PDA

View Full Version : How fail were the Class of 2005 5* prospects



feardafronfz3
07-06-2010, 11:28 AM
#1 Gerald Green G Houston, TXGulf Shores Academy 5 stars 6'8" 195 Oklahoma St.
#2 Josh McRoberts F Carmel, IN 5 stars 6'11" 241 Duke
#3 Monta Ellis G Jackson, MSLanier 5 stars 6'2" 160 Mississippi St.
#4 Andray Blatche F Syracuse, NYSouth Kent (CT) 5 stars 6'11" 230 list
#5 Martell Webster G Seattle, WASeattle Prep 5 stars 6'6" 225 Washington
#6 Andrew Bynum C Metuchen, NJSt. Josephs 5 stars 6'11" 270 Connecticut
#7 Louis Williams G Snellville, GASouth Gwinnett 5 stars 6'2" 175 Georgia
#8 Julian Wright F Flossmoor, ILHomewood 5 stars 6'8" 214 Kansas
#9 Richard Hendrix F Athens, ALAthens 5 stars 6'8" 250 Alabama
#10 Tyler Hansbrough F Poplar Bluff, MOPoplar Bluff 5 stars 6'8" 224 North Carolina
#11 Greg Paulus G Manlius, NYChristian Brothers Academy 5 stars 6'1" 180 Duke
#12 Mario Chalmers G Anchorage, AKBartlett 5 stars 6'3" 182 Kansas
#13 Brandon Rush F Kansas City, MOMt. Zion Academy 5 stars 6'6" 202 Kansas
#14 Keith Brumbaugh F DeLand, FLDeland 5 stars 6'8" 205 Oklahoma St.
#15 Shawne Williams G Laurinburg, NCLaurinburg Institute 5 stars 6'9" 210 Memphis
#16 Jamont Gordon G Nashville, TNOak Hill Academy 5 stars 6'3" 225 Mississippi St.
#17 Byron Eaton G Dallas, TXLincoln 5 stars 5'11" 210 Oklahoma St.
#18 Magnum Rolle F Laurinburg Institute (NC) 5 stars 6'9" 200 LSU
#19 Calvin Miles F Dallas, TXSkyline 5 stars 6'5" 195 Texas
#20 Tasmin Mitchell F Denham Springs, LADenham Springs 5 stars 6'7" 220 LSU
#21 J.P. Prince G Memphis, TNWhite Station 5 stars 6'7" 203 Arizona
#22 Mike Mercer G Snellville, GASouth Gwinnett 5 stars 6'3" 170 Georgia
#23 Joe Krabbenhoft F Sioux Falls, SDRoosevelt 5 stars 6'7" 200 Wisconsin
#24 Courtney Fells G Shannon, MSShannon 5 stars 6'5" 180 N.C. State
#25 Jovan Adams G Houston, TXGulf Shores Academy 5 stars 6'1" 180 UNLV

YeahImaBeasT
07-06-2010, 11:36 AM
This thread is now about how bad the 2000 draft class was.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_NBA_Draft

calibrah2010
07-06-2010, 11:37 AM
how is it fail when half the 5 star prospects are in the nba. do you have any idea how hard it is to make the league

