Rodgers or Brady

[HtotheOV]

you get to choose one for just rest of season


who you take??

[Day1086]

I just want to dive into the cleft of Brady's chin and never come out

[mabidi]

in on daily rodgers or brady thread

[sammywatkins]

TyGod taylor.

[ColdSteelToFace]

Godgers no question

[IsLifeRealLife]

Give me Rodgers by a million

[CheekClapperlol]

Rodgers playoff record is like 6 and 5? Lol just another regular season hero like manning dem playoff chokers

Gimme lord Brady any day of the week if I want a Super Bowl

[ColdSteelToFace]

Rodgers playoff record is like 6 and 5? Lol just another regular season hero like manning dem playoff chokers

Gimme lord Brady any day of the week if I want a Super Bowl

that is a team stat sonny

[Jaydawg08]

Who's my coach? Just imagine what Belicheck can do with Rodgers

[DarthRyuKen]

One has 1 ring and the other has 4. Sounds like an easy choice

[sammywatkins]

One has 1 ring and the other has 4. Sounds like an easy choice

Robert Horry> Charles Barkley
Chuck knoblauch> barry bonds
Eli Manning> Dan Marino

Pls fukkin go, red.

[DarthRyuKen]

Robert Horry> Charles Barkley
Chuck knoblauch> barry bonds
Eli Manning> Dan Marino

Pls fukkin go, red.

Brady>Rodgers, Manning


Stay mad son

[JmanTheJuiceman]

that is a team stat sonny

Patriots fans don't understand this, so don't try.




Last time I asked one of them to name a stat Brady > Rodgers in , they said W-L (****ing LOL)

[CheekClapperlol]

Patriots fans don't understand this, so don't try.




Last time I asked one of them to name a stat Brady > Rodgers in , they said W-L (****ing LOL)

As the goat said stats are for losers, Brady doesn't give a **** about stats he cares about winning you prob didn't even see he could care less about his 400 TD pass unlike manning or Brees who make celebrations over individual stats Brady is a winner stay mad son

[rampagefc77]

One has 1 ring and the other has 4. Sounds like an easy choice

Since Rodgers has been a QB, both have 1. Both have 1 SB in the last 10 years... Brady had early playoff success with a great defense and as a game manager. As "the guy" he's got 1. If we go by records and SBs, Eli manning has 2 SBs in that same time span, so he must be twice as good right?

[TheDude88]

Rodgers is the greatest of all time to play the quarterback position

[sdballer5588]

Since Rodgers has been a QB, both have 1. Both have 1 SB in the last 10 years...

Arbitrary guidelines are arbitrary. In the last ONE year Brady has 1 Rodgers has zero.

I shrunk your sample size even more, which was your point right? You shrunk it to make it more accurately reflect reality? Good thing I shrunk it even more, now we see the REAL truth!

[Hercegovac8]

To be fair brady could've had 7+ td's last game if he really wanted to stat pad, the pats ran the ball non stop in the redzone instead

Both are ATGs though, I think physically, Rodgers is better and can just do things Brady's body can't, but mentally and emotionally, Brady is like no one else, just a stone cold killer

[rampagefc77]

Arbitrary guidelines are arbitrary. In the last ONE year Brady has 1 Rodgers has zero.

I shrunk your sample size even more, which was your point right? You shrunk it to make it more accurately reflect reality? Good thing I shrunk it even more, now we see the REAL truth!

If we are looking at career stats/accomplishments (ie # of SBs, # of MVPs), that isn't a fair stat as 1 has many more years left than the other. Brady has failed in the playoffs 9/10 times in the last 10 years, Rodgers hasn't even played in 10 playoffs.

[sdballer5588]

If we are looking at career stats/accomplishments (ie # of SBs, # of MVPs), that isn't a fair stat as 1 has many more years left than the other. Brady has failed in the playoffs 9/10 times in the last 10 years, Rodgers hasn't even played in 10 playoffs.

You would be doing Rodgers QUITE the service considering Brady won 3 superbowls in his first 4 seasons, meaning if you were aCTUALLY being fair, you would simply compare their first 8 years (or however many Rodgers has been in) you wouldn't just arbitrarily START brady's career when Rodgers started.

That's logically absurd.

By your own definition of "failed" Rodgers has only NOT failed one time, the same amount as Brady "in the last 10 years", difference is Brady won 3 more before that, meaning his win % is significantly higher. You just removed that part of your criteria because it wouldn't make sense for your agenda.

[ColdSteelToFace]

Who's my coach? Just imagine what Belicheck can do with Rodgers

[DarthRyuKen]

You would be doing Rodgers QUITE the service considering Brady won 3 superbowls in his first 4 seasons, meaning if you were aCTUALLY being fair, you would simply compare their first 8 years (or however many Rodgers has been in) you wouldn't just arbitrarily START brady's career when Rodgers started.

That's logically absurd.

By your own definition of "failed" Rodgers has only NOT failed one time, the same amount as Brady "in the last 10 years", difference is Brady won 3 more before that, meaning his win % is significantly higher. You just removed that part of your criteria because it wouldn't make sense for your agenda.

Sdballer ethering nigguhs

[ColdSteelToFace]

Terry Bradshaw is ACTUALLY quite LITERALLY and SERIOUSLY and NOT ARBITRARILY the greatest quarterback of all time

anyone who disagrees is logically absurd

[LeonardShelby]

If we are looking at career stats/accomplishments (ie # of SBs, # of MVPs), that isn't a fair stat as 1 has many more years left than the other. Brady has failed in the playoffs 9/10 times in the last 10 years, Rodgers hasn't even played in 10 playoffs.

How many Conference championships has Brady won since Rodgers started? How many has Rodgers won? How many has each played in?

[LeonardShelby]

Who's my coach? Just imagine what Belicheck can do with Rodgers

Lose to the Bills in Buffalo for a change?

[rampagefc77]

Sdballer ethering nigguhs

if the seahawks just run the ball then brady has 3 rings and Wilson has 2....

Think about that. Shows you how much influence the QB has on those rings, and how must influence the rest of the team has as well.

[sdballer5588]

Terry Bradshaw is ACTUALLY quite LITERALLY and SERIOUSLY and NOT ARBITRARILY the greatest quarterback of all time

Based on being tied with Montana and Brady for ring total? I guess if we just stopped there.... sure? Again, this is another fallacious example where you no longer felt the need to continue on with criteria because it would ruin your terrible point.

[rampagefc77]

How many Conference championships has Brady won since Rodgers started? How many has Rodgers won? How many has each played in?

The packers have been playing stellar niners, seahawks, and giants teams in the playoffs. They don't get AFC cupcakes each year to stat pad in the playoffs

I'm pretty sure every team that packers have lost to in the playoffs have gone on to the NFC championship or SB. Can that be said about the teams the patriots have lost to?

[BuckNakedinBama]

Brady. Got that killer instinct.

[sdballer5588]

Rampagefc just going to pretend he didn't just get taken to church, baptized, eulogized and buried up there. Okay bud.