** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread **

[DeathBySquats]

I have a bit of an odd top 10 as well in some aspects

1. OCC
2. Cinnamon Buns
3. WAC
4. Phish Food
5. Peach Cobler
6. Peanut Brittle
7. S'Mores
8. LNS
9. Boston Cream Pie
10. Americone Dream

Have only scooped PB Cup, and Chubby Hubby once and was unimpressed especially for the cals might have been bad pints will revisist. Haven't tried target exclusives either, much bigger fan of 2nd street, graeters, and some local brands.

[kidkindacool]

Alright ice cream bros you asked for it. Ill post a pic tomorrow of them all out on the table.
20+ pint chaos
And this isn't even all of it lol

[xaurax]

^^^^^ Sick, bro.

Where did you get the Blueberry Cheesecake?

[Dre4]

^^^^^ Sick, bro.

Where did you get the Blueberry Cheesecake?

its a walmart exclusive

[Chadillac2000]

According to my rankings my top 10 B&J's are (keep in mind I haven't had OCC):

1. Cinnamon Buns
2. Peanut Butter World
3. What a Cluster
4. Chocolate Therapy
5. Banana Cream Pie
6. Chubby Hubby (Fairtrade Edition)
7. Half Baked
8. Pumpkin Cheesecake
9. Coconut 7 Layer Bar (Scoop Shop)
10. Brownie Chew Gooder

[xaurax]

its a walmart exclusive

Thanks. Gotta check out the selection at my local Walmarts soon.

[kidkindacool]

According to my rankings my top 10 B&J's are (keep in mind I haven't had OCC):

1. Cinnamon Buns
2. Peanut Butter World
3. What a Cluster
4. Chocolate Therapy
5. Banana Cream Pie
6. Chubby Hubby (Fairtrade Edition)
7. Half Baked
8. Pumpkin Cheesecake
9. Coconut 7 Layer Bar (Scoop Shop)
10. Brownie Chew Gooder

I believe OCC would hit right under CB if you had it that is. Tell you what man, score me a Pint of NO's Beignet and Ill get ya on a pint of my OCC. I dont know if you remember my last pic of OCC but so far every pint I had of it has been pretty on point. I know some BnJs have been lackluster in mixins as of late with alot of peoples reviews.
Trading ice cream? Thats on a epic scale my friend.

[ThousandEyes]

According to my rankings my top 10 B&J's are (keep in mind I haven't had OCC):

1. Cinnamon Buns
2. Peanut Butter World
3. What a Cluster
4. Chocolate Therapy
5. Banana Cream Pie
6. Chubby Hubby (Fairtrade Edition)
7. Half Baked
8. Pumpkin Cheesecake
9. Coconut 7 Layer Bar (Scoop Shop)
10. Brownie Chew Gooder

So underrated imo glad to see it got a top spot

[Bnizzle163]

I guess I'll play too...
1. Peanut butter world
2-10. Peanut butter world

Kidding . I'll report back when I try more B&J flavors. I've only tried 5 thus far.

[blindspot13]

Just had B&J Volun-tiramisu. I had never even had tiramisu irl so I wasn't sure what to expect and I don't really like coffee, but it was very good. Would scoop again.

[Ricky62Bobby]

Do we know when Candy Bar Pie is hitting stores? I'm sure this will be a top 5 flavor for me.

[ybsny]

Just had my first pint of Talenti. It was SSC. All the love it gets here is actually an understatement to how good it is. I've never had a pint of ice cream that I would legit work around to fit in my macros everyday, if only I had the money for it... Big life changing moment for me in terms of ice cream. Quickest yet most satisfying pint. Happy taste buds.

[xmohamm1]

Alright ice cream bros you asked for it. Ill post a pic tomorrow of them all out on the table.
20+ pint chaos
And this isn't even all of it lol

Wow...you are sooo lucky. All these awesome retired flavors...rocky roadish, dublin mudslide, creme brulee, key lime pie, cannoli, OCC. So jealous. My retired flavor stack is just 6 OCC pints, and 1 cannoli. My freezer isn't big enough I can only hold 12 pints at a time (always completely fill btw).

