** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread -- Round 2 **

[bambam601]

market pantry strawberry cheesecake



pretty meh.
cheesecake base was ok, but the graham cracker swirl was pretty nonexistent and i'm not a fan of frozen fruit in my ice cream.


market pantry s'mores



this one was better.
choc and marshmallow base were pretty good, but it still lacked that graham cracker swirl.


talenti sea salt caramel gelato pop



small but pretty good.
just their sea salt caramel base coated in choc.

[ErickStevens]

You guys already know how this one ends but here's my CBP review: http://poweredbyicecream.com/blog/20...candy-bar-pie/

[bartosh]

Candybar pie. Is it worth driving 20 miles to a scoop shop for? All i need is a few yays or nays and I'm on my way

[jubjubrsx]

Candybar pie. Is it worth driving 20 miles to a scoop shop for? All i need is a few yays or nays and I'm on my way

I'm the odd ball out but me personally i'd say no.....but i'd bet that 99% of people here would say yes! and some would drive twice that for it.

[Crucifist]

Candybar pie. Is it worth driving 20 miles to a scoop shop for? All i need is a few yays or nays and I'm on my way

Do you like PB and sweet/salty (especially if you are a Chubby Hubby fan)? If so, I'd do it. Bring a thermal bag and take a hand-packed pint for the road. Or you can wait until the retail version pops up on shelves near you...

[The Solution]

Candybar pie. Is it worth driving 20 miles to a scoop shop for? All i need is a few yays or nays and I'm on my way

Yes
It is godly

[ErickStevens]

Candybar pie. Is it worth driving 20 miles to a scoop shop for? All i need is a few yays or nays and I'm on my way

Yes.

[ugasar]

Candybar pie. Is it worth driving 20 miles to a scoop shop for? All i need is a few yays or nays and I'm on my way

Yea, it is that good and I haven't even had it in a pint yet! Seriously?!?! 20 minutes isn't far at all.. Shoot, I've driven way further than that for ice cream before!

[mussina123]

Yea, it is that good and I haven't even had it in a pint yet! Seriously?!?! 20 minutes isn't far at all.. Shoot, I've driven way further than that for ice cream before!

#icecreamaddictsunited im right there with yah haha

[Ricastle]

sweet sammies y'all.. mmm

[mordei]

Was so surprised at how good this was. Actually tasted very much like a cinnamon bun, and check out those swirls :O

Edy's cinnamon bun was the ice cream that made me realize how good a cinnamon swirl could be. Every pint I've had of that one had the best swirls, probably a top 3 definitely top 5 imo

[psychodiver9]

The package has been secured!

E I would love a shirt with that logo. Any plans?

[ugasar]

Publix was stocked! Yet I somehow refrained from buying it BECAUSE the salesperson told me either this week or next will be B1G1.. YEAH BUDDAYYY!!!





Also, for all of you Blue Bell bros (Bambam???) out there! This should be pretty interesting for September..
http://cdn.bluebell.com/the_little_c...ress_msic.html

[bambam601]

Also, for all of you Blue Bell bros (Bambam???) out there! This should be pretty interesting for September..
http://cdn.bluebell.com/the_little_c...ress_msic.html

well definitely pick that one up! hopefully it does not disappoint.
they're regular choc base is pretty average imo, but choc malt could be a whole notha story.

[psychodiver9]

TJ Chocolate Mochi. C. Will not rebuy. Don't care for the doughy texture.

[Vendetta52]

You should do as I did and write in to TH to tell them this and request that they make this either a regular flavor or regular seasonal flavor.

Hey man, I just got a letter from Turkey Hill thanking me for contacting them and saying what I said and they gave me like 6 coupons for $1 off ice cream pints, 4 coupons for $1 off turkey hill drinks, and another $1 off any TH product....talk about customer satisfaction! Hah, I'll be set for awhile with the Banana PB flavor. They also included a listing of their seasonal offerings, both new and recurring. Apparently for October-December they are coming out with a Froyo flavor that's Greek Sea Salt Caramel Truffle. I'm definitely picking up a container of that, it sounds too good to be true.

Coldstone PB Cake = Godlike. Highly suggest.

Can confirm, in HS and college I always had one for my birthday and it was glorious (not the whole thing in one sitting of course).

On a side note: Has anyone had Trader Joe's Peanut Butter Tracks ice cream? I saw it in the TJ's near me after work but didn't pick it up as I was not sure how it would compare to the benchmark of B&J PB Cup.

