[Video] What will happen if 2005 Jay Cutler version compete @ 2016 Mr.Olympia?

[Jegudiel]

Do you think that Jay Cutler can beat Phil Heath & Kai Greene?

[NaturalLoco]

With his size, conditioning.. easy win for Jay 05

[BartPimpson]

If Phil is on it would be close.

[lordlosh]

Depends what judges like/want. But if its fair judging, Cutler own the stage. Cutler have crazy conditioning, its more cut and have size/wdith/conditioning to beat anyone except Ronnie.
There is a poster in my gym with Jay, Phil, Dex, Branch, doing front relaxed, and Phil is from 2011, Cutler from 2010 and he is still twice as Phil.

[JigPig]

Yes but it will be close, 01 jay cutler however? Easy win in my opinion

[flangmasterj]

An upload at the correct aspect ratio!

Great vid too. Cheers OP.




He'd get second to Phil Heath.

[Grapplingmuscle]

If I remember right Jay wasn't at his most shredded for 05. Based on how he looks 2 weeks out in the BFTO, he has the potential to beat anyone in the current lineup. If jay is massive but not the best conditioning and Phil is dialed in like '11 then it would be very close, but Phil could win. 01/09 Jay would have a much better chance to clean house. As a side note Jay was so massive at that time; that was the height of him competing with and trying to outsize Ronnie. I miss those years

[brendanh32]

dammit i miss Jay

[sschantz]

I would go with the 2001 Jay.....

Here is my issue (not that you asked)........Would be nice to have a Mr O will less than a 34" waist....

[JigPig]

How hard do you think Jay pushed Ronnie? In my eyes Jay gave him a run in 01 and to a degree in 05.

I mean he was massive and in some cases looked wider than Ronnie thus he wasn't dwarfed unlike the other competitors(baring 03)

[purdey]

An upload at the correct aspect ratio!

Great vid too. Cheers OP.




He'd get second to Phil Heath.

Came to post this lol

[Kulutues]

those were the size game days,.....after Ronnie won the Olympia in 2004 at his biggest ever (and, according to most Ronnie fans, his least 'polished' physique) a lot of top guys were playing that game. It ruined a lot of physiques but Jay always held a lot of weight well. I still think Jay was biggest around 2007-8 and early 2009. He would upload a 15 minute vid of his workouts in Vegas multiple times weekly. Many of his workout vids are still on Jay Cutler TV from 6 years ago

[lordlosh]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hv-9qWSiYVI
Cutler looks linsane here. He is fu***** huge, and probably widder then Ronnie, and has insane back, great width and thickness, crazy legs too and his conditioning is spectacular.
Dont see how anyone of today scene have a chance against it.

[SmallShrimp]

Probably 3rd, lacks the conditioning compared to phil and kai, and both of them flow more IMO.

[brendanh32]

Probably 3rd, lacks the conditioning compared to phil and kai, and both of them flow more IMO.

10/10 trolling on the conditioning line.

[RobberBaron13]

those were the size game days,.....after Ronnie won the Olympia in 2004 at his biggest ever (and, according to most Ronnie fans, his least 'polished' physique) a lot of top guys were playing that game. It ruined a lot of physiques but Jay always held a lot of weight well. I still think Jay was biggest around 2007-8 and early 2009. He would upload a 15 minute vid of his workouts in Vegas multiple times weekly. Many of his workout vids are still on Jay Cutler TV from 6 years ago

You said it " those", but now size alone wont cut it, so id say Phil would nick it.
Actually Jay was "only" 254 lb in his 09 mr O win, a meek 6 lb heavier than 2011 Heath, which is not alot considering the width differential and similar height.

[SmallShrimp]

10/10 trolling on the conditioning line.

I meant upper body contidioning, i looked at the pics, he was really soft up top imo