-
Powerlifting in disguise
Originally Posted by GuyJin
---
This is a good question. I'd answer only from my own personal experience. Doing a shrug at the top of a deadlift WILL work with lighter weights (it's all relative), but once you get into the five-rep range or lower, the pre-exhaustion effect will be in place. That makes your traps more vulnerable, IMHO, to a tear, and this happened once with me a few years back. Tore both trap muscles (actually, strained them really badly) and suffered from spasms and headaches for about three months. Therefore, I'd recommend that if you do the combo, do the deadlifts i.e. the set itself first, and finish off by doing shrugs and do them with lighter weights you can shrug with for about ten to twelve reps. Once the deadlift gets into the five or lower range, deadlift and only that. JMO...
Your shoulders should be tight through the whole dead. Your arms do not just 'hang'. (or should not)
I have gotten 'cocky' and shrugged heavier deads for the heck of it. I would not recommend it though. Some times you get fired up when you can rip up something easier then you thought 
High rep deads really target the traps better then anything. The heavier the better. "heavy" is a relative thing, but you can really punish yourself on some 15 rep even 20 rep deads. Brutal and you will be sore in places you did not even know existed.
I with regular deads, I dont really see the need for shrugs. I get all the stim from deads and rows. Arguably my traps might be one of my best developed parts....and I would have to attribute that do the deads....
"Almost all WILL make progress if they go in the gym and exercise right...regardless. BUT!!!!
How your body adapts to that training stimulus, (gaining mass, strength or both) will be primarily determined by the quality and QUANTITY of your nutrition"-----Me 2012
Journal: http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=133005243
-
Registered User
Originally Posted by induced_drag
Your shoulders should be tight through the whole dead. Your arms do not just 'hang'. (or should not)
I have gotten 'cocky' and shrugged heavier deads for the heck of it. I would not recommend it though. Some times you get fired up when you can rip up something easier then you thought
High rep deads really target the traps better then anything. The heavier the better. "heavy" is a relative thing, but you can really punish yourself on some 15 rep even 20 rep deads. Brutal and you will be sore in places you did not even know existed.
I with regular deads, I dont really see the need for shrugs. I get all the stim from deads and rows. Arguably my traps might be one of my best developed parts....and I would have to attribute that do the deads....
---
Agree with the "stay tight" comment. Relaxing at any time during the dead is a sure recipe for disaster.
Some guys, though, no matter how many deads they do, high or low-rep, will never get that bulging, 'hump' effect to their traps, so they may need a little extra stimulation. Therefore, doing shrugs with lighter (relative to the individual) or upright rows may help a bit more.
"When you're born, you give up one percent of your life. When you die, that's the last one percent. Make the other ninety-eight percent count."--Threadweaver.
"A choice to be made, a price to be paid."--The Tower.
"One hundred percent unfiltered awesome."--Death Bytes.
Check out my links to Death Bytes at DevineDestinies.com, The Tower at Untreedreads.com, and as for Twisted and Lindsay versus the Marauders...wait 'til next year!
-
Powerlifting in disguise
Originally Posted by GuyJin
---
A..matter how many deads they do, high or low-rep, will never get that bulging, 'hump' effect to their traps, so they may need a little extra stimulation..
Yep....like many muscle groups, there are things we can and can not control. How they tie-in will determine a lot of how they develop over time. I have been lucky in this area, so my advice may not be the best. I do know that deads will work them well, but you are right, some guys may need more stimulation.
I think BTO mentioned farmers. That will really work you if you can find a place to do them. I know this from real world (non-training) lifting. Farmers will work the crap out of your traps.
"Almost all WILL make progress if they go in the gym and exercise right...regardless. BUT!!!!