Tes45
07-06-2010, 11:38 AM
JP Prince dunked on my ass in HS

Erik2806
07-06-2010, 11:38 AM
#1 Gerald Green G Houston, TXGulf Shores Academy 5 stars 6'8" 195 Oklahoma St.
#2 Josh McRoberts F Carmel, IN 5 stars 6'11" 241 Duke
#3 Monta Ellis G Jackson, MSLanier 5 stars 6'2" 160 Mississippi St.
#4 Andray Blatche F Syracuse, NYSouth Kent (CT) 5 stars 6'11" 230 list
#5 Martell Webster G Seattle, WASeattle Prep 5 stars 6'6" 225 Washington
#6 Andrew Bynum C Metuchen, NJSt. Josephs 5 stars 6'11" 270 Connecticut
#7 Louis Williams G Snellville, GASouth Gwinnett 5 stars 6'2" 175 Georgia
#8 Julian Wright F Flossmoor, ILHomewood 5 stars 6'8" 214 Kansas
#9 Richard Hendrix F Athens, ALAthens 5 stars 6'8" 250 Alabama
#10 Tyler Hansbrough F Poplar Bluff, MOPoplar Bluff 5 stars 6'8" 224 North Carolina
#11 Greg Paulus G Manlius, NYChristian Brothers Academy 5 stars 6'1" 180 Duke
#12 Mario Chalmers G Anchorage, AKBartlett 5 stars 6'3" 182 Kansas
#13 Brandon Rush F Kansas City, MOMt. Zion Academy 5 stars 6'6" 202 Kansas
#14 Keith Brumbaugh F DeLand, FLDeland 5 stars 6'8" 205 Oklahoma St.
#15 Shawne Williams G Laurinburg, NCLaurinburg Institute 5 stars 6'9" 210 Memphis
#16 Jamont Gordon G Nashville, TNOak Hill Academy 5 stars 6'3" 225 Mississippi St.
#17 Byron Eaton G Dallas, TXLincoln 5 stars 5'11" 210 Oklahoma St.
#18 Magnum Rolle F Laurinburg Institute (NC) 5 stars 6'9" 200 LSU
#19 Calvin Miles F Dallas, TXSkyline 5 stars 6'5" 195 Texas
#20 Tasmin Mitchell F Denham Springs, LADenham Springs 5 stars 6'7" 220 LSU
#21 J.P. Prince G Memphis, TNWhite Station 5 stars 6'7" 203 Arizona
#22 Mike Mercer G Snellville, GASouth Gwinnett 5 stars 6'3" 170 Georgia
#23 Joe Krabbenhoft F Sioux Falls, SDRoosevelt 5 stars 6'7" 200 Wisconsin
#24 Courtney Fells G Shannon, MSShannon 5 stars 6'5" 180 N.C. State
#25 Jovan Adams G Houston, TXGulf Shores Academy 5 stars 6'1" 180 UNLV

eh. quite a bit of fail, but you have to put it in perspective of their college careers. rush, chalmers, hansbrough, and ellis lived up to it id say. paulus and mcroberts were pretty solid too. u cant take the ratings too seriously, and that goes for every year. theres always a bunch of guys that are rated too high and some too low. overall, this isnt that bad of a top 25 considering how many have made the nba.

ryan36_1
07-06-2010, 11:39 AM
That list looks pretty average to me. Every year has 5s that don't pan out and 3s that overachieve.

feardafronfz3
07-06-2010, 11:42 AM
how is it fail when half the 5 star prospects are in the nba. do you have any idea how hard it is to make the league

how many nba stars came from this class? 1?

