֍ ֍ ֍ ≡ ≡ Ꙭ Misc Cologne Crew XXII: Use Code "FRAGCEL" for 10% Off Ꙭ ≡ ≡ ֍ ֍ ֍

[SouthDakotaBrah]

I prefer Haltane and Percival over almost any PDM other than Layton. I grabbed a large sampler that will last me for a few years at least, and the ones I loved, I noted. They did not have any of the variants as a sampler.

I haven't tried those ones yet brah, but both pique my curiosity (sedley and greenley as well for the summer)

sotn - prada black. sephora has 20% off coupon for everything but chanel of course. what to buy

not sure brah, let me know if you find anything good. Foreverlux usually has the same thing for cheaper even with the sephora 20% off code so be sure to check there too


bought a 100ml of Chanel Chance Eau Tendre for my gf and a 100mL of Versace Eros Pour Femme EDT for my mom (srs) for Christmas

[OT2000]

^^ Sedley and Greenley suck imo

That’s not the opinion here though. But they do.

Herod sucks as well.

Inb4 negged

[sloop]

^^ Sedley and Greenley suck imo

That’s not the opinion here though. But they do.

Herod sucks as well.

Inb4 negged

Herod sucks?!

All in favor of voting this blasphemous ph@git out of the thread say I ......

[dj006xx]

I haven't tried those ones yet brah, but both pique my curiosity (sedley and greenley as well for the summer)


not sure brah, let me know if you find anything good. Foreverlux usually has the same thing for cheaper even with the sephora 20% off code so be sure to check there too


bought a 100ml of Chanel Chance Eau Tendre for my gf and a 100mL of Versace Eros Pour Femme EDT for my mom (srs) for Christmas

the kilians IMO are probably the best buy

https://www.sephora.com/product/kili...475120:product

https://www.sephora.com/product/mini...ry-set-P503705

i may get the 2nd link since i didnt try most of those. Maybe a prada as well.

[IronCharles]

^^ Sedley and Greenley suck imo

That’s not the opinion here though. But they do.

Herod sucks as well.

Inb4 negged

IMO Pegasus > Carlisle > Herod > the rest of PdM.

Haven't tried any exclusif, or Haltane. Not a big oud fan, although one of the reasons I like PdM is their lack of funky stank notes in their fragrances.

[OT2000]

IMO Pegasus > Carlisle > Herod > the rest of PdM.

Haven't tried any exclusif, or Haltane. Not a big oud fan, although one of the reasons I like PdM is their lack of funky stank notes in their fragrances.

For me it’s Haltane > Layton > Percival > no chance of me buying the others.



SOTD: Fresh bottle of BDC Parfum courtesy of Macys who allowed the discount

[sloop]

Welcome back fgts


SOTD : Sausage EDP

[Coal Man]

Saw in my mod report that a few miscers flagged a ****ot in here for saying Herod sucked.

[OT2000]

Herod is too smoky and I don’t care for most tobacco fragrances. And the vanilla isn’t like the creamy vanilla in Layton that makes that one shine. It’s just an odd fragrance that’s a little busy.

[IronCharles]

Herod is too smoky

You don't like smoke? I think it's an awesome note.

This is the smokiest fragrance you will ever smell. One of the notes is "burnt match," Lol. Top 5 for me.

[OT2000]

You don't like smoke? I think it's an awesome note.

This is the smokiest fragrance you will ever smell. One of the notes is "burnt match," Lol. Top 5 for me.

A hint of smoke like what is in several Tom Fords or even Valentino Uomo is fine although it’s my least favorite note in them. Just not my jam.

I couldn’t even sample one with a note like burnt match. I mean, wtf is that? Never even heard of that kind of scent.

[Coal Man]

Today I learned Herod is smoky.

Meanwhile I wear it sometimes in the daytime here in the Caribbean. Buncha limp nosed fragcels ITT.

[IronCharles]

A hint of smoke like what is in several Tom Fords or even Valentino Uomo is fine although it’s my least favorite note in them. Just not my jam.

I couldn’t even sample one with a note like burnt match. I mean, wtf is that? Never even heard of that kind of scent.

