PDA

View Full Version : Where do you rank Joe Flacco?



MrRIP
02-01-2013, 11:48 AM
He's looking for drew brews money in his next contract. I believe there's 10 QBS in the league better than him and should get around top 10 money

youngwolf
02-01-2013, 11:54 AM
not a ravens fan, but i get to watch him every week.

he's just outside the top 10 for me. consistency is an issue.

imhere4tehlulz
02-01-2013, 12:01 PM
2nd Tier QB imo (outside the top 10) Needs to be surrounded with enough talent to be successful.

hardestout89
02-01-2013, 12:04 PM
elite/10

Nocks
02-01-2013, 12:20 PM
None of these tiers are ordered.

God tier
Peyton
Brady
Rodgers

So-close god tier:
Drew Brees

Elite:
Big Ben
Eli

Next in line:
Flacco
Ryan
Wilson
Kaep

RG3 and Luck maybe thrown into the next line group soon.

I think Flacco is maybe 9th-10th in QB rankings. Inconsistent but he's won a game in each postseason. Unlike the top 6 I posted, he isn't a QB who's going to "carry your team". But, he's definitely good enough to win a Super Bowl if he has talent around him... as you see now.

iamgenus
02-01-2013, 12:36 PM
I think Russell Wilson is due for a great career but how exactly are people putting him so high on the list already?

GetBigyo
02-01-2013, 12:40 PM
Rodgers
Brady
Peyton
Brees
Eli
Ben

After that it's pretty much a crapshoot.

brb_ballin
02-01-2013, 12:48 PM
Rodgers
Brady
Peyton
Brees
Eli
Ben

After that it's pretty much a crapshoot.


on spread but exactly this.

top 6 is set in stone.

krogtaar
02-01-2013, 12:50 PM
10-12 range. don't forget the ravens were 22nd in passing YPG this season, flacco has a decent O line and Ray rice to fall back on.

Either way I think Ravens should have gotten a contract done mid season while he was struggling. he's playing like a top 5 QB now.

9inchSub
02-01-2013, 12:56 PM
The only QBs better than him flacco is. Peyton, Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Eli , Ben, (Matt Ryan is good but not sure if better than Flacco..) So only 6 better than him.

But the thing people tend to judge the QB beside, (brady, peyton, brees, rodger) on the current season.

People saying Kaep is a good QB (has not even had 10 starts..) saying Wilson is good (1 season) same with RG3( 1 season not even sure if he come back like AP) Im not saying that any of them are crap but at the same time cant judge until atleast 3 seasons.

Cam Newton last year was in most people top 10 list (top 5 in some cases) look where people rank him now.

Flacco is Elite even if he loses SB cause he will prob be at AFC championship next year.

Coming from a Bills fan//

scotyg
02-01-2013, 01:00 PM
7-10 range for me.

Onita
02-01-2013, 01:03 PM
The only QBs better than him flacco is. Peyton, Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Eli , Ben, (Matt Ryan is good but not sure if better than Flacco..) So only 6 better than him.

But the thing people tend to judge the QB beside, (brady, peyton, brees, rodger) on the current season.

People saying Kaep is a good QB (has not even had 10 starts..) saying Wilson is good (1 season) same with RG3( 1 season not even sure if he come back like AP) Im not saying that any of them are crap but at the same time cant judge until atleast 3 seasons.

Cam Newton last year was in most people top 10 list (top 5 in some cases) look where people rank him now.

Flacco is Elite even if he loses SB cause he will prob be at AFC championship next year.

Coming from a Bills fan//

He's still not elite.

9inchSub
02-01-2013, 01:08 PM
He's still not elite.

If Elite is top 5 then no his not elite since hes the 7-8th best current starting QB.

Onita
02-01-2013, 01:11 PM
If Elite is top 5 then no his not elite since hes the 7-8th best current starting QB.

Where I'm from, if 1/4 of your competition is better than you, you are not elite.

CarpeD1em500
02-01-2013, 01:20 PM
If you honestly would take Big Ben over Joe Flacco this coming Sunday you're out of your damn mind. Dude's prime was a few years ago. He's not there anymore. Joe is. Deal with it.


Joe Flacco just went into your precious Peyton Manning and Tom Brady's houses and walked out holding the opponents hearts. He beat Eli like a drum earlier this year. What else do you want from him?


