Food Faceoff: Trick or Treat Semis

[boo99]

Happy Halloween to all.


These 15 Halloween candies all received 8 or more votes this week.


Please choose up to 6 that you like:



Kit Kat


Reese's PB Cups


Snickers


3 Musketeers


Butterfinger


Milky Way


Nestle Crunch


Starburst

[boo99]

100 Grand


Almond Joy


Krackel


Mr. Goodbar


Baby Ruth


Heath Bar


Milk Duds

[AdamWW]

Kit Kat
Reese's PB Cups
Snickers
Butterfinger
Almond Joy
Milk Duds


Was tough between 3-musk and milk duds ;o)

[bigjohncurler]

Reese’s PB Cups
Kit Kat
Milk Duds
Nestle Crunch
Mr. Goodbar
Starburst

[CommitmentRulz]

Reese's PB Cups
Snickers
Butterfinger
Almond Joy
Heath Bar
Milky Way

[paulinkansas]

Reeses
Snickers
Butterfinger
Crunch
Krackel
Goodbar

I do drug screens at a medical clinic. People pee in a cup and I tear off a label to see the results. If they are negative, I give them a choice of a mini candy bar. Most of which are in this post. If they are non-negative, I say "No candy for you" and send them out of the clinic back into the parking lot.

[boo99]

If they are non-negative, I say "No candy for you" and send them out of the clinic back into the parking lot.

Good. They had enough candy already. lol

[Omni]

Reeses PB Cup
Snickers
KitKat
Butterfinger
Goodbar
Heath

[Strawng]

Kit Kat
Reese's PB Cups
Snickers
Butterfinger
Almond Joy
Milk Duds


Was tough between 3-musk and milk duds ;o)

This. I REALLY struggled with this one tho, and I spent an unhealthy amount of time contemplating my choices. For me, it was tough between Milk Duds/3 Musketeers & Snickers/Milky Way/Heath Bar. Milk Duds just baaaaaarely edged out 3 Musketeers for me cuz overall they just have a slightly more interesting flavor profile and mouthfeel than 3-Musk, delicious though they are. I love Milky Ways, but only the fun size. Eating an entire bar would be overbearing. I also happen to love Heath bars. They're amazing crunched up and mixed into things like ice cream or frozen yogurt, but they're too hard to eat as a stand-alone experience. Snickers edges these two out by being very edible as a full or king size candy bar without as much texture and flavor fatigue. I've had many a full size Snickers, but few if any of the other 2 contenders.

[AdamWW]

This. I REALLY struggled with this one tho, and I spent an unhealthy amount of time contemplating my choices. For me, it was tough between Milk Duds/3 Musketeers & Snickers/Milky Way/Heath Bar. Milk Duds just baaaaaarely edged out 3 Musketeers for me cuz overall they just have a slightly more interesting flavor profile and mouthfeel than 3-Musk, delicious though they are. I love Milky Ways, but only the fun size. Eating an entire bar would be overbearing. I also happen to love Heath bars. They're amazing crunched up and mixed into things like ice cream or frozen yogurt, but they're too hard to eat as a stand-alone experience. Snickers edges these two out by being very edible as a full or king size candy bar without as much texture and flavor fatigue. I've had many a full size Snickers, but few if any of the other 2 contenders.

I literally pondered the exact same strengths/weaknesses between ALL those bars... lol

Heath: great as a topping but a whole bar wouldn’t be as appealing

3 Musketeers... really nice but a basic flavor profile and the texture is homogeneous

Milky Way is a great bar but, as you said, it’s more a fun size only one because unlike snickers just doesn’t have the crunch OR the nuts

Milk duds... I mean... I love caramel, and also they last a long time as a snack... childhood memories as a chubby teenager dumping them on heart-attack inducing popcorn... they pulled ahead

[desslok]

Kit kat
Reeses pb cups
Snickers
Hundred grand
Baby ruth
Nestle crunch

[snailsrus]

Chocolate so much chocolate and no white chocolate even

Starburst

Was hoping for zero bars at least

[TearsOfIce]

Kit Kat
Reese's PB Cups
Snickers
Butterfinger
Milky Way
Nestle Crunch

[Budjola]

Kit Kat
Reese's PB Cups
Snickers
Milky Way
Almond Joy
Baby Ruth

[aloosecannon]

Milky Way
100 Grand
Nestle Crunch
Almond Joy
Milk Duds
3 Musketeers

[hardyboysare]

Heath Bar
Kit Kat
Nestle Crunch
Milky Way
Snickers
Reese's PB Cups

[gbullock32]

Kit Kat
Reese's PB Cups
Snickers
Butterfinger
Almond Joy
Baby Ruth

[Strawng]

I literally pondered the exact same strengths/weaknesses between ALL those bars... lol

Heath: great as a topping but a whole bar wouldn’t be as appealing

3 Musketeers... really nice but a basic flavor profile and the texture is homogeneous

Milky Way is a great bar but, as you said, it’s more a fun size only one because unlike snickers just doesn’t have the crunch OR the nuts

Milk duds... I mean... I love caramel, and also they last a long time as a snack... childhood memories as a chubby teenager dumping them on heart-attack inducing popcorn... they pulled ahead

Mindblown how much overlap we have with these things! With how long this one took me to reason out, I was thinking we'd disagree. Sure enough though, we somehow had the same damn thought process.

Also, not only that, but Milk Duds in popcorn were one of my favorite things on Earth as a kid who ate like chit. The salty sweet combo was sofa king HNNNG! I didn't know anyone else that did that! I don't ever eat move theatre popcorn anymore cuz I can't really digest all that damn butter, but some homemade kettle corn with Milk Duds and some sea salt sounds absolutely fire.

[AdamWW]

Mindblown how much overlap we have with these things! With how long this one took me to reason out, I was thinking we'd disagree. Sure enough though, we somehow had the same damn thought process.

Also, not only that, but Milk Duds in popcorn were one of my favorite things on Earth as a kid who ate like chit. The salty sweet combo was sofa king HNNNG! I didn't know anyone else that did that! I don't ever eat move theatre popcorn anymore cuz I can't really digest all that damn butter, but some homemade kettle corn with Milk Duds and some sea salt sounds absolutely fire.

You know its funny, before the lockdown stuff started, I went to a movie with friends and they got popcorn with no butter... and it honestly tasted like it was already buttered...

Given how strong that flavor was WITHOUT the extra topping, I cannot imagine how gross it'd be WITH added fake butter... even with the built-in stuff, it was basically too much.

I don't know how I lived passed age 17... hah!

[Strawng]

You know its funny, before the lockdown stuff started, I went to a movie with friends and they got popcorn with no butter... and it honestly tasted like it was already buttered...

Given how strong that flavor was WITHOUT the extra topping, I cannot imagine how gross it'd be WITH added fake butter... even with the built-in stuff, it was basically too much.

I don't know how I lived passed age 17... hah!

Same. I'd DRENCH my popcorn in that liquid "butter" at that machine after they buttered it too. I always left with the WORST stomachache.

[AdamWW]

Same. I'd DRENCH my popcorn in that liquid "butter" at that machine after they buttered it too. I always left with the WORST stomachache.

Not to mention i'd honestly smell like popcorn for days after... I can't even imagine what the ingredients were before the FDA 'cleaned up' some of these things. I mean it's still horrible, but even moreso then im sure.