** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread -- Round 2 **

[Jevice]

BnJs makes gelato?

B&J's is only mentioned in the article about their frozen greek yogurt, not gelato.

[MITCHAPAL00ZA]

B&J's is only mentioned in the article about their frozen greek yogurt, not gelato.

yeah I didn't think so…I bet that will be there next endeavor though.

[ugasar]

Sorry for so many $ shots BUT this guy is well deserved…… R.I.P. dear friend, you will be greatly missed!

[seamus33]

looks pretty freezer burned. was it?

[Misctake7]

looks pretty freezer burned. was it?

Would eat OCC regardless if I got the chance.

[The Solution]

Peanut Butter Cup Fudge Brownie White Chocolate Perfection Combination at Coldstone

PB and Cake Batter base
Fudge
brownies
White Chocolate Chips
Reese Cups

out of reese pieces

[jubjubrsx]

Peanut Butter Cup Fudge Brownie White Chocolate Perfection Combination at Coldstone

PB and Cake Batter base
Fudge
brownies
White Chocolate Chips
Reese Cups

out of reese pieces

[]http://i688.photobucket.com/albums/vv241/LayzieBone085/Food/null_zps9f3399d6.jpg[/]

out of gummy bears to? LOL

[Vendetta52]

yeah I didn't think so…I bet that will be there next endeavor though.

Yea sorry about that, meant to put frozen greek yogurt in there but was distracted at work hah.

[VmissileX]

Aww man you know what I really love.
A nice cold slab of ice cream on a nice hot brownie(even protein based brownie).

I wish there was an easier way to make the brownie or else this would my breakfast every morning.

[Chadillac2000]

REVIEW: Jeni's limited edition Loveless Biscuits + Peach Jam almost became my favorite ice cream.

http://www.theicecreaminformant.com/...its-peach.html

[usawinston]

REVIEW: Jeni's limited edition Loveless Biscuits + Peach Jam almost became my favorite ice cream.

http://www.theicecreaminformant.com/...its-peach.html

[img]http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-4zIPvqNs0kg/UoQINysNtjI/AAAAAAAAQhI/D38Tl_MQJcQ/s1600/02-DSC_3642.JPG[mg]

[img]http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-wWquqPu-sF8/UoQIOoDpM_I/AAAAAAAAQhg/akNrNoUbXGI/s1600/04-DSC_3646.JPG[mg]

I agree with the number 2 spot! I have another pint in my freezer, I've already crushed one earlier this year, and I've had 2 scoops of it at the scoop shop. Insanely good!

[byukid]

BYU Creamery Earnestly Chocolate

Such a fantastic ice cream. BYU has the best, bar none, chocolate base of any ice cream out there.

Base: 9.5/10 (I gotta leave room for something else to blow me away)
Swirl: 9/10 (Perfect caramel and marshmallow, plenty of both)
Mixins: 9/10 (caramel-filled chocolates, and plenty of them both whole and in pieces)
Overall: 9/10

It's definitely up there with PB Trails and Graham Canyon.

[ugasar]

looks pretty freezer burned. was it?

The top layer had some ice crystals on it but I ate it regardless haha.. It did expire October 22, 2013! Also another really small crystal patch midway through, but this was still just as good as always!

Would eat OCC regardless if I got the chance.

^This x 10000000000!!!!

[The Solution]

out of gummy bears to? LOL

not even once.

[jgm815]

Would eat OCC regardless if I got the chance.

I bought some everything but the from a small gas station that was freezer burnt to hell and it didnt even matter...those mix ins were so good that the freezer burnt ice cream took a back seat

[seamus33]

I bought some everything but the from a small gas station that was freezer burnt to hell and it didnt even matter...those mix ins were so good that the freezer burnt ice cream took a back seat

well, good on you guys. i can't stand it.

[seamus33]

market pantry lemon meringue gelato. B+
i'm already a fan of lemon meringue, so i figured i would like this. it was nice and fluffy, had good flavor, crunchy meringue pieces, and a lemon swirl. i'm gonna start browsing through other market pantry stuff now...

[NotADeltaBravo]

Didn't take pics, but been on a Private Selection kick lately...

New York Pumpkin Cheesecake - D
The base is pretty boring and the cheesecake pieces were chalky and only faintly tasted like cheesecake

Denali Chocolate Peanut Butter Moose Tracks - B-
Not the biggest fan of chocolate bases, but this one wasn't overpowering. Peanut butter cookie dough pieces were plentiful and a nice touch.

Turtle Cashew Crunch - B+
Just dug into this one last night. I like the caramel base and swirl (though I wish the swirl was more prevalent). Fudge swirl and and cashews also good. Solid offering. I'll try to snap some pics of this one when I scoop it next (bought a quart).

[Misctake7]

market pantry lemon meringue gelato. B+
i'm already a fan of lemon meringue, so i figured i would like this. it was nice and fluffy, had good flavor, crunchy meringue pieces, and a lemon swirl. i'm gonna start browsing through other market pantry stuff now...