compare with the class of 2004

#1 Dwight Howard F Atlanta, GASouthwest Atlanta Christian 5 stars 6'10" 225 list
#2 Shaun Livingston G Peoria, ILPeoria 5 stars 6'6" 170 Duke
#3 Joshua Smith F Powder Springs, GAOak Hill (VA) 5 stars 6'8" 200 Indiana
#4 Al Jefferson C Prentiss, MSPrentiss 5 stars 6'9" 260 Arkansas
#5 Rudy Gay F Capitol Heights, MDArchbishop Spalding 5 stars 6'8" 205 Connecticut
#6 Sebastian Telfair G New York, NYLincoln 5 stars 6'0" 160 Louisville
#7 Malik Hairston G Detroit, MIRenaissance 5 stars 6'5" 190 Oregon
#8 Earl Smith F Clarksburg, NJSt. Benedict's Prep (NJ) 5 stars 6'6" 220 North Carolina
#9 Joe Crawford G Detroit, MIRenaissance 5 stars 6'4" 205 Kentucky
#10 Randolph Morris C Palmetto, GALandmark Christian 5 stars 6'11" 250 Kentucky
#11 Marvin Williams, Jr. F Bremerton, WABremerton 5 stars 6'9" 225 North Carolina
#12 Dorell Wright F Los Angeles, CASouth Kent Prep (CT) 5 stars 6'7" 210 DePaul
#13 Glen Davis F Baton Rouge, LAUniversity Lab 5 stars 6'8" 345 LSU
#14 Robert Swift C Bakersfield, CAHighland 5 stars 7'1" 245 USC
#15 D.J. White F Tuscaloosa, ALHillcrest 5 stars 6'7" 230 Indiana
#16 LaMarcus Aldridge C Dallas, TXSeagoville 5 stars 6'11" 215 Texas
#17 Demarcus Nelson G Elk Grove, CASheldon 5 stars 6'3" 195 Duke
#18 Jawann McClellan G Houston, TXCharles H. Milby 5 stars 6'5" 210 Arizona
#19 Shawne Williams F Memphis, TNLaurinburg Prep (NC) 5 stars 6'8" 200 Memphis
#20 Mike Williams F Camden, ALWilcox Central 5 stars 6'7" 225 Texas
#21 Marquise Gray F Flint, MIFlint Beecher 5 stars 6'8" 215 Michigan St.
#22 Jordan Farmar G Woodland Hills, CATaft 5 stars 6'2" 170 UCLA
#23 Darius Washington, Jr. G Orlando, FLEdgewater 5 stars 6'0" 165 Memphis
#24 Ron Steele G Birmingham, ALJohn Carroll 5 stars 6'2" 185 Alabama
#25 Rajon Rondo G Louisville, KYOak Hill Academy 5 stars 6'1" 155 Kentucky
#26 Arron Afflalo G Compton, CAPrice 5 stars 6'5" 195 UCLA
#27 Russell Robinson G New York, NYRice 5 stars 6'1" 180 Kansas
#28 Kyle Lowry G Philadelphia, PACardinal Dougherty 5 stars 5'11" 170 Villanova
#29 Daniel Gibson G Houston, TXJones 5 stars 6'2" 200 Texas
#30 Juan Palacios F Centereach, NYOur Savior New American 5 stars 6'8" 255 Louisville

namean
07-06-2010, 11:46 AM
#1 Gerald Green G Houston, TXGulf Shores Academy 5 stars 6'8" 195 Oklahoma St.
#2 Josh McRoberts F Carmel, IN 5 stars 6'11" 241 Duke
#3 Monta Ellis G Jackson, MSLanier 5 stars 6'2" 160 Mississippi St.
#4 Andray Blatche F Syracuse, NYSouth Kent (CT) 5 stars 6'11" 230 list
#5 Martell Webster G Seattle, WASeattle Prep 5 stars 6'6" 225 Washington
#6 Andrew Bynum C Metuchen, NJSt. Josephs 5 stars 6'11" 270 Connecticut
#7 Louis Williams G Snellville, GASouth Gwinnett 5 stars 6'2" 175 Georgia
#8 Julian Wright F Flossmoor, ILHomewood 5 stars 6'8" 214 Kansas
#9 Richard Hendrix F Athens, ALAthens 5 stars 6'8" 250 Alabama
#10 Tyler Hansbrough F Poplar Bluff, MOPoplar Bluff 5 stars 6'8" 224 North Carolina
#11 Greg Paulus G Manlius, NYChristian Brothers Academy 5 stars 6'1" 180 Duke
#12 Mario Chalmers G Anchorage, AKBartlett 5 stars 6'3" 182 Kansas
#13 Brandon Rush F Kansas City, MOMt. Zion Academy 5 stars 6'6" 202 Kansas
#14 Keith Brumbaugh F DeLand, FLDeland 5 stars 6'8" 205 Oklahoma St.
#15 Shawne Williams G Laurinburg, NCLaurinburg Institute 5 stars 6'9" 210 Memphis
#16 Jamont Gordon G Nashville, TNOak Hill Academy 5 stars 6'3" 225 Mississippi St.
#17 Byron Eaton G Dallas, TXLincoln 5 stars 5'11" 210 Oklahoma St.
#18 Magnum Rolle F Laurinburg Institute (NC) 5 stars 6'9" 200 LSU
#19 Calvin Miles F Dallas, TXSkyline 5 stars 6'5" 195 Texas
#20 Tasmin Mitchell F Denham Springs, LADenham Springs 5 stars 6'7" 220 LSU
#21 J.P. Prince G Memphis, TNWhite Station 5 stars 6'7" 203 Arizona
#22 Mike Mercer G Snellville, GASouth Gwinnett 5 stars 6'3" 170 Georgia
#23 Joe Krabbenhoft F Sioux Falls, SDRoosevelt 5 stars 6'7" 200 Wisconsin
#24 Courtney Fells G Shannon, MSShannon 5 stars 6'5" 180 N.C. State
#25 Jovan Adams G Houston, TXGulf Shores Academy 5 stars 6'1" 180 UNLV

