** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread -- Round 2 **

[DA_MOSS]

To whomever suggested the Sams Club Coffee and Donuts, thank ya Jesus!!!

Wow.... amazing

[EastWarrior10]

Innnnn

[sabol93]

Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie is fantastic, up there with Pumpkin Cheesecake despite the caloric difference. Real cinnamon flavour and the graham cracker swirl is great.

I really like most of Turkey Hill, in my opinion the best of the non premium brands. Anyone else tried their coconut cream pie?

The Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie is by far the best pumpkin pie ice creams I have had. It was the closest thing to having a frozen slice of pumpkin pie. So rich in the cinnamon and graham cracker flavoring. You have me missing this now.

[ErickStevens]

So far the Sam's Choice flavors go as follows:

1. Coffee & Doughnuts
2. Raspberry Cheesecake
3. Blackberry Cobbler

Not sure if I'll be trying any of those other flavors soon as they have a bit too much fat in them.

[seamus33]

So far the Sam's Choice flavors go as follows:

1. Coffee & Doughnuts
2. Raspberry Cheesecake
3. Blackberry Cobbler

Not sure if I'll be trying any of those other flavors soon as they have a bit too much fat in them.

is this a genuine concern of yours? not srs. a little srs.
how much? seems surprising since they seem to be in the mid-calorie range.

[Misctake7]

So far the Sam's Choice flavors go as follows:

1. Coffee & Doughnuts
2. Raspberry Cheesecake
3. Blackberry Cobbler

Not sure if I'll be trying any of those other flavors soon as they have a bit too much fat in them.

Excellent! Trying Coffee & Doughnuts this weekend. Pretty excited with all the hype.

Anyone that isn't a coffee fan like this flavor? Just curious

[AlwaysTryin]

Excellent! Trying Coffee & Doughnuts this weekend. Pretty excited with all the hype.

Anyone that isn't a coffee fan like this flavor? Just curious

I loved cafe au lait beignets and I hate coffee and that's similar (just better lol)

[ErickStevens]

is this a genuine concern of yours? not srs. a little srs.
how much? seems surprising since they seem to be in the mid-calorie range.

Yeah man, I'm dieting. I also like to eat more than 2 servings in a sitting and unlike some *cough* other people in this thread, I'm not willing to starve myself of good sources of dietary fat just so I can eat a bunch of ice cream. Those flavors will still be there in the Fall when I bulk, so I'll try them then.

[knowledgeEpower]

Yeah man, I'm dieting. I also like to eat more than 2 servings in a sitting and unlike some *cough* other people in this thread, I'm not willing to starve myself of good sources of dietary fat just so I can eat a bunch of ice cream. Those flavors will still be there in the Fall when I bulk, so I'll try them then.

Surprised you are going to pass up on trying the Sea Salt Caramel, would have liked to see your thoughts on it, and how it compared to the Talent, HD, and Steve's of the same name.

Sams Choice White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake on the same level as HD White Chocolate Raspberry and B&J Strawberry Cheesecake/Thats My Jam?

Would the Coffee and Donuts crack your top 5/10 overall?

[Jevice]

Just got this in an email from Jeni's

My bank account is ready.

[ErickStevens]

Surprised you are going to pass up on trying the Sea Salt Caramel, would have liked to see your thoughts on it, and how it compared to the Talent, HD, and Steve's of the same name.

Sams Choice White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake on the same level as HD White Chocolate Raspberry and B&J Strawberry Cheesecake/Thats My Jam?

Would the Coffee and Donuts crack your top 5/10 overall?

Maybe I'll give it a shot since everybody seems to be raving.

I'd say it's better than B&J but not HD.

It's very close to bring in my top ten. Cafe Au Lait Beignets is in there though. If you can't find NO flavors then it's a reasonable facsimile.

[Gigi999]

Sooo...if I post skinny cow to aware on what NOT to buy

will I still get negged?

[jubjubrsx]

Sooo...if I post skinny cow to aware on what NOT to buy

will I still get negged?

lol only if its the snickerdoodle one....love that one lol......j/k..everyone is entitled to thier own opinion

[Gigi999]

lol only if its the snickerdoodle one....love that one lol......j/k..everyone is entitled to thier own opinion

Haha I did actually post that one before, but in the middle of a couple BJ's, Private Selection, and Talenti posts It was the only one I would ever have again.

