Peyton Manning, not Tom Brady, is actually the GOAT, according to PFR's HoF metrics

[PITA21]

Brady is not the GOAT when it comes to a Pro Football Reference metric. The website created a "Hall of Fame Monitor" in 2019 that was designed to estimate a player's chances at being inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Using approximate value, Pro Bowls, All-Pros, championships and other statistical milestones, the site created a point system to determine the pecking order at each position.

At quarterback, Peyton Manning holds the top spot with 258 points.

https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/p...onitor-metric/


Pretty much nails it on the head. I’ve been saying this a long time when you add context to Bradys career there are a few factors to consider

-multiple cheating scandals asterisking at least his 4 Super Bowl titles

-Mostly ran a turn key operation in Tampa forcing them to blow out the cap to create a mega team to carry him to the superbowl

-Refs combined with the Falcons gifted a Super Bowl to Brady

That leaves him with one legitimate run against the Rams, where he had to do absolutely nothing but show up to win with Jared goof on the other team

His hallmark is 2 losses to mediocre giants team

The guy really has been the qb born with a horseshoe up his ass to have won more than 2 Super Bowls. The luckiest guy in history. He never had the command and ability to carve up a defense like Manning did, mainly because he lacked the ability to audible effectively at the line and entirely relied on holding the ball or dinking and dunking. Whenever he was slightly rattled in the pocket with some consistency he choked hard.

I commend PFT for pointing out that Manning is ranked higher than Brady on the merits

[ohiostate124]

Oh stfu.

[HandstandPushup]

https://www.instagram.com/p/CLZ_O8tg...=1w5qrzjtya3lx

[PITA21]

Oh stfu.

Refer to sig

[PITA21]

https://www.instagram.com/p/CLZ_O8tg...=1w5qrzjtya3lx

Seems a bit insecure

[Tyler2106]

While Brady has five more rings than Manning, Manning's two titles, five MVP awards (compared to Brady's three) and seven All-Pro selections (compared to three for Brady) gives him a slight edge for the time being.

LMAO, definitely makes Manning better than Brady. Too bad I can't neg OP.

[PITA21]

LMAO, definitely makes Manning better than Brady. Too bad I can't neg OP.

Triggered, refer to sig

[Tyler2106]

Triggered, refer to sig

Lol not triggered at all. Just think you're an idiot.

[Belome]

Damn Montana gona be mad when he sees they found some back woods ranking system that puts him at #6.

I also chuckled at the tight end list...

All in all I give these lists a 3/10 only because I laughed.

[ohiostate124]

Refer to sig

Go make some more threads whining about being red

[PITA21]

Go make some more threads whining about being red

Spoiler!

refer to sig

[PITA21]

Lol not triggered at all. Just think you're an idiot.

I think the real problem is you or anyone else here can’t bother to debate the points I raise. It takes deep thought and consideration to look at the whole picture instead of just evaluating it on a surface level. I’m not sure if it’s because you can’t refute the legitimate points I have raised, you’re too lazy to do so or you lack the intellectual capacity to even attempt to. I suspect it’s a combination of all 3 areas so as common place you and the others at your same level resolve to communal insults of a elementary level.

[ohiostate124]

Brady 11-6 h2h against Manning

[PITA21]

Brady 11-6 h2h against Manning

The low level qualifier and low info sports fan armchair evaluators opinion is that this stat actually means something. Contrary to popular belief quarterbacks don’t throw balls at each other to decide who wins. There are 52 other players on the roster if you didn’t know. For the same reason Brady’s 7 Super Bowl wins are not all that impressive when given proper context and evaluation.

[ohiostate124]

The low level qualifier and low info sports fan armchair evaluators opinion is that this stat actually means something. Contrary to popular belief quarterbacks don’t throw balls at each other to decide who wins. There are 52 other players on the roster if you didn’t know. For the same reason Brady’s 7 Super Bowl wins are not all that impressive when given proper context and evaluation.

Facts don’t care about red trolls feelings

Brady >>>>>> Manning

[DarthCholo]

Manning was pretty dam good. A coach on the field and a dam surgeon finding holes in defences. But those 7 damn rings can't be trumped.

[SmashinYoungVag]

Manning was pretty dam good. A coach on the field and a dam surgeon finding holes in defences. But those 7 damn rings can't be trumped.

Is bill Russell the goat? How bout yogi Berra?

Using a team metric to determine who the best individual is is absolutely retarded. Especially in football, the ultimate team sport. As great as anyone quarterback is they’re only on the field half the game.

[outfoxxed]

Being a bargain bin QB means you get to play with elite talent. NFL teams only get so much cap space every year so if they wanna splurge on the 400 dollar wagyu beef, they gotta skimp on the wine.

Tommy boy is a AAA Angus beef steak dry aged for 28 days. He's no wagyu, but if you go with him, you can splurge on that 400 dollar bottle of wine or get a half lobster with your meal

NFL has always been about price to performance, not sheer performance. Tommy boy is literally the kirkland QB in the NFL. He's a lexus. He's amazing value but he's not the best

[outfoxxed]

Brady 11-6 h2h against Manning

what's his h2h playoff record vs manning?

[homersexual]

No one cares about regular season stats. What's NFL MVP awards done for Rodgers and Manning? Why do you think players are resting during regular season nowadays? All that matters is postseason glory and Brady has it in abundance cause he's clutch.

[DarthCholo]

If you ask brady if he'd trade the championships for better stats he'd turn it down.

Ask peyton for to trade stats for rings he'd take you up.

[nn586]

OP is a dumb bitch

[BrickEX]

Lol at leftist red being red with the drivel. Eat sh*t *******

[HoganIsGOAT]

Is bill Russell the goat?

There were 10 teams in the league when Bill Russell won 11 NBA championships.

[HoganIsGOAT]

what's his h2h playoff record vs manning?

7 Super Bowls to 2. Any questions?

[Cartiac]

If you ever accomplished anything in your life you would realize needing to list so many excuses in an attempt to call someone a loser, you have made it clear how big of a loser you are.

[PITA21]

Facts don’t care about red trolls feelings

Brady >>>>>> Manning

Once again, in plain sight you have absolutely no basis for an argument, supporting evidence or rebuttal to my points

just a sad ohiostate fan that knows nothing about football and loser voter (for trump)

SAD!

[Swept]

7 all pro in 17 years
3 all pro in 20 years

Pretty simple math.



Brady is this generation Terry Bradshaw

[TyGuy505]

7 Super Bowls 5 super bowl mvps says otherwise but you do you

[PITA21]

I commend you all who have repped me in agreement. We must not bow to the brady mob. They have still refused to refuse or counteract any of my analysis other than posting superbowl wins. A argument I have already thoroughly debunked and destroyed.