I recently lost my job. So I figured this is a good time as any to get my fat arse in shape. I need to lose about 33lbs.
I'm female 5'3" 147lbs and 31% bodyfat.
I got a trainer for 6 weeks. I was asking him about losing fat vs muscle and he said it's actually very hard to lose muscle. So when I said "Really, awesome let's shoot for 3lbs a week then" He gave me the old 2lbs a week is the healthy way to lose. I was like "but you just said it's hard to lose muscle"
Needless to say, I'm a bit confused. My goal is to workout 2x a day HARD , 6-7 days a week, eat 1200 calories/day, and walk the dogs 2miles a day. of the 2x a day, only 3-4 workouts of the total 12-14 workouts will be weight lifting exercise, the other 8-11 workouts will be pure cardio. Each lasting about 1 hour long.
Before you answer, I am aware that I may burn out and may not be able to keep it up. I also know that I could injure myself. So with all of this said I plan on being careful and listening to my body and resting when I need to.
HOWEVER, let's just say for our purposes I'm able to keep up the rigerous schedule, eat and workout according to my plan without injuring myself or burning out over 6 weeks and I'm able to lose 3lbs a week.
Can I lose the 3lbs with minimum to no muscle loss. I dont want to lose the weight if It's going to be mostly muscle. That's just pointless. That's why I'm asking this question. I want to try to lose fat as much as possible and maximize weight loss.
PS my trainer wants me on a C/P/F ratio of 60/20/20
I always thought for fat loss you wanted something more like 50/40/10 to 40/40/20.
07-08-2010, 07:03 PM #1
Can I healthfully lose 3lbs a week for 6 weeks?
07-08-2010, 07:09 PM #2
At your height and weight 3lbs per week is unreasonable.
Also your trainer is wrong. It's very easy to lose muscle if you don't train properly and eat properly. If you don't manage your weight loss properly, you'll lose (roughly) equal amounts of fat and muscle. If you eat healthily and exercise properly, you can skew that proportion to more fat, and less muscle.
1200 cals is too low. 14 workouts per week is insane. 7 days of working out is going to wear you out. It's recovery that leads to muscle growth and weight loss. If you don't give your body time to recover, then you're going to regret it. Overexercising (overtraining) while under eating can not only stall your weight loss, it can make you go backwards as you simply build damage upon damage.
At a healthy rate, you should aim for about 1% of your bodyweight per week. More than that, you're going to be losing muscle in large amount.
Finally, ratios are meaningless really if you're eating the wrong calorie level. Aim for 1g of protein per pound of body weight. Then get about .3g of healthy fat per pound of bodyweight. Then make up the rest of your calories in carbs - whole grains, fruits and veg, etc. However that falls into the percentages is what it is.
07-08-2010, 07:11 PM #3
07-08-2010, 07:14 PM #4
07-08-2010, 09:48 PM #5
- Join Date: Feb 2010
- Location: United States
- Stats: 5'3", 125 lbs
- Posts: 792
- Rep Power: 4295
What she said.
You're current stats are very similiar to my starting stats (5'3", 146 lbs, 29% bf) when I first started lifting. . . in 6 weeks you won't be able to perform miracles, but you will be able to make large strides in your fitness level and changing your body's composition. For me, the actual number number on the scale has been moving slowly, but the way my clothing fits and my overall measurements have changed drastically. At our height 10 lbs can be an entire pant size or two, so sticking to the 2lb a week rule (providing your diet is on point the whole time) would be 12 lbs that can make a world of difference.
And why are your calories so low? You need a sufficient amount of calories to fuel your body for your workouts and to help your body maintain what muscle you do have. Doing tons and tons of cardio will burn you out and ravage your muscle.
Losing weight is simple:
Lift heavy+eat the proper amount of calories+stick to your diet= weight loss.
