Uggla and Bloomqist for Stubbs and Kuroda

[Greg1983]

Which side wins? Standard 5x5 scoring.

[thefullmonte]

Which side wins? Standard 5x5 scoring.

kinda depends...Uggla "should" be the best player in the deal...but if Stubbs gets hot like he did last year...the Stubbs/Kuroda side could win that big. I just don't see Willie B keeping the pace he's been on...not at 33 years old...but he just might be the Andres Torres of 2011.

I think this may be more of a needs trade. Which side are you getting...and what does your team look like?

[scrace]

stubbs could be 30-20 guy. but probably 20-20 with .250 avg

Uggla better avg and 30-40 hr, id do it. if you need steals and kuroda will be decent

[Greg1983]

Yeah I wanted to hear a few responses before I said who I was. I'm giving Stubbs and Kuroda. I already have a ton of speed (Rajai if he remembers how to hit, Pierre, Phillips) and stacked starters (Halladay, Oswalt, Cain, Latos, Dan Hudson, Jackson). However my average and power blow. Willie was just a throwin, though a nice one, and I really just wanted Uggla.

[thefullmonte]

Yeah I wanted to hear a few responses before I said who I was. I'm giving Stubbs and Kuroda. I already have a ton of speed (Rajai if he remembers how to hit, Pierre, Phillips) and stacked starters (Halladay, Oswalt, Cain, Latos, Dan Hudson, Jackson). However my average and power blow. Willie was just a throwin, though a nice one, and I really just wanted Uggla.

Phillips? as in Brandon Phillips? if thats so...I dont think I like that deal for you. I dont think at the end of the year that Uggla has all that much higher of an avg than Stubbs does. Kuroda also presents a sneaky good value for you. I think I'd pass on that deal.

[Greg1983]

Phillips? as in Brandon Phillips? if thats so...I dont think I like that deal for you. I dont think at the end of the year that Uggla has all that much higher of an avg than Stubbs does. Kuroda also presents a sneaky good value for you. I think I'd pass on that deal.

There's also a MI spot in this league, so it's not like Phillips and Uggla would be overkill. And I'm just saying Phillips would add 20-25 stolen bases on whatever Pierre and Davis get, so I'm sitting pretty nice in that category with or without Stubbs.

[thefullmonte]

There's also a MI spot in this league, so it's not like Phillips and Uggla would be overkill. And I'm just saying Phillips would add 20-25 stolen bases on whatever Pierre and Davis get, so I'm sitting pretty nice in that category with or without Stubbs.

be that as it may...I dont think you should be giving up Kuroda in the process