** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread -- Round 2 **

[bambam601]

my goodness bam...that high road jokester looks absolutely insane with mixins..almost looks like just mixins no ice cram lol

ha i definitely think the ratio is in the favor of mixins than ice cream, but didn't mind it.
i wonder if every pint is like that.

[mussina123]

Wegmans PB & J

Any PB & J lover would absolutely love this, but imo the pb base wasn't as strong as BJ or HD, and lacked mixins (pb cups or swirl would definitely enhance this flavor).. i'd give this a B

[byukid]

So the new rule is only one picture per flavor of ice cream, ever. Since they are all the same, needing more than one picture is unnecessary. After all, this is an encyclopedia of ice creams, not some sort of discussion thread. And reposting the same picture of CBP you've had a dozen times is somehow less obnoxious than pic quoting I guess.

[Crucifist]

I had two servings of Turkey Hill's Limited Edition Banana ice cream with PB&Co PB and it's really good! Like, I'm thinking it's tied with B&J's PB Cup for my favorite ice cream overall. I know you guys will be like what is this guy smoking but I just really enjoy PB and this flavor had a ton of it. The last pic is solely PB on my spoon and no ice cream, it was pure bliss. I never thought I would enjoy a TH flavor as much as I did this one.

You should do as I did and write in to TH to tell them this and request that they make this either a regular flavor or regular seasonal flavor.

[ugasar]

I have 3 coupons for Steve's

Thinking banana pudding , cinnamon coffee and Mexican chili?

Definitely get the Banana Pudding, I thought it was really good.. Shocked me actually!
I haven't had Sunday Morning, but hear that's pretty good.. So that's what I would try to get also!

So the new rule is only one picture per flavor of ice cream, ever. Since they are all the same, needing more than one picture is unnecessary. After all, this is an encyclopedia of ice creams, not some sort of discussion thread. And reposting the same picture of CBP you've had a dozen times is somehow less obnoxious than pic quoting I guess.

Why?!? This is an ice cream thread.. I want to see the pictures, at least that's what I come here for! Yeah I post my reviews and may go a little overboard at times, but you simply don't have to read or just scroll past the pictures.. I don't know, maybe I'm the only one like this, but the more the better for me anyway

[Crucifist]

Why?!? This is an ice cream thread.. I want to see the pictures, at least that's what I come here for! Yeah I post my reviews and may go a little overboard at times, but you simply don't have to read or just scroll past the pictures.. I don't know, maybe I'm the only one like this, but the more the better for me anyway

I believe he's being facetious. This thread would be pretty dead if we did that.

[Anaerobics]

Mint chocolate chip.....mmmmm

[MrM27]

Definitely get the Banana Pudding, I thought it was really good.. Shocked me actually!
I haven't had Sunday Morning, but hear that's pretty good.. So that's what I would try to get also!




Why?!? This is an ice cream thread.. I want to see the pictures, at least that's what I come here for! Yeah I post my reviews and may go a little overboard at times, but you simply don't have to read or just scroll past the pictures.. I don't know, maybe I'm the only one like this, but the more the better for me anyway

Sunday morning is actually pretty awesome in my opinion. Worth a shot.
Salted caramel is great. But I'm partial to caramel.

I also agree with you about the pictures. 1 picture limit? Talk about uptight.

[psychodiver9]

Itt Bob gonna Bob and sarcasm not even once

[ErickStevens]

Coolhaus Chocolate PB Sammich A+ I forgot the actual name of this but it was fuking AMAZING.
Coolhaus Dirty Mint Chip B- I ate this after the sammich and that was a big mistake. It's hard to follow up that one.

[Crucifist]

Picked up a container of this stuff early this morning:



Low expectations, but we will see. In general this brand looks a bit underwhelming, but this flavor has a number of elements that greatly appeal to my personal tastes and it was on sale. The base itself is flavored, which usually helps me to take a risk on iffier looking ice creams. Will report back once I finish off my current large container project in a couple of days.

Note: At 170 cals per serving so we are not looking at super premium ice cream by a long shot. I'm not a snob about that sort of thing but when it comes to pb flavors it often means the pb taste is a bit weak. We shall see.

[The Solution]

Definitely get the Banana Pudding, I thought it was really good.. Shocked me actually!
I haven't had Sunday Morning, but hear that's pretty good.. So that's what I would try to get also!

Already had SM (review in here and ICI webpage)

Yeah Banana Pudding for sure. Salted Caramel that something i will consider
see whats in stock.

[kohlerbear]

mother of god.jpeg

[MasonSmith]

I work in an ice cream production plant and get to try hundreds of flavors, im pretty basic though anything with peanut butter ripple or cups is my favorite

[jubjubrsx]

I work in an ice cream production plant and get to try hundreds of flavors, im pretty basic though anything with peanut butter ripple or cups is my favorite

damn if i worked at a ice cream prod plant...i have a feeling i'd be 300lbs or fired really quick.