How your body adapts to that training stimulus, (gaining mass, strength or both) will be primarily determined by the quality and QUANTITY of your nutrition"-----Me 2012
Journal: http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=133005243
-
Registered User
Not something I would try, but if you can nail down proper form, power shrugs could be awesome working the traps.
http://www.elitefitness.com/forum/we...ml#post4712284
-
Registered User
+1 on lighter, controlled shrugs. I hate doing them with the barbell because of shoulder impingement, and DB shrugs feel weird, but if you have a shrug bar then they are great.
there are a lot of shrug varients most people should be doing to focus on scapular stability, and straight up and down BB shrugs aren't really high on that list
rack deads, or deads off boxes
rows.
powe shrugs destroy the muscles, but they always felt like they could tear something when I did them.. and let's be honest, if you're shrugging more than you can deadlift then you're doing it wrong. There are some awful (or hilarious) youtube vids of smaller lifters doing power seizures with 700+ lbs that make my RC's and lower back hurt just watching them
-
Hammer time...
Originally Posted by bigtallox
I agree with you, but watch out, the self appointed strongman police, FLEX, will neg you for mentioning stuff like that. Apparently it doesn't matter if there's a bodybuilding benefit or not, guess its blasphemy here or something.
Lol, Then let the news flow!
Originally Posted by EjnarKolinkar
Do you see face pulls as a building movement, or more of an overall conditioning move of the traps, rhomboids, rear shoulder? I don't know that I have explained that question very well, but can't think of a better way to put it. I guess I am just trying to figure out the intensity level you shoot for with face pulls?
I do face pulls at the end of my workouts and I view them as a working exercise....I will start off in the 10-12 rep range for pne set then add weight and move to a 6-8 rep range for 3-4 sets, whoch i consider my working sets. I am an "older" guy that can sling some pretty good weight around and I credit these 100% for keeping my shoulders healthy.
2013 Goals :
Time for a redo.....
5K with my daughter...May 2013
Find some powerlifting comp and compete in the 242's. Goals:
Bench: 460# (Comp)
Squat: 575# (Comp)
-
Registered User
[QUOTE=BLaaR;1026126793]Not something I would try, but if you can nail down proper form, power shrugs could be awesome working the traps.
http://www.elitefitness.com/forum/we...ml#post4712284[/QUOT
I am in on the power shrugs. In conjunction with slower, controlled shrugs (never light; light shrugs are waste of time, IMO), and deads, you should have no trouble developing nice and strong traps.
Ray
"Take heed to yourself and to the doctrine. Continue in them, for in doing this you will deliver both yourself and those who hear you." --1 Tim. 4:16
"Exhaustion weighs ounces; quitting weighs tons." --Chris Morel
-
Registered User
You won't see much trap development though until you're shrugging 400+ lbs so get adding weight!
-
Hammer time...
Originally Posted by JonnoAUS
You won't see much trap development though until you're shrugging 400+ lbs so get adding weight!
I now believe you are either a troll or just plain stupid.
2013 Goals :
Time for a redo.....
5K with my daughter...May 2013
Find some powerlifting comp and compete in the 242's. Goals:
Bench: 460# (Comp)
Squat: 575# (Comp)
-
Registered User
Keep lifting,the weak drink booze!!!
-
Powerlifting in disguise
Originally Posted by flyineagle96
Power cleans are a good one too!!!
Nice
"Almost all WILL make progress if they go in the gym and exercise right...regardless. BUT!!!!
How your body adapts to that training stimulus, (gaining mass, strength or both) will be primarily determined by the quality and QUANTITY of your nutrition"-----Me 2012
Journal: http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=133005243
-
Registered User
At my beginner stage I can only DL 315. Past that my lower back isnt strong enought yet but my upper body has plenty strenght. This is why I do shrugs. At some point my body will even out in strenght and I can drop the shrugs.....but for now finishing off with shrugs completes my needs
-
Registered User
Originally Posted by JimmyJonny
At my beginner stage I can only DL 315. Past that my lower back isnt strong enought yet but my upper body has plenty strenght. This is why I do shrugs. At some point my body will even out in strenght and I can drop the shrugs.....but for now finishing off with shrugs completes my needs
Nothing wrong with a 315 deadlift - that's still a lot of weight for many of us! Good luck on your upcoming surgery.
-
Registered User
I know I don't fit the age for this forum, but this thread showed up on the forum mainpage.