[just4it]

Weiss bars

[SaganX]

^Cannoli is still rather easily found.. or at least it would seem in my area

[Rian016]

Oh Cone-ada!

Pretty much a "Canadian" version of Americone Dream.

Really wanted to like this flavour, but mine was just so badly freezer burnt that I could barely taste a difference in any of the ingredients.

Probably won't try it again.

Wow at how freezer burnt that is. This flavour also seemed to be discontinued in Canada but it seems that it doesn't matter as they're still showing up in stores (like your scoop of Red Velvet Cake).

[Chadillac2000]

I believe OCC would hit right under CB if you had it that is. Tell you what man, score me a Pint of NO's Beignet and Ill get ya on a pint of my OCC. I dont know if you remember my last pic of OCC but so far every pint I had of it has been pretty on point. I know some BnJs have been lackluster in mixins as of late with alot of peoples reviews.
Trading ice cream? Thats on a epic scale my friend.

I'll have to see what I can do about that. Sounds like it could be an even trade. Let me get in contact with NOLA Ice Cream Co. about getting a pint. Apparently that's their most popular flavor and there's never enough.

And in your stash...I see that Banana Cream Pie hiding in there. Love that stuff. Almost bought a pint tonight.

[chadomac]

Top tennin it...

1. Chubby Hubby
2. Oatmeal Cookie Chunk
3. Mud Pie (can't find it anywhere anymore, unfortunately)
4. HD White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
5. HD Vanilla Bean Espresso
6. Dublin Mudslide
7. Milk & Cookies
8. New York Super Fudge Chunk
9. Late Night Snack
10. Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz Buzz


I don't drink coffee, but as you can see I sure do love me some coffee-desserts.

I've only had two different flavors, but both the 2nd Street Creamery pints I had tasted like cheap garbage.

I also unfortunately hated the White Chocolate Bread Pudding NOLA pint I tried... which was super disappointing because I expected to love that flavor. Same main complaint as my gripe with 2nd Street... the base tasted "cheap"... had too much overrun or something. I've heard the NOLA flavor bases are different from flavor to flavor though, so I may have to give them another try next time I'm in New Orleans.

[ErickStevens]

Top tennin it...

1. Chubby Hubby
2. Oatmeal Cookie Chunk
3. Mud Pie (can't find it anywhere anymore, unfortunately)
4. HD White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
5. HD Vanilla Bean Espresso
6. Dublin Mudslide
7. Milk & Cookies
8. New York Super Fudge Chunk
9. Late Night Snack
10. Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz

[AlwaysTryin]

Alright ice cream bros you asked for it. Ill post a pic tomorrow of them all out on the table.
20+ pint chaos
And this isn't even all of it lol

[IMhttp://i1349.photobucket.com/albums/p756/kidkindacool/ice%20creams/null_zps3c35bedf.jpg[/IMG]

What's the use by on the older ones

[usawinston]

1. Cin Buns
2. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
3. Imagine Whirled Peace
4. Oatmeal Cookie Chunk
5. Candy Bar Pie
6. Banana Cream Pie
7. What a Cluster
8. Coffee Caramel Buzz
9. Phish Food
10. Chocolate Peppermint Crunch

[AlwaysTryin]

I'll do a top 10, except I've only had 10

1. Clusterfluff
2. Phish food
3. Fossil fuel
4. Half baked
5. NY fudge chunk
6. Maple tree hugger
7. Peanut brittle
8. Chunky monkey
9. Strawberry cheesecake
10. Choc chip cookie dough

[seamus33]

i have yet to try nutty caramel swirl, candy bar pie, and banana cream pie as well as a few others, so my top ten is subject to change.

i'm in france though and i just smashed a pint of oh my apple pie!. took plenty of pics, but i don't know how to upload from mobile. when i get back, i'll submit some formal reviews to chad which i'm hoping he'll except. let me just give you a prelude and say OMAP! is in my top 5. i've seen numerous flavors i'm excited to try including fairly nuts, HD speculous, and a ton of others.

[sofocused978]

Pulled into Target last night cuz I thought someone in here said B&J was 2/$5 but I was wrong. Wound up paying $3.25/pint for some of dat dere PB World. Got 2 pints. The pint I cracked open last night had huge cookie chunks in it, so damn good.

