** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread **

[Gemuadrken]

How people rate BCG above PB world blows my mind..

PB World >>>>>>>>> BCG by a mile.

For me it often depends on what i'm in the mood for. That being said I don't know if i'll have BCG again, tons of brownies is so similar and so better

[Chadillac2000]

REVIEW: The new Nutter Butter MilkQuake from Krystal

http://www.theicecreaminformant.com/...milkquake.html

[ugasar]

Going by a B&J scoop shop for the first time this weekend. Definitely looking to pick up a pint of C7LB. I also saw on their website that they have a chocolate peanut buttery swirl flavor. Has anyone tried this and if so, is it worth a pick up? I realize it's rather basic in comparison to some of the other pb flavors, but I'm still thinking about it since their milk chocolate base is fantastic and I haven't seen it in any stores before.

I did a mini review of the peanut buttery swirl a couple of months ago.. Although I though it was pretty good & worth a scoop, it is like crucifist and gemuadrken said being PB World minus the cookie mix-in.. Definitely go with PB World if you can get your hands on that!

http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showth...post1026828553

with all the occ talk, i decided to dig into my pint today.

last time i had this, i was thoroughly unimpressed. but supposedly i had a bum pint.
this time was different, i feel like i had pretty decent pint this go around.
with a better pint i gave it a better rating, but still its not even in my b&j top 15.



no luck but i found b&j truffle trifecta. i know it doesnt get great reviews around here but figured i should try it out for myself.
at least i got a dollar off tho

That's crazy! OCC is easily my #1 favorite offered by B&J.. Although I've only tried it once, it absolutely blew me away!

I also can't wait to find that Truffle Trifecta (just for the sake of trying it also).. Lucky find my friend! brb checking Walgreens everyday!!!

[ErickStevens]

As far as the Scoop Shop flavors go, PB Chocolate Swirl is pretty "Meh". I wish they still had Cinnamon Cereal Swirl.

[Crucifist]

As far as the Scoop Shop flavors go, PB Chocolate Swirl is pretty "Meh". I wish they still had Cinnamon Cereal Swirl.

Never got to try that one, which is a shame because it sounded promising.

[Robboe]

As far as the Scoop Shop flavors go, PB Chocolate Swirl is pretty "Meh". I wish they still had Cinnamon Cereal Swirl.

I enjoyed that one also. The spumoni flavor they had needs some work though, the choco overpowered everything.

[Robboe]

I don't often re-purchase Jeni's flavors I've already tried, but when I do, they tend to contain nuts... Or mint and white chocolate... Or dark chocolate... Or coffee... Or fruit... Err...

[LichtS]

I don't often re-purchase Jeni's flavors I've already tried, but when I do, they tend to contain nuts... Or mint and white chocolate... Or dark chocolate... Or coffee... Or fruit... Err...

Call me weird but I did not enjoy this flavor and I'm a huge PB and chocolate fan. It was meh.

[ErickStevens]

Call me weird but I did not enjoy this flavor and I'm a huge PB and chocolate fan. It was meh.

[emtvstheworld]

Tried Blue Bell Key Lime Pie, Blue Bell Cotton Candy, B&J's cotton candy today. I'm not a key lime pie fan. My fiancé LOVES KLP, so that's why I grabbed it. I thought it was better than the B&J's version purely on the massive graham cracker pieces. The BB cotton candy tastes JUST like cotton candy. Not a huge CC fan, but if you like CC, it's perfect for you. The B&J's CC I could barely taste the CC flavor. Was more of a nerds kinda vibe overall.

Picked up Rockslide Brownie and Blue Bunny White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookie today. Scooping Blue Bunny tomorrow. Tried a spoonful of Rockslide Brownie and it is great! Saving that for a day I can fit a bunch in for the day haha.

[kyle450rider]

I just got back from my local WalMart. They had a full isle of B&J's cotton candy. Not a single pint had been sold. Chocolate peanut butter cup had 2 left and Halfbaked was the second most sold there. I just don't understand the cotton candy flavor. Not one that I'll try on my own dime ever.

[kidkindacool]

Fixed

[Gemuadrken]

I just got back from my local WalMart. They had a full isle of B&J's cotton candy. Not a single pint had been sold. Chocolate peanut butter cup had 2 left and Halfbaked was the second most sold there. I just don't understand the cotton candy flavor. Not one that I'll try on my own dime ever.

I actually want to try his flavor. I don't like cotton candy in its own; but am curious as to how the flavor will taste

[kidkindacool]

The peanut butter cup variation side by side.


Chocolate peanut butter cup-
B
The pint says chocolate peanut butter ice cream but unfortunately I did not get much of the peanut butter flavor through the dominant chocolate flavoring that BnJs recipe carries. What makes this pint stand is the sheer size and quantity of cups. These aren't just halves but a mix of halves and wholes but it had me wanting more peanut butter less chocolate.





Peanut butter cup
A
What can I say I love peanut butter. This completely delivered. The base is strong and the cups dip into it perfectly with just the right amount of chocolate coming from the cups. The pint wasn't shy with the candy pieces and sure wasn't shy with the peanut base.

[Chadillac2000]

I actually want to try his flavor. I don't like cotton candy in its own; but am curious as to how the flavor will taste

Same.

