** Ice Cream Eating Now Official Thread **

[chillaxbroseph]

Have you had it? I thought you couldn't find it?

I know chillax didn't like it, but evidently he's a ****get.

Didn't taste anything like bourbon to me.

I should have made this explicit: I am a special case, and you should take my analysis cum grano salis. As an undergrad, I had a few very bad episodes with alcohol, and I'm hypersensitive to it as a result. Whereas it overpowered my senses, many of you guys may not even notice the taste. Before buying the pint, I spoke to a relative who assured me that most bourbon ice creams taste of brown sugar, not the alcohol, which is why I took the risk.

Tl;dr: You'll need to try it for yourself. I'm a little bish when it comes to the alch, yo.

[Robboe]

Dark chocolate is superior, but this is still better than yo' momma's ice cream.

[ugasar]

2$ for What a Cluster? Steal. Probably a top 3 pint of BnJ i have had (being a PB fiend) the swirls and pieces compliment it very well, this and Everything But The are awesome and OCC (awesome so pissed its gone)

I have yet to scoop WAC, so that's why I hurried over to Target.. OCC is my #1 all-time & Everything But The.. is my #4! So based off your opinions with those two flavors, it looks like I'm in for a real treat here!

Had the pleasure of making a trip to Super Walmart Today. They have 3 freezers of Blue Bunny LOL. Probably a couple freezer finds in there.

WOW! Your Super Walmart definitely puts mine to shame when it comes to the ice cream department.. I see that HD Peanut Butter Pie! Have you scooped it yet? I can't find it anywhere.. If so, how would you compare to Graeter's Chocolate PB Chocolate Chip or B&J PB Cup??? Nonetheless, you definitely picked up some top flavors!



Heading to scoop Candy Bar Pie at the local scoop shop later tonight.. Going to check for OCC pints as well, going to suck paying $7 a pint that they charge in scoop shops though!

[usawinston]

Yes. It's meh, like most Breyer's stuff.

Speaking of, a freezer find for Chad:

Was tempted to buy just to try, but Breyer's has disappointed me too many times to risk. The only one I'm keeping an eye open for is the salty pretzel based on Erick's review.

Can we all agree that Breyer's isn't actually Ice Cream and stop mentioning it here lol?

[usawinston]

Dark chocolate is superior, but this is still better than yo' momma's ice cream.

This is honestly their worst Ice Cream. So boring and not "milky" by most standards. It's still very good though lol.

I have yet to scoop WAC, so that's why I hurried over to Target.. OCC is my #1 all-time & Everything But The.. is my #4! So based off your opinions with those two flavors, it looks like I'm in for a real treat here!




WOW! Your Super Walmart definitely puts mine to shame when it comes to the ice cream department.. I see that HD Peanut Butter Pie! Have you scooped it yet? I can't find it anywhere.. If so, how would you compare to Graeter's Chocolate PB Chocolate Chip or B&J PB Cup??? Nonetheless, you definitely picked up some top flavors!



Heading to scoop Candy Bar Pie at the local scoop shop later tonight.. Going to check for OCC pints as well, going to suck paying $7 a pint that they charge in scoop shops though!

I am going to try HD Peanut Butter Pie Soon. Please post pics (and review?) of your Candy Bar pie.

[The Solution]

Never had graeter's cause the flavor selection near me seems bleh. May try since BOGO. recommendations?

Buckeye Blitz
Cookies and Cream
Raspberry Chocolate Chip

Top 3 IMO

I have yet to scoop WAC, so that's why I hurried over to Target.. OCC is my #1 all-time & Everything But The.. is my #4! So based off your opinions with those two flavors, it looks like I'm in for a real treat here!


Heading to scoop Candy Bar Pie at the local scoop shop later tonight.. Going to check for OCC pints as well, going to suck paying $7 a pint that they charge in scoop shops though!

If you dig OCC and EBT then yeah your going to love WAC. The PB Base and swirls + Marshmallow = Epic.

Jelly of scoop shop closest to me is right by Usawinston about 2+ hours away, in for your review if you get a pint or sample it.

[KingJames2012]

My score
[IMG]http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a113/winstonp/food%203/F21F9E0C-0708-4E41-9B1A-3CD6588FE8C6-311-000000110399A5F2_zps19275b89.jpg

I wish I had a super walmart near me! Let me know how you like the Coconut Macaroon. I hated the pumpkin cheesecake.

[Robboe]

Can we all agree that Breyer's isn't actually Ice Cream and stop mentioning it here lol?

Ha, true. This and the apple are both FDD, but they do have some actual ice creams.

[MITCHAPAL00ZA]

Ha, true. This and the apple are both FDD, but they do have some actual ice creams.

their plain vanilla is ice cream and quite good I might add

[tom626]

Can we all agree that Breyer's isn't actually Ice Cream and stop mentioning it here lol?

They must have some really good subliminal marketing strategy I'm not aware of. Every time I see it I want to buy it, even though I know it's chit.

On the other hand I always feel compelled to pass up Turkey Hill for some reason, although from experience their stuff is actually pretty damn good. Must be the artwork/logo or something.

[usawinston]

They must have some really good subliminal marketing strategy I'm not aware of. Every time I see it I want to buy it, even though I know it's chit.

On the other hand I always feel compelled to pass up Turkey Hill for some reason, although from experience their stuff is actually pretty damn good. Must be the artwork/logo or something.

