Heath Leger's Joker vs Joaquin Phoenix's joker?

[7empest]

which movie did you prefer and why?



also now I have ur attention. do you agree with us brits?

[BalognaNbeans]

Jack Nicholson

[Xgamer791]

Pete Davidson

[KegelGains]

Egg custard tarts should be higher

[Xgamer791]

Fruit cake should be top tier.

[latverian41]

"you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain"

Thay should answer that question.

Personally I like ceaser romero

[yieldtonothing]

apples and bowling balls

[7empest]

Egg custard tarts should be higher

it's a load of ****e m8. god tier in my opinion :

pannacotta
carrot cake (these losers put it as bland)
creme caramel (basically pannacotta)

[Kev1972]

Pete Davidson

[Voidgaze]

also now I have ur attention. do you agree with us brits?

Cheesecake needs to be one tier higher at least.

I feel like such an uncultured swine because I haven't had many of the pastries listed lol. Tiramisu is God Tier for sure.

EDIT:

Brownies? Eh, they're hit or miss depending on who makes them, they should be one tier down at least.

[Xerve]

I think Heath better represented what I picture the Joker to be, plus the film was better overall.

Joaquin did a good job, although I’ve never watched Joker a second time which I think says a lot.

Apple crumble deserves to be god tier if done right.

[kimm4]

Heath.

Loved him in, The Order and Candy.

[jamalfudge]

"you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain"

Thay should answer that question.

Personally I like ceaser romero

This

[andrepmeet]

If you are familiar with the comic you would say phoenix.

joker isn't a cartoonish figure in comics (albeit he is literally) he is a deeply complex angry character who was sweet at one time in his life. reminds of Frankenstein's monster who went rage mode after being outcast.

[Bodhy]

Phoenix.


But they are difficult to compare, they're different roles. Phoenix is the protagonist in his movie and it's much darker than Ledger's joker. It's an exploration into the mind of a mentally ill person and their gradual progression towards blowing up everything they've got bottled inside.

It's not a superhero movie at all and it's depressing and sad at times. I didn't walk out feeling like I'd watched a superhero movie, I walked out thinking what an incredible depiction of how society views mentally ill people through the lens of a mentally ill person themselves.


Phoenix nailed it.

[GuineaDago585]

Heath by a mile.

As for the deserts, mostly agree with a few exceptions. First of all, what the fuk kind of carrot cake is bland? Secondly, Eclairs belong in God tier and cheesecake in top tier. There should also be another tier above God tier with cannoli, sfogliatelle, rum baba (Italian style) and those cream puffs.

[Zere0wn]

they both fit the movie they are in amazing. can't pick its a tie

[Visel]

Ledger for "super hero movie super villain that could co exist in a universe where gods and magic, superman, etc. exist, without being too too unrealistic and cringe."

Phoenix for "terrorist villain that could exist in the real world, and is more relatable to the audience."

[Vhagar]

Ledger and it isn’t close

Anybody that says Phoenix felt the creepy outcast vibe resonate with them. Also if you did you agree with a guy who smeared chit all over walls

[1hardgainer]

Ledger by far, probably because the Dark Knight joker was more of a complex character than Phoenix's joker character who was just a fed up incel. Not sure why Phoenix gets so much credit for his performance when most miscers could have easily played the part by just being themselves lol

[David275]

Not sure why Phoenix gets so much credit for his performance when most miscers could have easily played the part by just being themselves lol

[bongowongo]

Red Velvet sucks.


Eclairs are god tier.

[wildchild11]

Phoenix Joker because Heaths Joker was hitting on fukking maggie gyllenhal

[Kev1972]

Phoenix Joker because Heaths Joker was hitting on fukking maggie gyllenhal

As opposed to the incel joker who wasn't getting anything besides his hand and his imaginary girlfriend?

[GuineaDago585]

Fuk man I’m craving desert now.

[7empest]

Nice

[ChristmasFnatic]

Heath's Joker was the closest to a DC Joker. Napoleon's Joker is basically an incel.

[Gotti99]

Phoenix.


But they are difficult to compare, they're different roles. Phoenix is the protagonist in his movie and it's much darker than Ledger's joker. It's an exploration into the mind of a mentally ill person and their gradual progression towards blowing up everything they've got bottled inside.

It's not a superhero movie at all and it's depressing and sad at times. I didn't walk out feeling like I'd watched a superhero movie, I walked out thinking what an incredible depiction of how society views mentally ill people through the lens of a mentally ill person themselves.


Phoenix nailed it.

As an actor, absolutely this.

[forthenoodz]

Pete Davidson

this is not pete davidson? isn't this matthew mcconaughey

[Adam16121]

One was supposed to represent what Joker became, the other represents how Joker became what he is. Totally different goals in those portrayals, and both were done well.