It's actually a gourmand, smells like burnt caramel. Kind of like roasting s'mores over a campfire, only with caramel instead of chocolate. It's also a cardamom bomb, like La Nuit De L'Homme.

https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/...own-64644.html

Today I learned Herod is smoky.

Agreed, I never noticed any smoke in Herod, either. Not everyone's nose works the same way, I suppose.

[dj006xx]

Lawd what am I reading in this thread

Sotn - sausage elixir

[sloop]

In b4 strong leather notes in Acqva Viva

[xLostxAngelx]

Kilian's fragrances tend to have a maturing time.

It's like Pure Tonka at first, only intensely linear and natural. Once it starts to mature, the tonka blends down some.

Creed Viking yesterday.

Today I'm not feeling it.

[dj006xx]

In b4 strong leather notes in Acqva Viva

Charles

[IronCharles]

SOTD: Replica - At The Barber's.

Charles

Nah, AV is just lemons and cypress. If somebody smells leather in it, they are probably smelling that leather strap on their BF just pulled out and went ATM.

[darkninja67]

SOTM: Profumum Roma - Patchouly

4 sprays for the bitter cold air. Not a bad patch scent but I think Jovoy is pretty much the best out there for that note.


https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/...ouly-3892.html

[sloop]

SOTD : Gallagher - Wicked Good

[Coal Man]

Sotd: one of my favorite oud scents, Prada L'homme

[twovalvekid]

Who tf reported for the herod hate? In for negs.

SOTD: RWA.

[sloop]

Sotd: one of my favorite oud scents, Prada L'homme

You fkn savage

[SouthDakotaBrah]

SOTD: Spicebomb Extreme

^^ Sedley and Greenley suck imo

That’s not the opinion here though. But they do.

Herod sucks as well.

Inb4 negged

Got a 10ml of Herod on the way, as well as 30mL of Sedley (srs). I like having a travel bottle of fresh fragrances for when I travel to warm/tropical areas so hoping i like the Sedley and it can be my warm weather freshie for traveling (plus maybe a 125mL for at home if I like it enough, will update once I get it, as well as thoughts on Herod)

the kilians IMO are probably the best buy

https://www.sephora.com/product/kili...475120:product

https://www.sephora.com/product/mini...ry-set-P503705

i may get the 2nd link since i didnt try most of those. Maybe a prada as well.

Interesting brah, will calculate the $/ml and see if I want to buy one of these sets vs. buying decants from the ******** groups. Haven't tried any Kilians yet

IMO Pegasus > Carlisle > Herod > the rest of PdM.

Haven't tried any exclusif, or Haltane. Not a big oud fan, although one of the reasons I like PdM is their lack of funky stank notes in their fragrances.

Haven't tried Haltane or Carlisle yet either. I do like Pegasus although I struggle with where/when to wear it. I think I like Layton more for most fall/winter scenarios, thinking Pegasus might be a good spring/summer daytime scent when meeting up with friends at a coffee shop or restaurant or something, but not forward/aggressive enough for going out at night? Not sure brahs, curious to hear opinions on when Pegasus works best. I have a 125mL of it now (srs) really impressed with the longevity and overall quality of it honestly. It remains a slight fresh/clean/soapy vibe while having a strong, sweet, powdery gourmand base. The sillage is amazing IMO, and the metallic note (from the heliotrope) is very interesting the way it somewhat lingers

[darkninja67]

Haven't tried Haltane or Carlisle yet either.s

Do not try Carlisle

[twovalvekid]

Never got smoke in Herod crew.

[IronCharles]

SOTD: Givenchy Gentlemen Only.

Do not try Carlisle

Unless you like apple pie.

[SouthDakotaBrah]

Do not try Carlisle

Unless you like apple pie.

How does it compare to Layton

[darkninja67]

How does it compare to Layton

Carlisle is like Herod and Layton had a baby. So fuking good.

[OT2000]

SOTD: AF Drooling in Love

This is full on powdery musky sweet vanilla with some floral notes. Absolutely feminine leaning. My wife was still sleeping when I left this morning …so I am hoping she doesn’t think I was with a woman instead of working. I sure smell like one.

I don’t get how no one even gets a hint of smoke in Herod. I mean ****, it’s even listed as a smoky vanilla type scent on the PDM website.