Top 5 Quarterbacks of all-time

[papi93]

Of the quarterbacks that I have SEEN play:

1) Montana
2) Elway
3) Favre
4) Marino
5) Manning

Favre, Manning, and Brady have the opportunity to change their positions due to their careers not being finished.

[kethnaab]

elway
marino
montana
farve
P. Manning

Of the quarterbacks that I have SEEN play:

1) Montana
2) Elway
3) Favre
4) Marino
5) Manning

those are my top-5 ever. Honorable mention to Warren Moon,Dan Fouts, and probably Tom Brady soon enough. Honorable honorable mention to Archie Manning, of the 'Ain'ts' fame.



Including guys like Otto Graham, Sammy Baugh, Sonny Jurgensen and even Johnny Unitas is pretty difficult, since the game was so much different and the talent pool was so much more diluted.

[bpb77]

During his Glory years, Favre had a **** load of talented receivers, no Jerry Rice but still...


Sterling Sharpe
Mark Chmura
Antonio Freeman
Andre Rison
Bubba Franks
Robert Brooks (he had some awesome years)

EDIT - Keith Jackson as well.

It takes a complete effort for any great QB to accomplish what teh great ones accomplish. Just sayin...

If I had to win one game; I would pick Joe Montana or Tom Brady as the starter. Hands down.

Don't forget Driver whose been there for 9 years now.

[5x10]

Of the quarterbacks that I have SEEN play:

1) Montana
2) Elway
3) Favre
4) Marino
5) Manning

Favre, Manning, and Brady have the opportunity to change their positions due to their careers not being finished.

x2
brady and elway are interchangable

[papi93]

x2
brady and elway are interchangable

If Brady wins another Super Bowl, I would have to knock Manning off and place him there (maybe even move him up the list farther). That would give Brady four Super Bowl wins, I believe. He could have one the best statistical seasons of all-time if Randy Moss stays healthy.

[Disenfranchised]

Some of you are crazy for not including Elway on your list. There's no way he's out of the top 3.

[SupaDJDiesel]

1. Unitas
2. Manning
3. Marino
4. Favre
5. Elway

[wsuwarrior]

Some of you are crazy for not including Elway on your list. There's no way he's out of the top 3.

I say the same about Favre. What else do these guys have to do to be considered the best of all time? Theyve both won the Super Bowl, they have the numbers, they have the records.....

But people but Fran Tarkenton in their top 5...lmao.

[TheStack]

in no order

montana
marino
brady
favre
manning

then
elway

[GarthVader]

I would even throw Brady on there with all his rings.

Montana definitely has to be number one.



Brady should be top 5 once he retires. He's probably going to have 4 or 5 rings.

Peyton Manning will be up there on day.

for what ive seen in my lifetime... so just 90s forward

1 Steve Young
2 Brett Favre
3 Peyton Manning
4 Tom Brady
5 Either Troy Aikman (cowboys bias) or kurt warner

montana
brady
favre
marino
elway

Some solid lists. Needs updating tho.

[ClevageGobbler]

1. Blitz 2001 Redskins QB
2. Blitz 2001 Redskins QB
3. Blitz 2001 Redskins QB
4. Blitz 2001 Redskins QB
5. Blitz 2001 Redskins QB