Barbell vs Trap Bar Deadlifts

[pre04]

Is the trap bar deadlift essentially a mix between squats and regular deadlifts? The trap bar takes the stress off the spine, it seems, but isn't the point of deadlifts to target the lower back?

On the other hand, if the trap bar deadlift allows you to lift the most wait, I can see why it would be beneficial.

How do most people incorporate the trap bar into your deadlifting routine?

[Alexandre76]

I do trap bar deadlift first in my back day, i'm curious to know if there's really that big of a difference between the two when it comes to weight usage.

[chazzy1864]

Trap bar deadlift is more akin to a squat than conventional deadlift.

[pre04]

How much more can a person typically lift with the trap bar that straight bar?

[k9pit]

it's basically like performing a DB squat.

[jgreystoke]

it's basically like performing a DB squat.

This.

But it is easier to load it heavy enough, since most gyms don't have very heavy DBs.

[vborn]

Is the trap bar deadlift essentially a mix between squats and regular deadlifts? The trap bar takes the stress off the spine, it seems, but isn't the point of deadlifts to target the lower back?

On the other hand, if the trap bar deadlift allows you to lift the most wait, I can see why it would be beneficial.

How do most people incorporate the trap bar into your deadlifting routine?

I use the Trap-Bar Deadlift when I'm running more of a bodybuilder split and I can't have my lower back be sore for days. It hits my Quads harder than conventional, and doesn't seem to work the spinal muscles as well, so I wouldn't do Trap-Bar forever in place of conventional. There may be less Lats in Trap-Bar too, since you're not pressing the bar into yourself.

[jgreystoke]

Is the trap bar deadlift essentially a mix between squats and regular deadlifts?

Yes. It is a sort of squat like movement where you pull the bar from dead stop on the floor(hence deadlift).

The trap bar takes the stress off the spine, it seems....

Yes it does, uses less back, more leg drive.

.... but isn't the point of deadlifts to target the lower back?

No. The deadlift is not some isolation movement or specialized movement. To target low back strength and development:

Hyperextensions, goodmornings(my favorite).

It is a whole body movement that allows a human with normal skeleton to pull the maximum weight off the floor. The poundage potential is greater even than squat to parallel.

On the other hand, if the trap bar deadlift allows you to lift the most wait, I can see why it would be beneficial.

I don't know if it allows you to use more weight than conventional. But it sure feels easier than stiff leg dead for the same weight and reps.

How do most people incorporate the trap bar into your deadlifting routine?

Just started using it to replace SLDS in my 5 3 1 program(knee issues meant avoiding conventional deads for a long time).

Some people use it to replace squats. Unless there is a compelling reason, that might not be a good idea.

You can make TBD even more of a squat lift by doing deficit trap bar deads. Stand on a 3" platform of plates/plywood and off you go. Much more leg drive required.

Modern trap bars are really cheap. But most of them now have two handle heights. The higher grip allows you to use a ton more weight,because of the reduced ROM. But it uses less leg. So it is like a low rack pull from below the knees, or a deadlift from boxes(the boxes being under the plates).

[anonymous]

when i used to do them I did them pretty much just like deadlifts with the back and PC lifting the weight. I don't understand this 'its like a squat' thing, but I guess it depends how you do the lift.

its a great lift, alternate that, rack pulls and RDLs and you have it all covered BB-wise

[italianplaya30]

trap bar deadlifts mimic closely squats...i would say its good to interchange them

[jgreystoke]

when i used to do them I did them pretty much just like deadlifts with the back and PC lifting the weight. I don't understand this 'its like a squat' thing, but I guess it depends how you do the lift.

The most natural way to lift with you standing inside the bar is to squat the weight up with a more upright spine. Also the grips tend to be wider apart than your hand position for either conventional or sumo on a normal bar. That forces you to use more ROM, usually even more leg, less back.

its a great lift, alternate that, rack pulls and RDLs and you have it all covered BB-wise

That sounds about ideal combination.

[Engineer_Guy]

Trap bar deadlift is basically a leg press with the bar in your hands. Not as good as a squat for leg development and not as good as a conventional deadlift for back development.

[anonymous]

im sure my short legs and long torso affected my leverage, I did have a lot of forward lean when doing them especially with heavier weight.

It's a lift I miss terribly, unfortunately it causes my piriformis syndrome to flare up massively even when done with light weight

[KBKB]

Is the trap bar deadlift essentially a mix between squats and regular deadlifts? The trap bar takes the stress off the spine, it seems, but isn't the point of deadlifts to target the lower back?

I've been doing trap bar deadlifts with 25lb plates as a squat replacement. The smaller diameter plates provide for a greater range of motion. The same effect can be had wiith larger plates by standing on a platform.

[9863]

Sorry to drag up an old thread but it seemed better then making a new one lol
I have the infamous "butt-wink" issue, I put this down to a mobility issue but I have also injured my lower back a few times now (agitation of the discs) according to the doctor.

I find I can do the hex bar deadlift without getting any butt-wink

So my question being could I get the same/similar results doing the hex bar deadlift as opposed to a conventional deadlift?
I understand the HBD to involve more legs & puts less pressure on the spine, but would it still involve the same back recruitment?
Only other way I see of getting around it is doing a conventional deadlift on a platform (kind of like a lower rack pull).

I have a similar issue when trying to do parallel squats which due to that I've swapped out of my routine for leg press machine due to not wanting to agitate my lower back again.

Does anyone have any suggestions in regards to this?
Would it be fine to just continue down the road of doing hex bar deads/leg press instead of conventional deads/back squats with similar results?

Any advice appreciated

Thanks