I usually say "puppy dog cute, or adam brody cute?" Or something like that, and then go from there... keeps a convo going. Then you talk about the different kinds of cute, etc etc, and crack some jokes. Pretty easy topic to banter about.
If she says "adam brody cute" I usually say something like "Awesome, maybe when I hit puberty I'll be ruggedly handsome.... any day now says my doctor." Of course I'm just weird and can say stupid stuff like that...
"Puppy dog cute" usually gets a cute reply from me... not that I script this **** ever, I just end up on this topic pretty often for some reason, prob cuz I have a babyface.
Our Arnold, whose arms are heavy,
Vascular be thy veins
Nine sets of lunges, ten reps be done,
To add girth as it is to strengthen.
Give us this day our daily protein, and forgive us our fats,
As we forgive those who eat fat too.
And lead us not into overtraining, nor deliver us pizzas,
For thou art the king of the dumbell, the power clean, and the steroids forever,