You think Adrian Peterson is good? Watch Darren Mcfadden

[Crestor]

This guy is better than Adrian. He is the fastest player I have ever seen. Put 8 in the box and he will throw it on you. If the Jets get him next year, I'd seriously watch out. Best RB to come out of SEC EVER. Last year he had 182 on LSU's defense which was basically an NFL defense in it's own right. Top 10 picks Glen Dorsey and LaRon Landy will tell you so.

[bignpisst]

whatever

[Budweiser]

This guy is better than Adrian. He is the fastest player I have ever seen. Put 8 in the box and he will throw it on you. If the Jets get him next year, I'd seriously watch out. Best RB to come out of SEC EVER. Last year he had 182 on LSU's defense which was basically an NFL defense in it's own right. Top 10 picks Glen Dorsey and LaRon Landy will tell you so.

College does not have nearly as good of players as the NFL. Wait until he is in the NFL before you compare him to the greatness that is AD

[kooldude]

This guy is better than Adrian. He is the fastest player I have ever seen. Put 8 in the box and he will throw it on you. If the Jets get him next year, I'd seriously watch out. Best RB to come out of SEC EVER. Last year he had 182 on LSU's defense which was basically an NFL defense in it's own right. Top 10 picks Glen Dorsey and LaRon Landy will tell you so.

No

[INGENIUM]

I don't know if he will better than peterson, but mcfadden WILL be a great NFL back...

adrian peterson is amazing though...i can't remember being this impressed with a back since barry sanders

[natespeer]

not saying he'll be better, but i'm really looking foward to watching him at the next level

[Mindripper]

This guy is better than Adrian. He is the fastest player I have ever seen. Put 8 in the box and he will throw it on you. If the Jets get him next year, I'd seriously watch out. Best RB to come out of SEC EVER. Last year he had 182 on LSU's defense which was basically an NFL defense in it's own right. Top 10 picks Glen Dorsey and LaRon Landy will tell you so.

New flash genius... Adrian Peterson is awesome; the best back in a league of great backs this year.

We'll see what Mcfadden can do at the next level.

[lovermangenuis]

Nope. McFadden is excellent definitely something special, but Peterson is one of those backs that comes around once every twenty years. He is a power back that runs a 4.38.....that is insane. I even read that some nfl personnel felt that Peterson was so talented coming out of high school that he could have potentially made the high school to pro jump ( a la the NBA). I don't see how you can pimp McFadden over Peterson where Adrian dominated the NCAA like McFadden is doing now but Peterson is doing it at the next level

[Cramerica]

Nope. McFadden is excellent definitely something special, but Peterson is one of those backs that comes around once every twenty years. He is a power back that runs a 4.38.....that is insane. I even read that some nfl personnel felt that Peterson was so talented coming out of high school that he could have potentially made the high school to pro jump ( a la the NBA). I don't see how you can pimp McFadden over Peterson where Adrian dominated the NCAA like McFadden is doing now but Peterson is doing it at the next level

Then you can't legitimately say that McFadden won't be as successful in the NFL as Peterson has been thus far. Granted, that's a lot to live up to, but McFadden has looked just as good if not better in college so far.

For someone to say he will be better or worse than AP is too early to tell.

[Budweiser]

Then you can't legitimately say that McFadden won't be as successful in the NFL as Peterson has been thus far. Granted, that's a lot to live up to, but McFadden has looked just as good if not better in college so far.

For someone to say he will be better or worse than AP is too early to tell.

Yep, AD is breaking so many records this year. He broke the NFL total yards in a game vs Chicago, he broke the Vikings rushing yards in a game vs Chicago, he Broke the Vikings rushing yards in a game (his own record) vs San Diego, he broke the NFL rushing yards in a game vs San Diego, he is the only rookie running back to have (2) 200 yard games in a single season, I am sure he is on pace to break the rookie TD record and the rookie rushing yard per season.

[Runngunn29]

Jesus Christ, relax with AP. Yea hes good but lets let him play a couple more years without getting injured before we anoint him God.

I like Run DMC but havent seen too much from him this year. I'm a little worried because the SEC has been inclined to give up tons of points and yards this year, but he looks real good nonetheless. Hopefully I can catch LSU-Ark so I can see more of both Dorsey and DMC for the draft.

[laxer22]

Nope. McFadden is excellent definitely something special, but Peterson is one of those backs that comes around once every twenty years. He is a power back that runs a 4.38.....that is insane. I even read that some nfl personnel felt that Peterson was so talented coming out of high school that he could have potentially made the high school to pro jump ( a la the NBA). I don't see how you can pimp McFadden over Peterson where Adrian dominated the NCAA like McFadden is doing now but Peterson is doing it at the next level

AP ran a 4.38 the day after his bro was killed, and he was not happy with his time. His best times are in the 4.25-4.28 range.

[Kevintensity]

peterson>>>>mcfadden>>>>>>>>>>>>bush


anyone disagree?

[5x10]

I don't know if he will better than peterson, but mcfadden WILL be a great NFL back...

adrian peterson is amazing though...i can't remember being this impressed with a back since barry sanders

x2
i wish i got every minnesota game

[Rumple4skin]

peterson>>>>mcfadden>>>>>>>>>>>>bush


anyone disagree?

nope

[Cramerica]

peterson>>>>mcfadden>>>>>>>>>>>>bush


anyone disagree?

Well, McFadden hasn't played in the NFL yet, but for a rookie to do what AP is doing, it's highly unlikely.

As for Bush, his hype (and maybe USC's NC trophy) are dust in the wind.

Peterson owns Bush.

[Bulldog0520]

rofl. Peterson - 2nd in Heisman his freshman year.

I've watched them both plenty of times, and, while McFadden is good, Peterson is on another level.

[MISSINGLINK]

Too bad he plays for Arkansas

[RWHJR3]

A. Peterson over the rest of them. McFadden will be good, but..he's not Peterson. Just sayin!

[.fedale.]

Another quality thread...

[T2TL]

This guy is better than Adrian. He is the fastest player I have ever seen. Put 8 in the box and he will throw it on you. If the Jets get him next year, I'd seriously watch out. Best RB to come out of SEC EVER. Last year he had 182 on LSU's defense which was basically an NFL defense in it's own right. Top 10 picks Glen Dorsey and LaRon Landy will tell you so.

so youre saying there will be back to back rookies breaking several rushing records? i dont think so, ADP healthy = one of the most talented backs ever and dont talk college stats lets see once he gets into the NFL. hell be a good back but dont count on him having a career

[3lftbig3]

AP looks legit, Mcfadden could go either way its hard to tell, he definitely could end up being a bust.

[RavenStorm]

AP is ****ing incredible, Darren is great but we will see when he gets to the NFL.

[Crestor]

AP is good but won't last past 4 years. Book it his running style will catch up to him eventually.

[Ace50]

Marshawn Lynch is a pretty nasty rookie back also

[Dennis71]

McFadden will never be the back that AP is....

McFadden has never played as good as AP....


AP is a fast guy too (ran in the 4.3's didnt he?) but unlike McFadden, he can run between the tackles and run people over

[Negatron617]

cuz somebody is nasty is college doesnt mean they will be nasty in the pros
2 totally different leagues 2 totally different levels
ask reggie bush
ask ryan leaf

[Alfro]

Better than Bo?Better than half of the great Auburn running backs alone? He is a great running back, but not the best...

[snuffiluffigus]

Peterson is currently better than McFadden. McFadden could be a total flop for all we know.

[Crestor]

Better than Bo?Better than half of the great Auburn running backs alone? He is a great running back, but not the best...

yes