** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread -- Round 2 **

[Jevice]

Well yea if a store near me carried that I would be all over it. So jealous of the people who had have it, it looks awesome.

Blue Bunny is the non super premium version of 2nd street so I'd go with that over B&J's

[chillaxbroseph]

I know we have all beat this dead...but what a colossal mistake on BnJs part. Their flavor changes lately have been really unfortunate.

No kidding. The fact that we all have rows of Pina Colada sitting in the freezers of our local grocery stores instead of Candy Bar Pie speaks to how bad things have been. Troll move of the year though was resurrecting White Russian in my opinion. The only way things could get worse is if they discontinued a forum favorite like WAC to make Key Lime Pie a permanent member of the B&J's family. At this point I honestly wouldn't even be surprised.

[The Solution]

Well yea if a store near me carried that I would be all over it. So jealous of the people who had have it, it looks awesome.

Oh it is
Friend in South Carolina found Mississippi Mud Pie at Walmart, so it looks like it may be around the South right now if you guys are looking to pick that up.

[tyler1636]

leave now.

lol thats messed up

[Chadillac2000]

REVIEW: Turkey Hill's limited edition Raspberry Shortcake

http://www.theicecreaminformant.com/...shortcake.html





FREEZER FINDS: McConnell's Winter Cranberry Chip (along with Pumpkin Pie, Peppermint Stick and Egg Nog.

http://www.theicecreaminformant.com/...-chip-and.html

[Misctake7]

B&J Peanut Butter Cup - Still an A+

[AlwaysTryin]

^^ I really didn't rate it that high. A+ for me were CKC, cafe au lait, PB world.

I don't think PB cup is as high (in my ratings at least)

[seamus33]

^^^ i've had all 4 of those mcconnell's flavors except pumpkin pie recently. gotta give them high ratings for quality, but they aren't too exciting.

[Credz]

Breyer's Blast Girl Scout Samoa's






This was good. Really liked the cookie chunks and these are one of my favorite girl scout cookies. Everything blended great together. Definitely would get again

[ybsny]

Breyer's Blast Girl Scout Samoa's
This was good. Really liked the cookie chunks and these are one of my favorite girl scout cookies. Everything blended great together. Definitely would get again

Oddly enough, I agree that this was one of the better Breyer's Blasts. Some of them have the weird texture that Chad's reviews note, but others are actually decent. Of course given the lower calorie amount, they can't stand to par with super premium blends, but they're also not all horrid.

[Misctake7]

^^ I really didn't rate it that high. A+ for me were CKC, cafe au lait, PB world.

I don't think PB cup is as high (in my ratings at least)

I love peanut butter, so that's why it's personally one of my favorite flavors. I do rate PB World above it but I also rate both of them a A+.

[pkahnman]

Talenti Vanilla Bean

A


Wow


Intense vanilla flavor

[jaredmus]

just got my hands on turkey hill pumpkin pie ice cream!
It was on sale for 1.99
Just had a spoonful after PR in the gym, this is good stuff, Very tasty like it a lot better then edy's.
and even better then the Ben and Jerry's

[The Solution]

just got my hands on turkey hill pumpkin pie ice cream!
It was on sale for 1.99
Just had a spoonful after PR in the gym, this is good stuff, Very tasty like it a lot better then edy's.
and even better then the Ben and Jerry's

its by far better than EDY's which is a mediocre brand
this is why i rate Handels, Coldstone, and TH above BnJ

That swirl is insane.

[Dre4]

Talenti Vanilla Bean

A


Wow


Intense vanilla flavor

Seriously? Dont get me wrong, talenti's a great brand and I like vanilla but it didn't blow me away enough to give it an A.

[Vendetta52]

Blue Bunny is the non super premium version of 2nd street so I'd go with that over B&J's

Sounds good, I'll pick it up next time I'm at the store.

B&J Peanut Butter Cup - Still an A+

My #1 flavor, love it. Those are some huge cups at the end, did you save them or were they all at the bottom?

[Credz]

Graeter's Ice Cream is offering free ground shipping on cyber Monday!

[Jevice]

Black Friday deal from Jeni's http://www.jenis.com/holiday-in-the-alps-collection/ you get free shipping on that collection when you enter BFALPS at checkout.

[The Solution]

Black Friday deal from Jeni's http://www.jenis.com/holiday-in-the-alps-collection/ you get free shipping on that collection when you enter BFALPS at checkout.

if it included some of the basic flavors like Dark Chocolate, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, Salted Caramel, Buckeye State i would consider it..
Seasonal flavors like that.. not even once.

[Dre4]

Talenti Fudge Brownie



Base tasted better than most other chocolate bases I've had. Had some decent sized brownies in there, expected them to be the size of the truffles in SSC but they were bigger. Giving it a B+. Worth a second buy.

[seamus33]

if it included some of the basic flavors like Dark Chocolate, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, Salted Caramel, Buckeye State i would consider it..
Seasonal flavors like that.. not even once.

some of the seasonal flavors look good.

[Jevice]

some of the seasonal flavors look good.

All except the pumpernickel flavor sound good to me.

[The Solution]

some of the seasonal flavors look good.

was not a fan of the Sweet Potato/Marshmallow or Pumpkin from them.
and i do not like eggnog or anything along those lines (pumpernickel etc) just not my thing.

[usawinston]

was not a fan of the Sweet Potato/Marshmallow or Pumpkin from them.
and i do not like eggnog or anything along those lines (pumpernickel etc) just not my thing.

going tonight or tom. definitely getting the ice cream sandwich. as for everything else...we shall see.


sweet potato with torched marshmallows def isn't my favorite

[Credz]

I'm traveling for business these next few days and on the way home there is a Whole Foods. I plan on hitting up the ice cream and picking up some Jeni's Splendid for the first time. What flavors should I pick up? I'm looking forward to it and bringing a cooler with lol.

[psychodiver9]

I'm traveling for business these next few days and on the way home there is a Whole Foods. I plan on hitting up the ice cream and picking up some Jeni's Splendid for the first time. What flavors should I pick up? I'm looking forward to it and bringing a cooler with lol.

Brown butter almond brittle, dark chic, Brambleberry. Avoid salted caramel. But my WF doesn't carry jenni

[The Solution]

Brown butter almond brittle, dark chic, Brambleberry. Avoid salted caramel. But my WF doesn't carry jenni

Salted Carmel was one of my favs
Buckeye state is a must
Queen City cayenne

[psychodiver9]

Salted Carmel was one of my favs
Buckeye state is a must
Queen City cayenne

Hvent had the other two but would buy on sight

[Credz]

Thanks guys! Definitely want to get Bramble Berry and Buckeye if they have it!

[TearsOfIce]

I left all the cookies at the end...compared to the last one, this one had definitely way more pieces. OMG, delicious!!