And, well...
<---
Heavy (relative, more than 5 reps =/= heavy) barbell shrugs. Straight up and down. No squeeze.
8 to 10 sets of 1 to 5 reps twice a week.
-
Registered User
Deads
Farmer Carries
Power Cleans
Tire Flip
One arm snatch
Dumbell Burpees
Speed Sumo Deads
Sumo High Pull
https://www.youtube.com/user/DougHollandJr
-
Registered User
Originally Posted by Smelly bull
I now believe you are either a troll or just plain stupid.
Er.....neither. The traps need to be punished. And can handle a HELL of a lot of weight. Bill Starr often said a goal is at least 5 or 6 plates a side. And more.
I used to power shrug with moderate weights - I'm not strong - with around 320-330 for 5 reps. And I always figured 5 reps ala Starr style never builds much muscle anyway.
But from starting out shrugging with half of what i mentioned to using the total above.....zero trap development.
And I knew I was hitting it correctly because I had a deep soreness for days. So kinda figured 400+ lbs would be needed to get some growth.
-
Cold day in hell
Originally Posted by JimmyJonny
At my beginner stage I can only DL 315. Past that my lower back isnt strong enought yet but my upper body has plenty strenght. This is why I do shrugs. At some point my body will even out in strenght and I can drop the shrugs.....but for now finishing off with shrugs completes my needs
A 3 plate DL as a begginer is actually impressive.
I can't hit the bottom, but I can sure bang the hell out of the sides!!!
-
Registered User
Originally Posted by jd2967
I know I don't fit the age for this forum, but this thread showed up on the forum mainpage.
And, well...
<---
Heavy (relative, more than 5 reps =/= heavy) barbell shrugs. Straight up and down. No squeeze.
8 to 10 sets of 1 to 5 reps twice a week.
We have a winner!
-!!!---!!!-No Excuses Homemade Equipment Crew #17-!!!---!!!-
DSC
ironsanctuary.com
"Weakness is not going to the gym. Once you go to the gym, there are only different levels of strength." -Bando
-
Hammer time...
Originally Posted by JonnoAUS
Er.....neither. The traps need to be punished. And can handle a HELL of a lot of weight. Bill Starr often said a goal is at least 5 or 6 plates a side. And more.
I used to power shrug with moderate weights - I'm not strong - with around 320-330 for 5 reps. And I always figured 5 reps ala Starr style never builds much muscle anyway.
But from starting out shrugging with half of what i mentioned to using the total above.....zero trap development.
And I knew I was hitting it correctly because I had a deep soreness for days. So kinda figured 400+ lbs would be needed to get some growth.
No, no muscle needs to be punished, that is a stupid mentality. Pushed, yes. Punished, no.
5x5 doesn't build much muscle? Holy shiat! Then you quote Bill Starr, the king of mass and strength....who invented the 5x5 programs... 5x5 programs build huge mass and huge strength...That is why so many programs have copied Starr.
The problem with your posts is your blindly making statements like "3000 calories will make you fat" or "400# for big traps" or even better, "5x5 doesn't build much muscle". You have much to learn, I would sit back, read and hit the journals before you start making these types of statements.
2013 Goals :
Time for a redo.....
5K with my daughter...May 2013
Find some powerlifting comp and compete in the 242's. Goals:
Bench: 460# (Comp)
Squat: 575# (Comp)
-
Registered User
I hated dead for years and didn't do them. just in the last couple weeks I started doing them again with my kids. we use a Hex bar. your hands stay down to your side more like a dumbbell shrug. I can rep 350 8 times and then after a couple sets of them I did a one rep max of 395. I thought that wasn't bad for only two weeks doing them again. I can see improvement in my traps already. since my shoulder surgery I can't reach back for conventional squats so I gave them up and have been looking for a good alternative. the Hex bar is the way to go in my case.
Yetti
"you're not good enough to be disappointed!"
Dan John
-
Registered User
I loved to try deads but with my bad knees( to many tears , and needing surgery in the right ) is there a way to try deads and not put a ton of pressure on the knees.
