and Cutting Water Weight??
By fight_prof in forum SupplementsReplies: 8Last Post: 01-19-2007, 05:27 PM -
Hey cutting water help
By Hunterchilla in forum Contest Prep and Competition DiscussionReplies: 6Last Post: 08-02-2006, 11:02 AM -
Product for cutting water weight?
By ThrowinWeight in forum SupplementsReplies: 2Last Post: 04-10-2006, 11:29 PM -
Help me with cutting water
By Hunterchilla in forum Losing FatReplies: 0Last Post: 04-01-2006, 03:55 PM -
Cutting water intake
By akaMarko in forum Losing FatReplies: 7Last Post: 07-17-2005, 06:25 PM
Bookmarks