[IMG]http://i1276.photobucket.com/albums/y464/seamus331/image_zps188fa0e9.jpg/IMG]

[IMG]http://i1276.photobucket.com/albums/y464/seamus331/image_zpsaf21281b.jpg[IMG]

I tried the triple chocolate flavor a month or two ago and was not a fan. I have heard good things about tiramisu though.

[ugasar]

Didn't take pics, but been on a Private Selection kick lately...

New York Pumpkin Cheesecake - D
The base is pretty boring and the cheesecake pieces were chalky and only faintly tasted like cheesecake

Denali Chocolate Peanut Butter Moose Tracks - B-
Not the biggest fan of chocolate bases, but this one wasn't overpowering. Peanut butter cookie dough pieces were plentiful and a nice touch.

Disappointed to hear about the NY Pumpkin Cheesecake.. I was looking into picking that up this weekend! Has anyone else reviewed this or had similar thoughts?

Also, I knew there was a Denali Extreme Moose Tracks that had fudge and mini PB cups.. But I was not aware of there being one with cookie dough in it also!

[seamus33]

I tried the triple chocolate flavor a month or two ago and was not a fan. I have heard good things about tiramisu though.

this is the first one i tried. i think this flavor can get away with being "light" and not super premium, because meringue is light and fluffily anyway.

[Crucifist]

Disappointed to hear about the NY Pumpkin Cheesecake.. I was looking into picking that up this weekend! Has anyone else reviewed this or had similar thoughts?

Also, I knew there was a Denali Extreme Moose Tracks that had fudge and mini PB cups.. But I was not aware of there being one with cookie dough in it also!

Someone else in the thread liked it.

The cookie dough one is called Peanut Butter Moose Tracks and it is bomb. I'm in complete opposition to that B- rating. A- for me. Only drawback is that the base isn't super-premium (still quality though), which isn't as big of a thing for me as it is for some people. Definitely recommended.

[Chadillac2000]

REVIEW: The Fresh Market Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice

http://www.theicecreaminformant.com/...kin-spice.html

[psychodiver9]

Talenti Fudge Brownie. Bish. Should just be called fudge. Good base but do you even mix in?

Trader Joe s'more sandwiches were pretty good B+

[Dre4]

Talenti Fudge Brownie. Bish. Should just be called fudge. Good base but do you even mix in?

Hopefully my pint is better whenever i get my hands on it.

Scooped publix cherry cheesecake, giving it a B+. Cherry flavor became a bit too much after a couple spoonfuls, graham cracker pieces were nice.

[psychodiver9]

^ would be interested in trying that as a pint. Don't really want a whole carton. None of their current seasonals are jumping out at me.

Just don't expect to be wowed by the fudge brownie

[ugasar]

Talenti Fudge Brownie. Bish. Should just be called fudge. Good base but do you even mix in?

Thought it was pretty good, but then again I had a pretty decent amount of mix-ins!

Scooped publix cherry cheesecake, giving it a B+. Cherry flavor became a bit too much after a couple spoonfuls, graham cracker pieces were nice.

I agree with you here.. This flavor was shockingly good to me, but I can see what you are saying about it being overly sweet!

[Goalie_Girl]

Ben and Jerry's Greek Frozen Yogurt Banana Peanut Butter Swirl





Yum, possibly my new favorite ice cream ever. I like the reduced guilt feeling that comes with the frozen yogurt territory. The added tang to the taste and protein content are just even more of a bonus. When I cracked open the pint I was a little apprehensive staring at the plain white surface. The first psoonful reveals a true tasting banana base. Its sweet and chock full of banana flavor with no fakenss about it. There is something that makes me keep wanting more and more. And then comes in the peanut butter swirl. I picked this pint because I knew it would be a favorite with combining a few of my favorite things and it is. The peanut butter swirl is sweet and nutty and tasty. It could be a little more thick and prevalent but no real complaints here. I really enjoy this stuff. A suggested improvement would be a graham cracker type or cinnamon mix in. But still solid top 3 for me. A

Haagen-Dazs Peppermint Bark Ice Cream





Thank goodness these are limited edition or I'd be slamming them year round. The cut keeps me in restriction well enough though. Opening this ice cream you san see the mix ins in abundance clearly displayed at the surface. The ice cream itself is smooth, sweet, creamy, and mildly minty. The mix ins are plentiful and tasty. The peppermint pieces give great color and textre to the ice cream while amping up the mint taste. I love the grainy crunch of peppermint in the soft creamy base. The chocolate bark pieces are mottled white and dark choclate and are of good size and very tasty. A

[ugasar]

Haagen-Dazs Peppermint Bark Ice Cream

I swear if I don't find that this year...

[Chadillac2000]

REVIEW: Trader Joe's Pecan Pie Super Premium

http://www.theicecreaminformant.com/...pecan-pie.html