-
Do I Even Lift?
I have bad knees also, I do rack pulls... just set the pins to knee height and pull it from there.
My dopey journal http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=141352341
NJ Crew (856)................. Do you even lift, no seriously do you? crew.....type 2 Diabeetus crew
-
Da1UnV
<----- Count this guy in that deads do nothing for my traps.
I have to hit them more directly with shrugs and farmers and upright rows.
Deads just don't stimulate my traps enough to make them grow.
I AM THE DANGER, I AM THE ONE WHO KNOCKS!
That's it. I am bringing you up on charges ~ Eomrat.
-
No longer in denial
Originally Posted by Brosynthesis
Going to be 100% with you.
Fapping.
I am serious.
I don't work out traps, but I do fap a lot, so my conclusion is that fapping made them grow.
Edit: this isnt the misc, is it? Bb.com mobile doesnt show categories. Sorry guys if this isnt misc.
Ahahahahahaha...if this were true I'd look like Jim Wendler when he was fat.
(semisrs)
"The Internet is the first thing that humanity has built that humanity doesn't understand, the largest experiment in anarchy that we have ever had."
Eric Schmidt
-
Registered User
DB shrugs and DB upright rows seem to hit my traps better than any other movements.
-
Supreme Tiger lifter
Originally Posted by mtpockets
Aside from deads,
Farmers and shrugs
I do a combo.....
get a comfortable weight
Farmer walk it, when you stop, rep out the shrugs
without putting the weight down do this 3 times.
Farmers and Shrugs for the win! I do farmers all the time and am the only person that does them, or at least I never see anyone else ever doing them. Have even had people ask me wtf i'm doing and when I explain they thank me and claim they will try them but never do. Our db's only go to #145 but that's ok since I can't make a complete lap of the gym without my grip giving out while using those anyways. The #120's are plenty for now but then when I started out 3 yrs ago I could barely use the 70's.
And I honestly credit shrugs as well as behind the back shrugs with my trap development so far. Start out with 135 and work up to 405, what's weird though is I can only do 5 reps with the bar in front before my grip gives out whereas with the bar behind me I can do 10 reps with 405.
Don`t forget Detroit is like ummmm Baghdad without all the glitter ....Thomas Henry
-
CARLMAN
As for any muscle I will always believe in direct work for maximum benefit. Since upright rows, deadlifts, face pulls etc... should already be in the "plan" of training sessions already..... I'm going to have to say shruggs are going to help build them even that much more.
Every day counts.
-[][][]---------[][][]-
I has a PHmuthaf'nD in Broscience!
ntrllftr > azstrengthlosscouchpotato
-
Hora e Sempre
heavy squats, FRONT SQUATS, deads and POWER CLEANS. anything else is just run of the mill bull chit
**Dallas Cowboys**
Follow on Instigram for bulking meals @mrbradfarmer
-
CARLMAN
Originally Posted by y0lked
heavy squats, FRONT SQUATS, deads and POWER CLEANS. anything else is just run of the mill bull chit
Did you even read the question by the OP
Every day counts.
-[][][]---------[][][]-
I has a PHmuthaf'nD in Broscience!
ntrllftr > azstrengthlosscouchpotato
-
Registered User
Big traps aren't all they are cracked up to be..... I have to carry my bags in my hands now cause the strap just keeps sliding off.
Y U NO COME TO IRON-SANCTUARY.COM???
Similar Threads
-
By Ravskie in forum Teen Bodybuilding
Replies: 9
Last Post: 11-09-2012, 06:35 AM
-
By Merc009 in forum Exercises
Replies: 61
Last Post: 04-21-2012, 09:36 AM
-
By newbodybuilder2 in forum Misc.
Replies: 100
Last Post: 03-10-2009, 08:35 PM
-
By FWCMuZiK in forum Exercises
Replies: 41
Last Post: 08-27-2008, 10:25 AM
-
By welterracer in forum Workout Programs
Replies: 36
Last Post: 05-08-2006, 06:17 PM
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
Forum Rules
|
Bookmarks