
Banned
Weight to Height ratio?
I have been wondering this for a while and want to know if anyone has an answer to this....
If there are two people who have the same frame (proportional to their height) and are directly proportional to each other in muscle, fat, etc, basically the same in everything except height. If one person is an inch shorter, how much more must the taller person weigh to achieve the same proportion of musculature.
Im just looking for a rough estimate here so I can compare my progress to my friends' who is a few inches taller than me. thanks to anyone who responds.

Banned
It depends on the heights of the people.
Example:
If one person was 10 inches tall and the other person was 9 inches tall it would be a much bigger differance than if one person was 100 inches tall and the other was 99 inches tall.

Registered User
Originally posted by Heisman
It depends on the heights of the people.
Example:
If one person was 10 inches tall and the other person was 9 inches tall it would be a much bigger differance than if one person was 100 inches tall and the other was 99 inches tall.
lets say 5'10 and 5'11

Banned
my very fast and rough way is 1'' = ~12pds.so if you're 6' 200, if you were 6'3 i'd guestimate you to be 236ish. *shrug* works more or less

Evangelical Agnostic
My guess is 5lbs.
I've always equated 5'8 160lbs = 5'9 165lbs = 5'10 170lbs etc.
So for example if you were 5'6 145lbs and wanted to determine what you would weight if you were 6'8 it would be 215lbs.
You can't convince a believer of anything; for their belief is not based on evidence, it's based on a deepseated need to believe.  Carl Sagan

OMNISCIENT.
Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by BoSox
I have been wondering this for a while and want to know if anyone has an answer to this....
If there are two people who have the same frame (proportional to their height) and are directly proportional to each other in muscle, fat, etc, basically the same in everything except height. If one person is an inch shorter, how much more must the taller person weigh to achieve the same proportion of musculature.
Im just looking for a rough estimate here so I can compare my progress to my friends' who is a few inches taller than me. thanks to anyone who responds.
Investigate the body mass index calcualtion
NO CELLTECH SOURCECHECKS.

Banned
Re: Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by RiK
Investigate the body mass index calcualtion
that thing is a piece of ****...it told me i was a 40 or something, lol (w/ > 25 being obese)

OMNISCIENT.
Re: Re: Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by hyp3r3xt3nsion
that thing is a piece of ****...it told me i was a 40 or something, lol (w/ > 25 being obese)
nah nah nah not to see if your overweight, because obviously it doesn't take into account muscle. It's very useful to compare the figure you get to others. Basically it lets you know if you are larger for your height than them.
NO CELLTECH SOURCECHECKS.

Banned
Re: Re: Re: Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by RiK
nah nah nah not to see if your overweight, because obviously it doesn't take into account muscle. It's very useful to compare the figure you get to others. Basically it lets you know if you are larger for your height than them.
thanks that helps a lot

Registered User
I remember reading an article by Steve Reves that was similar. For every inch up to 6' add 5lbs. For every inch over 6' add 10 lbs.

Injured
Re: Re: Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by hyp3r3xt3nsion
that thing is a piece of ****...it told me i was a 40 or something, lol (w/ > 25 being obese)
Amusclehead?
*****PL stats under construction*****

OMNISCIENT.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by Rookie
Amusclehead?
Correct.
NO CELLTECH SOURCECHECKS.

geaux tigers
it depends on how tall and how much weight gained. tell us how tall youand your friend are, and how much both of you gained, then we can tell you who has done proportionally better.

Banned
Re: Re: Re: Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by Rookie
Amusclehead?
who's asking

Registered User
Re: Re: Weight to Height ratio?
Originally posted by RiK
Investigate the body mass index calcualtion
Spot on.
Some people think it's 10 pounds per inch, but they couldn't be more wrong. In actuality it's closer to the 5 pounds CerealKiller guessed, at least for people of normal height.
As Rik suggested, you can just use the body mass index to find out this information.
Since the system is most accurate in a person of normal height and weight we'll calculate how much heavier a 5'11'' man should be than a 5'10'' man of identical weight ( relative to height ).
We'll say the 5'10'' man weighs 154.3lbs ( 70.0kg ), giving him a body mass index of 22 ...
( to calculate your body mass index, you need to convert your height and weight to metric  in this case 5'10'' 154lbs = 1.78m and 70kg  multiply your height in metres by itself, and then divide that number into your weight. In this case 70 / 3.1684 = 22 )
Now we calculate a 5'11'' man's weight at the same bmi ( 22 ).
I'll be real exact here to get the most accurate figure, I'll call 5'11'' 1.8054m to make it PRECISELY an inch more than 1.78m ... and working with that, the 5'11'' man would weigh 72.03kg / 158.8lbs to be the the exact same size as the 5'10'' 154.3lb man. A difference of approximately 4.5 pounds ...
BUT  one more thing to take into account. Body mass index becomes more inaccurate the taller you get, it's geared towards someone of average height. It doesn't take into account the fact that people grow out ect as well as up. A bmi of 22 on a 5'10'' guy is not the same as a bmi of 22 on a 6'8'' guy. A bmi of 22 would be average on the 5'10'' guy but skinny on the 6'8'' guy.
The best estimate I can give as to exactly how much increasing or decreasing height from the average ( roughly 5'10'' for a man ) affects your bmi is roughly 1 whole bmi point for every 5.5 inches above or below 5'10''  i.e 5'10'' @ a bmi of 22 = 6'3 1/2'' @ a bmi of 23 and so on.
Taking that into account I would estimate you would have to add around 1/3 of a pound to how much heavier you should be at an inch taller for every inch above 5'10''.
i.e in men of normal weight the difference between 5'10'' and 5'11'' is about 4.8  4.9 pounds ... but the difference between a 6'5'' and a 6'4'' man would be closer to 7 pounds and so on ...
Weight also affects it. Obviously if you're comparing two 250 + pounders the difference per inch is going to be more than comparing people of the same height who are of normal weight. Off the top of my head I think it's something like 0.5 pounds for every 40 or so pounds you are above the norm bmi ( 22.5 ). If you're 100 + lbs above you'd have to add 1.5 pounds or more. It's something like that. You have to factor in height as always too. I can calculate it if anyone REALLY wants to know, but what I guessed is pretty close.
But anyway, the difference between a 5'10'' and 5'11'' man with a bmi of 22 is about 4.85 pounds ... so there you have it. I hope this answered your question adequately, BoSox
Last edited by jay81; 06012004 at 12:50 PM.

OMNISCIENT.
NO CELLTECH SOURCECHECKS.

Registered User
Originally posted by RiK
Great post!
Thanks Rik.
Made an error or two I had to go back and edit, though, kinda complicated stuff :
Posting Permissions
 You may not post new threads
 You may not post replies
 You may not post attachments
 You may not edit your posts
Forum Rules

Bookmarks