Trade Opinions

[MuscleSouth]

Currently I'm in a 0.5 PPR 10 man league, I've just been offered a trade of Najee Harris and Darrell Henderson for Dalvin Cook. Trying to decide if this is a good trade for me or not since I am light on running backs or if I should counter this guy. My roster is as follows:

Tom Brady
Deandre Hopkins
Cooper Kupp
Dalvin Cook
Gus Edwards
Darren Waller
Julio Jones
Tyler Boyd
James Conner
Noah Fant
Matt Ryan
Jonnu Smith
Cole Beasley
Mason Crosby
San Francisco

His roster is:
Russell Wilson
Mike Evans
DJ Chark
Saquon Barkley
Najee Harris
Miles Sanders
D'Andre Swift
Leonard Fournette
Darrell Henderson
AJ Dillon
Devin Singletary
JUJU Smith-Schuster
Rashaad Penny
A.J. Green
Cordarelle Patterson

He currently has no TE, K or DEF. This started when I offered him Noah Fant for Miles Sanders which he rejected and countered with the above mentioned offer.

[WHChampion]

No way I'd take that.

Maybe offer him Fant + Boyd for Henderson.

I'd drop Beasley and Ryan for whatever the best backup RBs are on waivers because you never know who will end up being a starter at some point. Could also probably drop Jonnu since you don't need to roster multiple tight ends when you have Waller.

[Murph0408]

no, i'm not doing that before kickoff. that's ridiculous. sure maybe down the road you're kicking yourself for passing but it's way too early to hand over the 2nd overall pick to a guy for this RB2 and his arguable RB3/4.

[MuscleSouth]

No way I'd take that.

Maybe offer him Fant + Boyd for Henderson.

I'd drop Beasley and Ryan for whatever the best backup RBs are on waivers because you never know who will end up being a starter at some point. Could also probably drop Jonnu since you don't need to roster multiple tight ends when you have Waller.

no, i'm not doing that before kickoff. that's ridiculous. sure maybe down the road you're kicking yourself for passing but it's way too early to hand over the 2nd overall pick to a guy for this RB2 and his arguable RB3/4.

I was thinking the same thing, took Cook at #2 after CMC went #1. Seems like this guy is hoarding RB's right now for some reason but he'll have to make 3 drops at some point. I considered offering Cook for Barkely and Harris or Evans but Barkley's injury history scares me.

[dyee4613]

Cook for Henderson, Sanders, and Evans seems like a good counter.