You're probably very correct about the marketing. Turkey hill containers look terrible. They do have some half decent stuff.

I wish I had a super walmart near me! Let me know how you like the Coconut Macaroon. I hated the pumpkin cheesecake.

I will post a review. Gonna take me a month or so. Unless I try to finish my next 2 months of bulking with a rage of pints. I did not really enjoy Graeter's Pumpkin, but this Pumpkin Cheesecake could be promising...

[psychodiver9]

^bj pumpkin cheesecake > Graeters pumpkin. Only Graeters I've tried. Took advantage of bogo but vanilla choc chip is only one I've tried. Also score Praelines and Cream. Got Jenni salted caramel (wife wanted to try) I was leaning towards dark chock or brambleberry. Soon.

What is the verdict on 3 twins? Saw cardamom, mint, and lemon

[KingJames2012]

You're probably very correct about the marketing. Turkey hill containers look terrible. They do have some half decent stuff.



I will post a review. Gonna take me a month or so. Unless I try to finish my next 2 months of bulking with a rage of pints. I did not really enjoy Graeter's Pumpkin, but this Pumpkin Cheesecake could be promising...

Im about the same stats as you...what are you bulking at? I have like 4-5 pints in the freezer but I like to eat a serving or two from a different pint every night. I just got a nasty sinus infection so no gym for the next few weeks. I'm still gonna eat my bulking calories though . I need to "get better."

[Mikelh]

Had the pleasure of making a trip to Super Walmart Today. They have 3 freezers of Blue Bunny LOL. Probably a couple freezer finds in there.

Never thought I would say this in my whole life, but... I really wish I had a super walmart around me

[Tdiguy]

Never thought I would say this in my whole life, but... I really wish I had a super walmart around me

Agreed but i woulda came out of there with alot more then those pints LOL

[Tdiguy]

Really really wasnt sure about the chips....however i actually liked this quite a bit, and the vanilla bean base is awesome.



Money

[NotADeltaBravo]

If it weren't for ice cream I would have trouble hitting my fat macros.

Do you even peanut butter?

Do you even avocado?

[tom626]

Do you even peanut butter?

Do you even avocado?

Allergic

Occasionally

[Ricky62Bobby]

Id kill myself if I was allergic to peanut butter.

[chillaxbroseph]

Just went to a Ben & Jerry's scoop shop for the first time since I was a little kid. The smell of the waffle cones brought back memories.

Anyways, they had a bunch of OCC pints that I was tempted to snag up, but I decided to pack a pint instead. I stood in the shop for a good 20 minutes debating whether to get coconut 7 layer bar or candy bar pie. Then it hit me:



Ended up doing half and half. Hopefully it works out.

[Mikelh]

^bj pumpkin cheesecake > Graeters pumpkin. Only Graeters I've tried. Took advantage of bogo but vanilla choc chip is only one I've tried. Also score Praelines and Cream. Got Jenni salted caramel (wife wanted to try) I was leaning towards dark chock or brambleberry. Soon.

What is the verdict on 3 twins? Saw cardamom, mint, and lemon

3 twins has some good stuff. I've had their cookies and cream and theyre lemon flavor (lemon cake maybe?) which were both decent. But I really really liked they're salted caramel.

[oneday752]

Id kill myself if I was allergic to peanut butter.

By eating peanut butter?

[Tdiguy]

Not sure if this has been said but ben and jerrys has said Creme Brulee has been graveyarded so if your looking for it or like it get it now

[chillaxbroseph]

Not sure if this has been said but ben and jerrys has said Creme Brulee has been graveyarded so if your looking for it or like it get it now

I was lurking their ******** and they also confirmed that Dublin Mudslide is getting the axe as well. I thought that one had already been scrapped, but a guy posted a review a few pages back.

[chillaxbroseph]

My score

How did I miss this post? You have to let me know how that new 2nd street creamery flavor is. Money shot pics pls. I had no idea they were rolling out new offerings.

[KingJames2012]

I was lurking their ******** and they also confirmed that Dublin Mudslide is getting the axe as well. I thought that one had already been scrapped, but a guy posted a review a few pages back.

They are getting rid of my favorite flavors by them. I hope they are coming out with new non froyo stuff.

[Tdiguy]

They are getting rid of my favorite flavors by them. I hope they are coming out with new non froyo stuff.

I swear if they axe cinnamon buns im done with b&j i cant handle loosing occ and cb.

[psychodiver9]

Jennis Salted Caramel. Bleh. Pretty terrible. Just tasted like burnt marshmallow. My wife, who likes caramel more than me (and picked it out) ate like 3 bites. Honestly probably one of the worst caramel ice creams I've had

[The Solution]

I was lurking their ******** and they also confirmed that Dublin Mudslide is getting the axe as well. I thought that one had already been scrapped, but a guy posted a review a few pages back.

OCC and now Dublin Mudslide? Da Fuk is BnJ doing? If they keep coming out with flavors like Candy Bar Pie (which i have yet to try) then ill let it be, but damn they are letting go of some solid flavors. Id rather see things like
Cheesecake Brownie
Banana Split
Cherry Garcia
Strawberry Cheesecake

go to the graveyard instead.

[Dre4]

^^ agree with all but cheesecake brownie, really liked that one.

Yoplait Black Cherry Greek Froyo


First time trying this lineup, pretty good. Doesn't have that sour taste that GY typically has. Uses cherry swirls rather than pieces like Cherry Garcia which is another plus. Would definitely consider buying this again.