Can't wait to go back to the casino and get some more Candy Bar Pie.

[Crucifist]

And in your stash...I see that Banana Cream Pie hiding in there. Love that stuff. Almost bought a pint tonight.

Gaaah! How are you guys still finding this? I think I found it once and then never saw it again. It's a serious shame too, because that was one of the best flavors I've had.

Top ten from what I've had?

1. Chubby Hubby
2. Cinnamon Buns
3. Oatmeal Cookie Chunk (replacing this soon since dead flavors aren't allowed on my list)
4. Banana Cream Pie (see above)
5. What a Cluster
6. Peanut Brittle
7. Nutty Caramel Swirl
8. Brownie Chewgooder
9. Phish Food
10. Imagine Whirled Peace

Chocolate Therapy almost squeezed in. Chunky Monkey used to be in there until Banana Cream pie, but since the latter is a limited batch it may yet return (or Banana Split, once I try it).

A couple of hyped flavors that I have not had yet but are on the list and/or in my freezer:

Peanut Butter Cup (yes, really), Candy Bar Pie, Coconut Seven Layer Bar. I have a number of other ones to try as well, just to make sure I sample all of the flavors that interest me. There is a Scoop Shop by me, but their hours are absolutely ridiculous. 9-5 M-F with a 20+ minute drive downtown? It's impossible for me to get there without a holiday or something, and they are often closed for the bigger ones. Maybe I can sneak in on Memorial Day..?

In other news, OnSecondScoop has some impressions on Truffle Trifecta. From the looks of things, it's basically Peanut Butter Cup for the chocolate crowd.

http://www.onsecondscoop.com/2013/05...walgreens.html

[kidkindacool]

I'll have to see what I can do about that. Sounds like it could be an even trade. Let me get in contact with NOLA Ice Cream Co. about getting a pint. Apparently that's their most popular flavor and there's never enough.

And in your stash...I see that Banana Cream Pie hiding in there. Love that stuff. Almost bought a pint tonight.

I would kill for a pint of it. Ive been trying to get ahold of that flavor for such a long time and being up here in the midwest its near impossible. Icecreamsource never has it : /
I...have...to...try..it...man I just have to lol.
Any pint I have, any two pints is yours my friend dry ice it to ya.

I have yet to scoop banana cream pie but I heard its quite good. If you can still find it id say stock up on that stuff!

[kidkindacool]

Wow...you are sooo lucky. All these awesome retired flavors...rocky roadish, dublin mudslide, creme brulee, key lime pie, cannoli, OCC. So jealous. My retired flavor stack is just 6 OCC pints, and 1 cannoli. My freezer isn't big enough I can only hold 12 pints at a time (always completely fill btw).

Summer stock up my friend : ) if your in the Midwest swing on by I gotcha covered

[tf13]

I think B&J Cinnamon Buns gets overrated in this thread.. While it is good, people act like its the best flavor B&J offers and while taste varies person to person, its in the latter part of my top 10

Agree here, while I think it's one of the most rescoopable ones, because it is simple in its composition, yet unique in flavor, I'm not 100% sure it's at top 3 for me, though it's a very very good ice cream. I just had HD Caramel Cone and it was amazing. I'm guessing people would take that over the B&J's Americone?

[Bnizzle163]

Pulled into Target last night cuz I thought someone in here said B&J was 2/$5 but I was wrong. Wound up paying $3.25/pint for some of dat dere PB World. Got 2 pints. The pint I cracked open last night had huge cookie chunks in it, so damn good.

Yeah, I made a stop last night. Talenti is 2/$7, so on a whim I grabbed black raspberry chocolate chip. I wanted to branch out and try something different. I was going to get ssc, but I know where I can get some 2nd street now, so I'm going to try that before I rescoop talenti's version

[Gemuadrken]

Agree here, while I think it's one of the most rescoopable ones, because it is simple in its composition, yet unique in flavor, I'm not 100% sure it's at top 3 for me, though it's a very very good ice cream. I just had HD Caramel Cone and it was amazing. I'm guessing people would take that over the B&J's Americone?

Ill actually agree on the HD caramel cone being amazing. I haven't scooped americone dream though, i can't imagine its better.
,
310 calories a serving though