andrew bogut
deron williams
chris paul
andrew bynum

other than those....you are correct! Pretty $hitty draft!!!!! Would have to be the WORST draft class of ALL-TIME!!

feardafronfz3
07-06-2010, 11:48 AM
andrew bogut
deron williams
chris paul
andrew bynum

other than those....you are correct! Pretty $hitty draft!!!!! Would have to be the WORST draft class of ALL-TIME!!

you eat a lot of paint chips as a kid?

Lasers1
07-06-2010, 12:19 PM
andrew bogut
deron williams
chris paul
andrew bynum

other than those....you are correct! Pretty $hitty draft!!!!! Would have to be the WORST draft class of ALL-TIME!!

o lawd

bustermac
07-06-2010, 12:37 PM
Andray Blatche is legit now. Was a beast on both ends last year.

Da_tulipe
07-06-2010, 12:54 PM
wtf is this thread??

chris paul, deron williams, bogut were the top picks in that years draft. wtf you didnt mention them?

Big_Pete1000
07-06-2010, 01:01 PM
This thread is now about how bad the 2000 draft class was.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_NBA_Draft

lol Mark Madsen won some rings and had the epic dance at the parade

Lasers1
07-06-2010, 01:10 PM
wtf is this thread??

chris paul, deron williams, bogut were the top picks in that years draft. wtf you didnt mention them?


You can't teach stupid

Big_Pete1000
07-06-2010, 01:13 PM
wtf is this thread??

chris paul, deron williams, bogut were the top picks in that years draft. wtf you didnt mention them?

OP is talking about 5* recruits going to college

tmc.
07-06-2010, 01:58 PM
Wouldn't that be a failure more on the part of the recruiting rating service?

SwagMorris
07-06-2010, 02:19 PM
Wouldn't that be a failure more on the part of the recruiting rating service?

And the schools that recruited them.

batman15
07-06-2010, 03:37 PM
I thought this was going to be about football.

OP, I am disappoint.

batman15
07-06-2010, 03:38 PM
#3 Monta Ellis G Jackson, MSLanier 5 stars 6'2" 160 Mississippi St.
#6 Andrew Bynum C Metuchen, NJSt. Josephs 5 stars 6'11" 270 Connecticut
#10 Tyler Hansbrough F Poplar Bluff, MOPoplar Bluff 5 stars 6'8" 224 North Carolina
#11 Greg Paulus G Manlius, NYChristian Brothers Academy 5 stars 6'1" 180 Duke
#12 Mario Chalmers G Anchorage, AKBartlett 5 stars 6'3" 182 Kansas
#13 Brandon Rush F Kansas City, MOMt. Zion Academy 5 stars 6'6" 202 Kansas


only people I have heard of.

IllPhill
07-06-2010, 03:39 PM
andrew bogut
deron williams
chris paul
andrew bynum

other than those....you are correct! Pretty $hitty draft!!!!! Would have to be the WORST draft class of ALL-TIME!!


wtf is this thread??

chris paul, deron williams, bogut were the top picks in that years draft. wtf you didnt mention them?

pls go....

Also why did Monta drop to 40ish later in the ACTUAL draft while bynum was #10?

Lasers1
07-06-2010, 03:57 PM
only people I have heard of.

lol you've never heard of Gerald Green, Martell Webster, Louis Williams, and Julian Wright? srs

tmc.
07-06-2010, 03:59 PM
lol you've never heard of Gerald Green, Martell Webster, Louis Williams, and Julian Wright? srs

Blatche?