Oh a Super Bowl MVP you say? Fine. Come see me Monday morning.

moundpounders32
02-01-2013, 01:43 PM
this made me rank all 32 QBs, flacco finishes 11 for me, but could swap romo or eli out of top 10 and put him in and be fine..

1 - brady, 2 - p.manning, 3 - rodgers, 4 - brees, 5 - ryan
6 - luck, 7 - wilson (might be high but i love what ive seen), 8 - stafford, 9 - romo (might be high since cant seem to win big game) 10 - eli,
11- flacco, 12 - griffen, 13 - kaep, 14 - bradford, 15 - roethlesberger,
16 - dalton, 17 - newton, 18 - rivers, 19 - freeman, 20 - schaub,
21 - palmer, 22 - fitz, 23 - cutler, 24 - ponder, 25 - tannehill,
26 - locker, 27 - weeden, 28 - foles, 29 - sanchez, 30 - cassel,
31 - gabbert, 32 - kolb


not really sure what my criteria was besides, "this is where id rank them"

GPx
02-01-2013, 01:49 PM
this made me rank all 32 QBs, flacco finishes 11 for me, but could swap romo or eli out of top 10 and put him in and be fine..

1 - brady, 2 - p.manning, 3 - rodgers, 4 - brees, 5 - ryan
6 - luck, 7 - wilson (might be high but i love what ive seen), 8 - stafford, 9 - romo (might be high since cant seem to win big game) 10 - eli,
11- flacco, 12 - griffen, 13 - kaep, 14 - bradford, 15 - roethlesberger,
16 - dalton, 17 - newton, 18 - rivers, 19 - freeman, 20 - schaub,
21 - palmer, 22 - fitz, 23 - cutler, 24 - ponder, 25 - tannehill,
26 - locker, 27 - weeden, 28 - foles, 29 - sanchez, 30 - cassel,
31 - gabbert, 32 - kolb


not really sure what my criteria was besides, "this is where id rank them"

http://www.vh1.com/celebrity/bwe/images/2010/01/SIMON-CONFUSED-GIF.gif

moundpounders32
02-01-2013, 02:06 PM
lol, who am i so far off on?

GPx
02-01-2013, 02:09 PM
lol, who am i so far off on?

I don't have time to fully dissect that ridiculous list so I'll highlight a few points.

Matt Ryan too high
Andrew Luck = 6? lol
Big Ben 15?
Romo over BigBen and Eli and others?

Your list looks like this was the first NFL season you've watched.

9inchSub
02-01-2013, 02:18 PM
I don't have time to fully dissect that ridiculous list so I'll highlight a few points.

Matt Ryan too high
Andrew Luck = 6? lol
Big Ben 15?
Romo over BigBen and Eli and others?

Your list looks like this was the first NFL season you've watched.

Strong this.. I think he ranked them by how they preformed this year even tho Luck had 18INT, Kaep at 14 after playing 10 matches lol..

jesusonaciid
02-01-2013, 02:22 PM
None of these tiers are ordered.

God tier
Peyton
Brady
Rodgers

So-close god tier:
Drew Brees

Elite:
Big Ben
Eli

Next in line:
Flacco
Ryan
Wilson

RG3 and Luck maybe thrown into the next in like group.

I think Flacco is maybe 9th-10th in QB rankings. Inconsistent but he's won a game in each postseason. Unlike the top 6 I posted, he isn't a QB who's going to "carry your team". But, he's definitely good enough to win a Super Bowl if he has talent around him... as you see now.
quality post. srs. repped.

moundpounders32
02-01-2013, 02:24 PM
ryan at 5 is perfect.
luck at 6 i can see people ranking him lower, was prolly higher on my list because of his future, hes obviously smart and has the tools to be here.
ben i can agree with you, but i think its easy to put ten guys ahead him, i cant disagree with romo not deserving to be in the top ten, if i crunched it alittle more then just off the top of my head then maybe it would look alittle different
sorry your opinion of my opinion differs :(

moundpounders32
02-01-2013, 02:28 PM
Strong this.. I think he ranked them by how they preformed this year even tho Luck had 18INT, Kaep at 14 after playing 10 matches lol..

its not an all time list, lol, okay i guess i should have cassel over wilson.

