Official Fantasy Football Sit em or start em thread***

[dirtdickens]

Start Gerhart over Brown, AP may not even play at all and if he does it will be only a few touches.

Gerhart averaged 90+ yards per game last year filling in for AP and has Jags as the matchup.

Im a Gerhart owner and Im not strating him this week only because AP is the game time decision. Im not putting him in and then finding out 3 minutes before kickoff that AP is playing-even in a limited role. Thats the F'n worst.

[dcabral80]

What do you guys think about Torrey Smith vs Cin or Peyton Hillis vs Atl for my flex spot? I'm leaning towards Smith right now because I'm unsure of how the carries will be distributed between Hillis and Charles, but I've got this weird feeling Hillis is gonna punch a couple in.

[rsnnh12]

Both of those are equals in this situation. But, since you have Cjarles going you have to play Washington in case of a shutout in KC where you are left holding two starters. I like both your options.

Thanks for the help. That's what I was leaning too. The Pats secondary isn't great and they are okay with giving up lots of yards and catches underneath once they have a nice lead. Hopefully Washington can take advantage.

Repped

[MCrow]

Im a Gerhart owner and Im not strating him this week only because AP is the game time decision. Im not putting him in and then finding out 3 minutes before kickoff that AP is playing-even in a limited role. Thats the F'n worst.

AP won't get very many carries (Maybe 3-4), Gerhart is going to be the 3rd down back this year so until AP is back he's going to get 15+ touches per game. I'm not sure why people are so scared of AP right now, there'd absolutely no faurking way that he plays enough week 1 to really affect Gerhart's numbers.

[solidus86]

Eric Decker vs CHI or Steve Johnson at NYJ?

Johnson has had success against Revis last season with 11 catches for 159 and a TD over two games. Decker, I believe, will be Manning's number 1 target this season in Denver and he put up good numbers last season with garbage signal callers. Wat do? My other receiver is Steve Smith if it matters.

[rsnnh12]

Eric Decker vs CHI or Steve Johnson at NYJ?

Johnson has had success against Revis last season with 11 catches for 159 and a TD over two games. Decker, I believe, will be Manning's number 1 target this season in Denver and he put up good numbers last season with garbage signal callers. Wat do? My other receiver is Steve Smith if it matters.

PPR? I think I'd roll with Decker, just because Revis scares the **** out of me. The Bills shouldn't need to throw too much because they shouldn't be playing catch up, and the Broncos could very easily have to air it out against the Steelers D.

I'd lean Decker, and if its PPR I'd start Decker no question

[adamfm8]

Two dilemmas:

Peyton or Eli Manning?

T. Gerhart or B. Wells?

[MCrow]

Eric Decker vs CHI or Steve Johnson at NYJ?

Johnson has had success against Revis last season with 11 catches for 159 and a TD over two games. Decker, I believe, will be Manning's number 1 target this season in Denver and he put up good numbers last season with garbage signal callers. Wat do? My other receiver is Steve Smith if it matters.

Tough call. Decker is the biggest boom or bust on the list. Decker could blow up for huge numbers week 1 but we're talking a lot of new moving parts there as well. Johnson and Smith are safer picks.

If you feel like your team is the underdog this week you might take Decker and hope he blows up. Otherwise I'd go with Smith as he typically has big week 1 games. Since becoming a full time starter Steve Smith (Carolina) most years he goes 100+ yards, 1+ TD in the opener.

[MCrow]

Two dilemmas:

Peyton or Eli Manning?

Eli typically is garbage week 1.

I would probably go Peyton this week but don't like either for week 1.

T. Gerhart or B. Wells?

I'd go Gerhart. Wells only had 2 100+ yard games last year and is facing a very good defense week 1.

Gerhart will probably go over 100 yards vs the Jags, AP will not get more than a hand full of touches, Gerhart will get 15+. When he gets 12+ touches he'll get 90+ yards rushing and 30+ yards recieving and a TD or two when looking at what he did last year filling in for AP.

[adamfm8]

Eli typically is garbage week 1.

I would probably go Peyton this week but don't like either for week 1.



I'd go Gerhart. Wells only had 2 100+ yard games last year and is facing a very good defense week 1.

Gerhart will probably go over 100 yards vs the Jags, AP will not get more than a hand full of touches, Gerhart will get 15+. When he gets 12+ touches he'll get 90+ yards rushing and 30+ yards recieving and a TD or two when looking at what he did last year filling in for AP.

Thanks man, that's how I had it so far. I've got a good feeling about Peyton

[Rosco75]

I am trying to decide who to start in my RB positions. I am at a loss with so much controversy over AP, and because I have such strong supporter RB's (Like rodgers) Did I make the reight choice in starting D-willy over AP for week 1? I am in a 12 man leauge H2H points.
Here is my team and bench:

[dougefresh93]

Two dilemmas:

Peyton or Eli Manning?

T. Gerhart or B. Wells?

Eli and Gerhart... IMO

[Rosco75]

Edits of peace...

[dougefresh93]

royster
spiller
little


ppr league my week 1 flex

who should it be? spiller safest right?

spiller is the safest bet, royster could be the highest scorer if (big if) he is the main RB in WASH. but i'd take spiller. good luck

[dirtdickens]

AP won't get very many carries (Maybe 3-4), Gerhart is going to be the 3rd down back this year so until AP is back he's going to get 15+ touches per game. I'm not sure why people are so scared of AP right now, there'd absolutely no faurking way that he plays enough week 1 to really affect Gerhart's numbers.

Im not scared of AP, but if there are better options you have to take them. Im personally starting Mike Bush over Gerhart because what will happen is both Gerhart and AP are going to get carries this weekend and make eachother useless or we will find out 3 minutes before kickoff.

