Has there been a more overrated QB over the past 15 years than Philip Rivers?

[JewishSuperHero]

Flacco? Ryan? Eli? Brees?

[lsiberian]

You have to be rated highly to be overrated OP.

[LukeS1]

Probably Roethilsberger tbh

[JewishSuperHero]

You have to be rated highly to be overrated OP.

The dude is always on top 10 QB lists. And the Chargers were always listed as AFC dark horses his entire time there.

[drvillain]

Flacco? Ryan? Eli? Brees?

All 4 of these Qbs have something in common that Rivers doesn't

[Droopdx]

Rivers is a HOFer. Hasn’t been at his best in some time so most casuals like yourself will just remember his bad games

[Tyler2106]

I'm not sure I understand how a future HOF QB is overrated...?

[Tyler2106]

All 4 of these Qbs have something in common that Rivers doesn't

Hard to win Super Bowls when his entire career he had to compete against Peyton Manning and Tom Brady...and a few good years from Big Ben.

[wildchild11]

This is unfair to Rivers. When he was good, he was elite. The days where it was him and Ladanian, they could have easily won it all. He was always failed by defenses or coaching.

[Miked1978]

I dont think he was ever overrated. To me fans have always ranked him in the middle of the pack in regards to good QBs in the league.

[lsiberian]

This is unfair to Rivers. When he was good, he was elite. The days where it was him and Ladanian, they could have easily won it all. He was always failed by defenses or coaching.

Or running into Peyton/Brady/Prime Big Ben. He made the playoffs and pro bowl several years.

[Jaydawg08]

Rivers is a HOFer. Hasn’t been at his best in some time so most casuals like yourself will just remember his bad games

No he isn't. He's in the Hall of Very Good. The HOF should be reserved for the Rodgers, Brees, Brady level.

[tripod29]

The most over rated QB ever was Rob Griffen .......then it was proven he was over rated.

[SmashinYoungVag]

Eli Manning

[SmashinYoungVag]

No he isn't. He's in the Hall of Very Good. The HOF should be reserved for the Rodgers, Brees, Brady level.

Actually agree with this. How many post 2000s quarterbacks get in

Peyton, brees, Rodgers, Brady. Warner and favre are already in. Favre was half 90s but still.

So that’s 6. Ben is a shoe in. And then you got rivers and Eli. Which would be 9.

9 quarter backs from the 2000-2010 era is ridiculous.

[Droopdx]

I would respond to JayDawg, but I already said in another thread I will not interact with him anymore, because he has that virgin school shooter vibe.

[Swept]

Rivers>>>>>>>>Ryan, Eli, Ben, Brees


You cucks wouldn’t begin to understand the chit Rivers had to deal with.

Brb no home field advantage
Brb the best WR he ever played with was Vincent Jackson who they let go in his prime
Brb chit coach after chit coach, who the fuk is gonna win anything with Norv Turner, Mike McCoy, Anthony Lynn??
Brb the chargers were cursed with injuries, from 11-17 led the nfl in IR
Brb horrible pass blocking and special teams on a yearly basis.


Brees got benched on those same chargers team. And never put up those monster numbers until he got with Payton

Rivers and Peyton are the only two QBs that actually called their own plays. Rivers also was a gunslinging beast not a dink and dunk cuck









Respect Beast Rivers

[chaunce54]

Kaepernick.

[DynamicDot]

This is unfair to Rivers. When he was good, he was elite. The days where it was him and Ladanian, they could have easily won it all. He was always failed by defenses or coaching.

Yep.

Rivers is a HOFer. Hasn’t been at his best in some time so most casuals like yourself will just remember his bad games

Unfortunately, no. If he had a ring he would be a lock but without a ring he doesn't have anything to offer other than volume stats.

He was the best QB of the 2004 Class though and I say this as a Giants fan who had Eli.

[YoungMetro24]

All 4 of these Qbs have something in common that Rivers doesn't

They have less than 6 kids?

[ohiostate124]

They have less than 6 kids?

I think Phil is up to 9 now

[Droopdx]

Yep.



Unfortunately, no. If he had a ring he would be a lock but without a ring he doesn't have anything to offer other than volume stats.

He was the best QB of the 2004 Class though and I say this as a Giants fan who had Eli.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.esp...3fplatform=amp

Nfl experts and former players disagree with your low IQ babble

[DynamicDot]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.esp...3fplatform=amp

Nfl experts and former players disagree with your low IQ babble

Wow I am pretty surprised it was a unanimous yes. I want him to make the HOF, but I just don't expect him to based on the criteria.

Guess we'll see. I don't think any of the QBs in 2004 will be first ballot though.

[Tyler2106]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.esp...3fplatform=amp

Nfl experts and former players disagree with your low IQ babble

Anyone who says he shouldn't be in the HOF probably never paid attention to his outside of fantasy football stats.

[LobsterRageFist]

I can guaranteed that no QB in the Hall of Fame ever threw 4 INTs in the 4th quarter of a 1 score game:

https://www.pro-football-reference.c...all_vis_drives

[DynamicDot]

Anyone who says he shouldn't be in the HOF probably never paid attention to his outside of fantasy football stats.

I mean he has zero accolades unless you consider pro-bowls to be one. Zero all-pro teams and zero rings, personally wonder if either Big Ben or Eli are HOFers without rings. Eli is a no and Ben is also probably a no.

If this was a basketball HOF he would be 1st ballot lock, but then again Jay Cutler would probably be a HOFer in basketball HOF standards.

[Jaydawg08]

Is Matt Ryan a HOFer? He has a better case for it than Phillip Rivers imo.

[SmashinYoungVag]

I mean he has zero accolades unless you consider pro-bowls to be one. Zero all-pro teams and zero rings, personally wonder if either Big Ben or Eli are HOFers without rings. Eli is a no and Ben is also probably a no.

If this was a basketball HOF he would be 1st ballot lock, but then again Jay Cutler would probably be a HOFer in basketball HOF standards.

Agreed. Not one all pro should disqualify you from the hall

Boomer and McNair won mvp and made a super bowl. Culpepper had a 1st and 2nd team all pro. None are in the hall.

[AMeyer9]

He's always been a top 15 QB, but never a top 5. Good not great. He'll get in the HoF just because of his longevity.

[Murph0408]

a good compiler and i know he's going to the Hall. but never that impressed w/ him. not a top guy, not elite.

i put him with Tony Romo. and i loved Romo. real good players. Rivers hung around longer. Stafford will end up like this, the way he's going.