skinny to aesthetic or fat to aesthetic - which do you think is harder and why?

[izeey]

title^

I'd say being skinny to aesthetic is harder.

[SteelSS]

its easier to eat less than to eat more. fat people are dumb as suk

[niiick]

both have their different demons...

[nickh04]

im skinny, and i find it harder than hell to eat more

[Hercul3s]

fat people are dumb as suk

You shut your whore mouth

[Jax05]

I think skinny to aesthetic is harder...especially if you're a skinny-fat. Good luck putting on muscle without adding fat...then having to cut fat and not lose muscle.

[baraaa]

Look at the before pictures of people how managed to look really aesthetic
That should answer your question

[JihadJoe]

gonna go with the one where the lean mass is ALRAEDY there lol.

ever seen a fat persons calvse and abs? rock solid once cut.

[Zacface]

They are equally as difficult to the respective individual involved.

However, 'Skinny to Aesthetic' don't have to worry about excess skin from massive weight gain. 'Fat to Aesthetic' people can have excess skin, stretch marks, and generally more fat cells always craving to be refilled.

[Winzer]

its easier to eat less than to eat more. fat people are dumb as suk

Although I kinda agree I think it's harder for fat people to become aesthetic. Sure they gain mass easier but they rarely achieve low bf without loose skin and they often have weird proportions.

It's easier to have good proportions if you had no muscle at all in the first place.

[shawco]

If you find it hard to eat more go fuk yourself.

[RCAK]

Comparing apples & oranges. Both have their challenges

[vsukicker]

skinny to aesthetic is easier. just fuking lift heavy

[NoWipePoop]

Its really hard for me to even get 2k calories in. Couple years ago I was doing 10miles a day cardio and had to stop cause I could not eat 4k+ calories a day. Mostly because I dont live to eat, I eat to live. I assume thats not the "norm" though.

[jsityo12]

brb need to eat 4k+ to actually gain weight. brb go to sleep for a few hours then set alarm at 3am to eat. brb get sick for a few days and lose 10lbs. Skinny people end up more aesthetic but it take years of perfect dieting to look like you lift.

[rorschachsaysno]

Look at the before pictures of people how managed to look really aesthetic
That should answer your question

True. Those pictures are always people who already built the muscles and just need to lose fat. Skinny to aesthetic takes years, losing fat takes weeks.

[rickyng]

I think overweight to aesthetic is harder. Most people who are overweight have a very hard time eating less food and eating healthy food and have probably tried many many times to lose weight, but can't.

[SquatWombats]

prior fat kent checkin in. forever endo and hard to lose weight

brb putting on 2kg looking at a cookie
brb putting on 3kg touching a cookie
brb putting on 5kg smelling a cookie
brb putting on 15kg eating a cookie

[itsonlysmellzz]

it's harder to go from fat to aesthetic because you have to cut then bulk.
If you're skinny you just have to bulk.

[baraaa]

True. Those pictures are always people who already built the muscles and just need to lose fat. Skinny to aesthetic takes years, losing fat takes weeks.

Wat
The only pro I can think of that was a fat kid is Evan Centopani
Name me one male fitness model that was really fat before their started lifting

[PerthboyxD]

its also cheaper to lose weight

[miscHelix]

I want to say fat to fit. When your really fat its a lifestyle. You have a lot more variables you need to change in your life. That being said both of these are hard as chit.

[jsityo12]

its also cheaper to lose weight

this. bulking as a povkunt in australia not even once. srs I can only afford bulk rice, white potatoes, eggs, and chicken maybe every second day.

edit how long have you been lifting? those lifts are impressive for your weight.

[shawntoronto]

fat to aesthetic easily. There's so many reasons why, but it just is.

skinny fat is just game over right from the start, might as well not even try.

[cle2ric]

prior fat kent checkin in. forever endo and hard to lose weight

brb putting on 2kg looking at a cookie
brb putting on 3kg touching a cookie
brb putting on 5kg smelling a cookie
brb putting on 15kg eating a cookie

These feels i know

[TsarChasm]

In my case gaining weight is easy because I like to eat. Being disciplined and cutting the 1lbs a week for a while is tough. I can confirm. 230 and 17%bf. I have the mass to be really aesthetic once I get down to 10%.

[microsuede]

If you find it hard to eat more go fuk yourself.

Stats: 6'0", 175 lbs
Keep talking that chit once you hit 185 and try to reach 190...

[SkinnyBeast24]

Getting swole starting skinny is harder i dont give a chit what anybody says.

why do we have the biggest loser and all these fat loss shows but no skinny to swole...

b/c it is ****ing hard and takes alot longer

--> and not even close to swole

[TheAlterEgo]

Going from fat. You have to get lean first, then build.

[so far away]

Assuming they're both new to lifting or have had a long hiatus and are getting noob gains:

Commonly you have the 250lb+ fat guy getting to 180-190 and being aesthetic as fuk in like a year with lots of solid muscle mass because most fat guys have a decently solid foundation underneath.

Then you have skinny fat @ 130-140, even if he gains 30-40lbs in the first year of lifting, he still gained quite a bit of fat too and isn't even close to being on the fat guys level. It will take the skinny guy 2+ years to get to 200+ and then cut down and be aesthetic.

Of course yes, the fat people have to worry about stretch marks and loose skin, but I'd still say it's easier for the fat people.