I personally dont think he plays, but I cant tell people to play Gerhart knowing that AP is still a GTD.

[MCrow]

Im not scared of AP, but if there are better options you have to take them. Im personally starting Mike Bush over Gerhart because what will happen is both Gerhart and AP are going to get carries this weekend and make eachother useless or we will find out 3 minutes before kickoff.

I personally dont think he plays, but I cant tell people to play Gerhart knowing that AP is still a GTD.

AP IS NOT GOING TO GET MORE THAN A FEW CARRIES.

I'm not sure why people can't unsderstand that. The guy has about 50/50 chance even being active, has not touched the ball yet this year outside of practice, and the coaches are very much on the "slow it down AP" mind set. If he even sees the field this week it will be a few carries.

Bush will get many less touches than Gerhart.......book it. Gehart is a starter this week.

[dunit94]

ROMO @ NYG


or

RIVERS @ oakland

(4 pts per td)

[blackberries]

Trent Richardson or Eric Decker for Flex.

Pick 2: Law Firm, Gerhart, Mathews, Jennings
Pick 2: Antonio Brown, White, Austin, Lloyd

[dirtdickens]

royster
spiller
little


ppr league my week 1 flex

who should it be? spiller safest right?

Thats a pure vom train. Spiller is the safest bet, but at this point the safe bet is ionly going to net you measly points, so why not roll the dice with Royster?
I ahrdly ever recommend one fo the WAS RBs, but if your other options are 4 point guys, whats the harm in going all in?

Two dilemmas:

Peyton or Eli Manning?

T. Gerhart or B. Wells?

Eli in a shootout and Gerhart over that walking vagina Beanie Wells.

PPR? I think I'd roll with Decker, just because Revis scares the **** out of me. The Bills shouldn't need to throw too much because they shouldn't be playing catch up, and the Broncos could very easily have to air it out against the Steelers D.

I'd lean Decker, and if its PPR I'd start Decker no question

You dont play anyone not named Clavin, Julio or AJ against Revis, Bailey and Haden. They flat out eliminate WR1s. Go back and look at the numbers, the WRs he has shut completely down over the last 4 years.

Play Decker all day in this one.

[dirtdickens]

AP IS NOT GOING TO GET MORE THAN A FEW CARRIES.

I'm not sure why people can't unsderstand that. The guy has about 50/50 chance even being active, has not touched the ball yet this year outside of practice, and the coaches are very much on the "slow it down AP" mind set. If he even sees the field this week it will be a few carries.

Bush will get many less touches than Gerhart.......book it. Gehart is a starter this week.

How many carries is Gerhart getting?

*Bush will be the GL back against IND = TD

[MCrow]

Trent Richardson or Eric Decker for Flex.

Pick 2: Law Firm, Gerhart, Mathews, Jennings
Pick 2: Antonio Brown, White, Austin, Lloyd

#1- Jennings and Gerhart (Better match up)
#2- White and Brown

[MCrow]

How many carries is Gerhart getting?

*Bush will be the GL back against IND = TD

AP will get 5 total touches tops. Gerhart is the pass catcher of the two and will get almost all 3rd down plays. He will get 90% of all touches by the RBs this week. I would estimate he gets a minimum of 15 touches but could go as high as 20+ if the Vikes get a decent lead.

Bush might punch hope a TD in the game but he'd not going to get **** for yardage. I'd put Bush on about 8 points this week. Gerhart around 16 points. AP might not even score a single point.

[Rosco75]

I am trying to decide who to start in my RB positions. I am at a loss with so much controversy over AP, and because I have such strong supporter RB's (Like rodgers) Did I make the reight choice in starting D-willy over AP for week 1? I am in a 12 man leauge H2H points.
Here is my team and bench:

Bump for answers. Are there any better prospects than D willy that I could / would consider in leu of AP?

[ClaptonDeCheeks]

I'm in a real tough spot right now... who should I start at RB?

also need to drop someone for a kicker. Should it be Jacquizz Rodgers? Thinking of dropping Doug Baldwin for Jon Baldwin/Brandon LaFell too.

[MCrow]

I'm in a real tough spot right now... who should I start at RB?

also need to drop someone for a kicker. Should it be Jacquizz Rodgers? Thinking of dropping Doug Baldwin for Jon Baldwin/Brandon LaFell too.

Start Redman, sit AP, start Jennings this week only.

[MCrow]

I am trying to decide who to start in my RB positions. I am at a loss with so much controversy over AP, and because I have such strong supporter RB's (Like rodgers) Did I make the reight choice in starting D-willy over AP for week 1? I am in a 12 man leauge H2H points.
Here is my team and bench:

Wow....RBs look rough right now.

Williams and Martin are porbably your best two options this week.

[dunit94]

ROMO @ NYG


or

RIVERS @ oakland

(4 pts per td)

bump

[MCrow]

bump

I'd go Rivers this week, Romo going to get smashed this week.

[The Gootz]

PPR 10 team league

Unsure of Richardson in week 1 due to his recent knee scope.

Reps to good responses (include logic)

[dirtdickens]

PPR 10 team league

Unsure of Richardson in week 1 due to his recent knee scope.

Reps to good responses (include logic)

[IMG]http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/aa149/thegootz/FFB2012wk1.jpg[MG]

This your sitting at your optimal lineup. I would look into starting Quizz if it looks like TRich isnt going to go. Like last year, keep an eye on THUR/FRI practice, if he is limited in those then he isnt worth playing.

bump

Dont over think this, NYG DLine is gonna be all over Romo and Rivers will be slinging it on the shtty Raiduhs.