Strizzz
02-03-2013, 07:58 PM
2nd Tier QB imo (outside the top 10) Needs to be surrounded with enough talent to be successful.


None of these tiers are ordered.

God tier
Peyton
Brady
Rodgers

So-close god tier:
Drew Brees

Elite:
Big Ben
Eli

Next in line:
Flacco
Ryan
Wilson
Kaep

RG3 and Luck maybe thrown into the next line group soon.

I think Flacco is maybe 9th-10th in QB rankings. Inconsistent but he's won a game in each postseason. Unlike the top 6 I posted, he isn't a QB who's going to "carry your team". But, he's definitely good enough to win a Super Bowl if he has talent around him... as you see now.


He's still not elite.


this made me rank all 32 QBs, flacco finishes 11 for me, but could swap romo or eli out of top 10 and put him in and be fine..

1 - brady, 2 - p.manning, 3 - rodgers, 4 - brees, 5 - ryan
6 - luck, 7 - wilson (might be high but i love what ive seen), 8 - stafford, 9 - romo (might be high since cant seem to win big game) 10 - eli,
11- flacco, 12 - griffen, 13 - kaep, 14 - bradford, 15 - roethlesberger,
16 - dalton, 17 - newton, 18 - rivers, 19 - freeman, 20 - schaub,
21 - palmer, 22 - fitz, 23 - cutler, 24 - ponder, 25 - tannehill,
26 - locker, 27 - weeden, 28 - foles, 29 - sanchez, 30 - cassel,
31 - gabbert, 32 - kolb


not really sure what my criteria was besides, "this is where id rank them"

http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif
http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif
http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif
http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif
http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif
http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif







































































































http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif

Flacco exposed as the GOAT.

Nocks
02-03-2013, 07:59 PM
http://gifsforum.com/images/gif/misc%20bb/grand/684utw.gif

Flacco exposed as the GOAT.

I put Flacco at #7, which is right.

Not better than Peyton, Brady, Rodgers, Brees... not debatable.

And Eli and Big Ben have 2 Super Bowls as well as are more consistent.

Don't be rustled

MrRIP
02-03-2013, 08:07 PM
I put Flacco at #7, which is right.

Not better than Peyton, Brady, Rodgers, Brees... not debatable.

And Eli and Big Ben have 2 Super Bowls as well as are more consistent.

Don't be rustled


7 may be right hes just really too inconsistent for me. Hes about to get PAID though

krogtaar
02-03-2013, 08:35 PM
goodnight sweet Baltimore salary cap

actually they should be top contenders for a few years. They won the superbowl without Webb, T sizzle, Ngata at full strength. get a young MLB who can run at a fraction of Ray's paycheck, bake

CarpeD1em500
02-04-2013, 02:47 PM
If you honestly would take Big Ben over Joe Flacco this coming Sunday you're out of your damn mind. Dude's prime was a few years ago. He's not there anymore. Joe is. Deal with it.


Joe Flacco just went into your precious Peyton Manning and Tom Brady's houses and walked out holding the opponents hearts. He beat Eli like a drum earlier this year. What else do you want from him?


Oh a Super Bowl MVP you say? Fine. Come see me Monday morning.


Bumping for wizardry.

TTexasTT
02-04-2013, 02:51 PM
he makes it into the top 10
http://i675.photobucket.com/albums/vv117/ttexastt/5a094cf3-bc21-492c-b69a-39b1c1d12df3_zpsaf9bfaff.jpg

CurryTech777
02-04-2013, 02:59 PM
top15. He is finally understanding his game so he could creep into the top10 very easily. In terms of big plays he is much higher but i don't think he could pick a defenses apart consistently like the elite qbs can.

nic9212
02-04-2013, 03:04 PM
Flacco is not in my top ten, but has improved alot over the past couple years

Justang
02-04-2013, 03:23 PM
What are we basing this off of? His first 5 years? Wins? What? If we are basing this off his first five years, then he is not in the top ten. If we are basing this starting with this years post season, he is easily top five with what he did. 12 TDS 0 INTS? Thats pretty much god like stats, I just don't believe he will be able to put up this kinda performance ever again and def not in the season.