[The Solution]

Can confirm, in HS and college I always had one for my birthday and it was glorious (not the whole thing in one sitting of course).

On a side note: Has anyone had Trader Joe's Peanut Butter Tracks ice cream? I saw it in the TJ's near me after work but didn't pick it up as I was not sure how it would compare to the benchmark of B&J PB Cup.

Mom got one for me a while ago when i was still in college. had a slice on my bday, then put in freezer and said she would have a slice and give one to my grandma

every weekend i came home nobody touched it
yeah i crushed that whole cake too haha

Comes out to 500 kcals a slice

[Vendetta52]

Mom got one for me a while ago when i was still in college. had a slice on my bday, then put in freezer and said she would have a slice and give one to my grandma

every weekend i came home nobody touched it
yeah i crushed that whole cake too haha

Comes out to 500 kcals a slice

That's it! I love that cake haha. That's too funny about the cake remaining untouched in the freezer. I modify mine to get vanilla ice cream with PB cups and a PB ripple on the inside because I'm not a fan of chocolate ice cream, and it makes the cake even better. I have not had it in forever but I may need to order one "just because" hah.

[jubjubrsx]

damn any $$$ shots of that cake bob?

I got the cake as a reward to myself...kind of makes me wanna sign up for another marathon as an excuse to reward myself again lol.

[jaredmus]

still can't find candy bar pie may try target tmrw

[Crucifist]

Hey man, I just got a letter from Turkey Hill thanking me for contacting them and saying what I said and they gave me like 6 coupons for $1 off ice cream pints, 4 coupons for $1 off turkey hill drinks, and another $1 off any TH product....talk about customer satisfaction! Hah, I'll be set for awhile with the Banana PB flavor. They also included a listing of their seasonal offerings, both new and recurring. Apparently for October-December they are coming out with a Froyo flavor that's Greek Sea Salt Caramel Truffle. I'm definitely picking up a container of that, it sounds too good to be true.

Nice! I got that little package as well. Glad I didn't buy my Banana PB stock before those came in the mail...


Still no CBP for me. I hate you all.

[Vendetta52]

Nice! I got that little package as well. Glad I didn't buy my Banana PB stock before those came in the mail...


Still no CBP for me. I hate you all.

Good to hear! I need to check the stores around me for CBP. I'm sure Wegmans has it but it's not that close to Philly, would need to bring a cooler and some ice.

[The Solution]

damn any $$$ shots of that cake bob?

I got the cake as a reward to myself...kind of makes me wanna sign up for another marathon as an excuse to reward myself again lol.

Just Choc/PB layers basically, its very very dense in flavor. Highly suggest it.

[Crucifist]

Good to hear! I need to check the stores around me for CBP. I'm sure Wegmans has it but it's not that close to Philly, would need to bring a cooler and some ice.

As always, I recommend a thermal bag if possible. Dirt cheap and works like a charm.

[sofocused978]

Pretty funny that B&J's social media team is denying the existence of CBP in pints. Has anybody had any luck with the flavor locator on their site?

[ugasar]

As always, I recommend a thermal bag if possible. Dirt cheap and works like a charm.

^This or a styrofoam cooler works better than your typical plastic one!

[Vendetta52]

As always, I recommend a thermal bag if possible. Dirt cheap and works like a charm.

Those things work? I've seen them in Wegmans for like $5-6 for a big one but never got one. I got a cooler but it's not the best. I may have to pick up one of those bags, thanks for suggesting it!

[seamus33]

Pretty funny that B&J's social media team is denying the existence of CBP in pints. Has anybody had any luck with the flavor locator on their site?

nope.

[Jevice]

Pretty funny that B&J's social media team is denying the existence of CBP in pints. Has anybody had any luck with the flavor locator on their site?

The flavor locator won't help because all their limited editions have the same upc code so you wouldn't be able to tell if they have candy bar pie or a different limited edition flavor in stock. That's why they were crowd sourcing locations for the other limited batches like cannoli and scotchy scotch scotch. When they announce that cbp is in pints, I'm sure they'll set one of those up again.

[The Solution]

Those things work? I've seen them in Wegmans for like $5-6 for a big one but never got one. I got a cooler but it's not the best. I may have to pick up one of those bags, thanks for suggesting it!

Small Cooler + Ice
worked a charm for me bringing back 5 pints from Columbus (3.5-4 hour trip)
no problems with the ice cream melting at all.