So for anyone with an extra 100 cals to fill, a SC Pink Velvet bar prob isn't the best idea. But the bar itself looks cute haha.

[beatris15]

Sam's Choice Chocolate Peanut Butter: B+ Another solid flavor from Sam's Choice, huge chunks of peanut butter swirl and a decent amount of chocolate pieces also.

[usawinston]

Jeni's flash sale seems decent. Probably overstock. Agree?

[Njustice4all]

Jeni's flash sale seems decent. Probably overstock. Agree?

Definitely... Jeni's is worth the coin.

[easty23]

Ben and Jerry's Milk and Cookies







I really liked it, lots of oreos and chocoalte chip cookies mixed in. I would give it an A

[tbaxley93]

Ben and Jerry's Milk and Cookies


[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/bRfnVxR.jpg[/IMG

[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/AApn04W.jpg[/IMG


I really liked it, lots of oreos and chocoalte chip cookies mixed in. I would give it an A

holy chit

this looks so hnng
I'm gonna have to be on the lookout for this one.

[sofocused978]

I had a great pint of Milk and Cookies last week. It was my second time having it and this time was much better than my first experience.

Tried Sams Choice Coffee and Doughnuts last Monday. I thought it was good. My only complaint is I thought the coffee flavor should have been stronger like that of Talenti's Coffee Chocolate Chip. I didn't really get to have a good sit down with it though. Picked it up while on the road and ate it in the dark on the car ride home.

[jubjubrsx]

Ben and Jerry's Milk and Cookies


[]http://i.imgur.com/bRfnVxR.jpg[/IMG]

[]http://i.imgur.com/AApn04W.jpg[/IMG]


I really liked it, lots of oreos and chocoalte chip cookies mixed in. I would give it an A

lmao would you like some ice cream with those mixins?

[AlwaysTryin]

lmao would you like some ice cream with those mixins?

??? It's not that many mix ins... It's a swirl.

I see you're completely deprived with your weird opinions on amazing flavours and what you think is amazing mix ins lol

[Njustice4all]

Ohhhhhh... The local Whole Foods carries that flavor of B&J religiously... Never tried it but I will be now.

[gbullock32]

Ohhhhhh... The local Whole Foods carries that flavor of B&J religiously... Never tried it but I will be now.

Whole Foods near me has both B&J and Graeters in stock, great place; needs 2nd Street though.

[seamus33]

Yeah man, I'm dieting. I also like to eat more than 2 servings in a sitting and unlike some *cough* other people in this thread, I'm not willing to starve myself of good sources of dietary fat just so I can eat a bunch of ice cream. Those flavors will still be there in the Fall when I bulk, so I'll try them then.

i see. thought you were still on that PL's diet haha. happy cutting.

while it's being talked about, i think b&j's milk & cookies is incredibly underrated...

ALSO, has anyone tried the confetti cake blizzard at dq yet? looks promising.

[mussina123]

Homemade Gelado from a local place in my college town

Homemade waffle come with half sea salt caramel half peanut butter (just got put out, incredibly fresh) <3

[jubjubrsx]

Just picked up the Great value birthday cake

Overall not that bad at 140 calories/serving really made me think of pronom23 vanilla cupcake batter protein shake just a touch sweeter with the confetti pieces. Guess I was hoping for cake chunks in it. Wasn't stellar by anymeans. C+

[Crucifist]

i see. thought you were still on that PL's diet haha. happy cutting.

while it's being talked about, i think b&j's milk & cookies is incredibly underrated...

Agreed. I think part of the reason it doesn't get much love is the lame/bland "on pint" description. For a long time I saw it and thought: "Meh. Cookies and Cream." Then I picked up a pint on a huge sale just because it was so cheap. Misjudged for sure.

Whole Foods near me has both B&J and Graeters in stock, great place; needs 2nd Street though.

The company locator for 2nd Street now officially pings one Walmart in my area. If I can clear some more freezer space I'm going to call over and see if there's any truth to that.

[ErickStevens]

i see. thought you were still on that PL's diet hah.

Soon.

[SaganX]

tfw stationed overseas and the only flavors are B&J choc chip cookie dough, americone dream, cherry garcia, pistachio pistachio, phish food and chocolate fudge brownie. Also, HD butter pecan, vanilla swiss almond, coffee, vanilla and chocolate.


A store nearby does have Talenti double dark and Caribbean coconut though. Better than nothing I guess.