[bambam601]

damn if i worked at a ice cream prod plant...i have a feeling i'd be 300lbs or fired really quick.

they'd wait until you hit 300 then fire you, the double whammy.

[MasonSmith]

damn if i worked at a ice cream prod plant...i have a feeling i'd be 300lbs or fired really quick.

trust me it gets old, i barely touch the stuff anymore

[Crucifist]

Favorite ice cream ever? lolol sorry had to laugh

Why? If Banana+PB is a passion of his the competition in the ice cream scene isn't exactly fierce. Who else has an offering right now? I know BnJ's had their Greek Froyo (discontinued) which was "okay" at best and although it was a frozen dessert it wasn't actually ice cream.

[pkahnman]

Why? If Banana+PB is a passion of his the competition in the ice cream scene isn't exactly fierce. Who else has an offering right now? I know BnJ's had their Greek Froyo (discontinued) which was "okay" at best and although it was a frozen dessert it wasn't actually ice cream.

I guess if you really like banana/pb

[seamus33]

I guess if you really like banana/pb

who doesn't?

[MrM27]

Pkahnman, have you picked up any of the Fairway brand stuff yet?

[Vendetta52]

You should do as I did and write in to TH to tell them this and request that they make this either a regular flavor or regular seasonal flavor.

Done, hopefully it becomes a regular flavor.

Favorite ice cream ever? lolol sorry had to laugh

its good but not that great

It's tied for it, and Talenti and 2nd Street Creamery is an extremely close second with their sea salt caramel. Besides, not everyone has the same tastes and PB and banana is a great combo I enjoy.

Why? If Banana+PB is a passion of his the competition in the ice cream scene isn't exactly fierce. Who else has an offering right now? I know BnJ's had their Greek Froyo (discontinued) which was "okay" at best and although it was a frozen dessert it wasn't actually ice cream.

B&J's Greek Froyo was a big let down for me, the GY overpowered everything else. TH's is a solid flavor and so far wins the banana+PB combo for me. Does anyone else offer it?

[mussina123]

Candy Bar Pie spotted at my local supercenter Walmart

[pkahnman]

Pkahnman, have you picked up any of the Fairway brand stuff yet?

I tried the caramel toffee (i think that's it) which was pretty good but something was off about it. gave it a solid B though

Thinking about trying the moose tracks next

[MrM27]

I tried the caramel toffee (i think that's it) which was pretty good but something was off about it. gave it a solid B though

Thinking about trying the moose tracks next

That caramel toffee was the one I was going to buy on Saturday but I put it back and got the Greater's Peach instead. Most likely a bad trade.

[The Solution]

B&J's Greek Froyo was a big let down for me, the GY overpowered everything else. TH's is a solid flavor and so far wins the banana+PB combo for me. Does anyone else offer it?

Banana Peel N from wegmans, has PB Cups.

[pdizzlecity]

That caramel toffee was the one I was going to buy on Saturday but I put it back and got the Greater's Peach instead. Most likely a bad trade.

I liked the Sea Salt Caramel Toffee Crunch. Gave it a solid A. If you get a good pint with lots of mix-ins, it is pretty fantastic. If I make it out to Fairway before Thursday, I'll probably pick up another pint while it's on sale. The mud pie is good (solid B) but nothing to go out of your way to get. None of the other flavors interest me.

Can't wait till CBP pints show up in NYC!

[Crucifist]

B&J's Greek Froyo was a big let down for me, the GY overpowered everything else. TH's is a solid flavor and so far wins the banana+PB combo for me. Does anyone else offer it?

A local creamery by me makes one seasonally, Chocolate Shoppe has one: http://www.chocolateshoppeicecream.com/node/404 , and that is all I can think of. The TH is WAY better though.

[bambam601]

blue bell voting

Hot Fudge Brownie - 21%
German Chocolate Cake - 15%
Coconut Cream Pie - 11%
Cinnamon - 11%
Maple Pecan Swirl - 10%
Pineapple Upside Down Cake - 9%
Peach Amaretto Pecan - 9%
Cherry Cobbler - 8%

looks like all the unique flavors are getting killed off, and maple pecan swirl seems to be next.
guess i'm gonna start voting for hot fudge brownie cuz i'd be pissed if german choc cake won.

[Vendetta52]

Banana Peel N from wegmans, has PB Cups.

I googled it and I'm not a fan of fudge swirls. It's odd, but I only like chocolate when it's paired with peanut butter like in a Reese's cup, plain chocolate on it's own does nothing for me. I may pick it up just to give it a shot though, thanks for making me aware of it. Ever since moving to Philly I don't frequent Wegmans like I used to, I need to change that.

A local creamery by me makes one seasonally, Chocolate Shoppe has one: http://www.chocolateshoppeicecream.com/node/404 , and that is all I can think of. The TH is WAY better though.

Good to hear TH makes it better.