[bambam601]

with it being hot as phuck right now in ms, i go into this old ass gas station just to pick up a bottle of water.
like always i go by the freezer section and i see 3 pumpkin cheesecakes! i had to get all 3.
2 finds in one day. but actually one im proud of.

[Robboe]

Call me weird but I did not enjoy this flavor and I'm a huge PB and chocolate fan. It was meh.

It is unusual as it leans more towards the savory, but the back note sweetness from the honey that pokes through is ingenious.

[ugasar]

Chocolate peanut butter cup
B
The pint says chocolate peanut butter ice cream but unfortunately I did not get much of the peanut butter flavor through the dominant chocolate flavoring that BnJs recipe carries. What makes this pint stand is the sheer size and quantity of cups. These aren't just halves but a mix of halves and wholes but it had me wanting more peanut butter less chocolate.

Peanut butter cup
A
What can I say I love peanut butter. This completely delivered. The base is strong and the cups dip into it perfectly with just the right amount of chocolate coming from the cups. The pint wasn't shy with the candy pieces and sure wasn't shy with the peanut base.

Definitely agree with your reviews.. Chocolate PB Cup sounded great at first but did not deliver!

I actually want to try his flavor. I don't like cotton candy in its own; but am curious as to how the flavor will taste

^^^THIS!!


On another note, I cracked into my PB World pint today (will have review up sometime tomorrow probably). Based off of scooping the first half of the pint, I am in agreement with the everyone who favors it over WAC.. Will scoop the other half tomorrow to confirm! I look forward to following it up with Brownie Chewgooder as well since many seem to be debating which one is the best Target exclusive..

[AlwaysTryin]

Went back to that place in Philly that I got the OCC at and saw they had more.... To get another or have 2nd st tons of brownies...






Jealous of pumpkin cheesecake too

[emtvstheworld]

Went back to that place in Philly that I got the OCC at and saw they had more.... To get another or have 2nd st tons of brownies...
Jealous of pumpkin cheesecake too

Jealous. I really wanna try OCC

[Bad Meets Evil]

with it being hot as phuck right now in ms, i go into this old ass gas station just to pick up a bottle of water.
like always i go by the freezer section and i see 3 pumpkin cheesecakes! i had to get all 3.
2 finds in one day. but actually one im proud of.
http://i.imgur.com/0q4h12u.jpg

Oh my

Not one, not two, but THREE?

[bambam601]

Oh my

Not one, not two, but THREE?

lol yep, had to. pumpkin cheesecake is my #2 ranked b&j flavor.
no telling when ill see it again either.

[AlwaysTryin]

Amazing. #1 ahead of OcC

Starting from the presentation you see when removing the lid, which is 100% consistent with everyone else's pics they've posted of it here, to the caramel ice cream itself and the swirl. I could not believe the number of little truffles. I doubted and thought people were exaggerating how many there are in all the posts here but I counted as I went snd had 52.

Easily the best ice cream

[AlwaysTryin]

Jealous. I really wanna try OCC

There were heaps for those in Philly

[emtvstheworld]

There were heaps for those in Philly

Damnit. Ill be in Florida next month. Anyone aware of anywhere between Indiana and Florida that might have OCC???

[Vendetta52]

Amazing. #1 ahead of OcC

Starting from the presentation you see when removing the lid, which is 100% consistent with everyone else's pics they've posted of it here, to the caramel ice cream itself and the swirl. I could not believe the number of little truffles. I doubted and thought people were exaggerating how many there are in all the posts here but I counted as I went snd had 52.

Easily the best ice cream

I love this flavor so much, in my top 3 flavors for sure. Have you tried Tons of Brownies yet? Honestly, I have a tough time deciding between the two. I loved CKC but Tons of Brownies is extremely close, it's so rich and so good.

[AlwaysTryin]

I love this flavor so much, in my top 3 flavors for sure. Have you tried Tons of Brownies yet? Honestly, I have a tough time deciding between the two. I loved CKC but Tons of Brownies is extremely close, it's so rich and so good.

Not yet, only had CKC a few hours ago. Once it stops raining tonight I'll go get tons of brownies

It's either tons of brownies, OCC or Brooklyn blackout (prob not this based on mixed reviews)

[psychodiver9]

Not yet, only had CKC a few hours ago. Once it stops raining tonight I'll go get tons of brownies

It's either tons of brownies, OCC or Brooklyn blackout (prob not this based on mixed reviews)

You rank those two ahead of brown butter almond brittle? Or have you not tried it?

[Vendetta52]

Not yet, only had CKC a few hours ago. Once it stops raining tonight I'll go get tons of brownies

It's either tons of brownies, OCC or Brooklyn blackout (prob not this based on mixed reviews)

Hit up Tons of brownies, I didn't care for OCC and the reviews for blackout are not great, like you said.

[r3pnIt]

Amazing. #1 ahead of OcC

Starting from the presentation you see when removing the lid, which is 100% consistent with everyone else's pics they've posted of it here, to the caramel ice cream itself and the swirl. I could not believe the number of little truffles. I doubted and thought people were exaggerating how many there are in all the posts here but I counted as I went snd had 52.

Easily the best ice cream

what brand of ice cream is this ? I mean where do they sell this , never seen it before?