I suggest you go and read the stickies."Pain is temporary. It may last a minute, or an hour, or a day, or a year, but eventually it will subside and something else will take its place. If I quit, however, it lasts forever. That surrender, even the smallest act of giving up, stays with me. So when I feel like quitting, I ask myself, which would I rather live with?" - Lance Armstrong
07-09-2010, 03:45 AM #6
- Join Date: May 2008
- Location: Massachusetts, United States
- Age: 46
- Stats: 5'4", 128 lbs
- Posts: 25,198
- Rep Power: 141596
3lbs a week is not going to happen. Losing over 2lbs a week and you're tapping into muscle. Most women are lucky if they can lose a steady 1-1.5 lbs a week...and to do this your calories better be spot on. 1200 calories is too low and won't work for you. As you continue losing you'll need to lower calories and you're going to end up with no where to go.
You need to focus on heavy weight training while eating in a deficit, it's how we preserve our muscle. You need to seriously cut back on some of the cardio. All that cardio while eating in a deficit and you'll end up losing more muscle then anything else. Also training 6-7 days a week...when do you plan to recover? Rest and recovery is crucial for growth and this happens outside the gym. You need to learn to train smart and training smart is about the quality of a workout...not the quantity.
I hope you didn't pay your trainer, because this is the perfect program for losing muscle...
Last edited by kimm4; 07-09-2010 at 03:54 AM.www.iron-kim.com
Online Nutritional Coach/Trainer
Over 40 bb of the week - http://www.bodybuilders.com/kimberly-lachance.html
Muscle Dog - http://www.muscledog.com/forum/TRANSFORMATION_STORIES_WOMEN/1050/TRANSFORMATION_STORY_KIMBERLY_LACHANCE.html#
National Level Competitor
Over35 Training Journal:
07-09-2010, 10:48 PM #7
- Join Date: Jun 2003
- Location: Sydney, Australia
- Age: 32
- Stats: 5'7", 131 lbs
- Posts: 12,933
- BodyPoints: 13604
- Rep Power: 4806
Good advice above
Also "healthfully" is not a word. I think you mean "healthily"September 2006 - 9km Sydney Harbour Bridge Run - 45:25
August 2007 - 14km City to Surf - 77:00
September 2007 - Sydney Running Festival Half Marathon - Withdrawn due to stress fractures :(
September 2008 - Sydney Running Festival Half Marathon - 1:59.22
May 2009 - Sydney Morning Herald Half Marathon - 1:53:22
07-13-2010, 08:41 AM #8
- Join Date: Apr 2010
- Location: New Jersey, United States
- Age: 33
- Stats: 5'4", 144 lbs
- Posts: 187
- Rep Power: 115
There is lots of great advice posted here already, so I will spare you the rehash. I agree, fire your trainer. I dont like the diet he put you on, you can lose muscle quickly, and didnt low weights/high reps leave the gym with high top reeboks?
Since you a looking to really push yourself and are looking for ongoing high intensity to lose fat and build muscle AND you can afford a trainer, I suggest that you fire his a** and find a local Crossfit. You have to check it out and see if it is for you, but it sounds like it is. I am an addict. Changed my life. Plus you will get the motivation, competition, and support you need to keep your program up. Some will help you with your diet, but be critical. These people have no training in that really.
PM me if you have Crossfit questions. Check out the main site, www.crossfit.com. There is a workout posted every day, but most crossfit gyms (called boxes) usually make up their own to suit the members.
No matter what, good luck! GET IT DONE!Always demand more from yourself than anyone can ever expect of you.
07-23-2010, 02:48 PM #9To conquer oneself is the best and noblest victory; to be vanquished by one's own nature is the worst and most ignoble defeat-Plato
For those who "neg" my reputation JUST because I am a woman and then put that in the description to why you "negged" me, I will do it right back.
07-23-2010, 03:43 PM #10
07-23-2010, 03:46 PM #11
- Join Date: Sep 2009
- Location: Chicago, Illinois, United States
- Age: 26
- Stats: 5'8", 185 lbs
- Posts: 9
- Rep Power: 0
Actually low weight high rep is not a bad plan. personal trainers (for the most part know what they are talking about). high rep/low weight is more catered towards muscular endurance and toning. it will not decrease ur muscularity however it will not aid much in building muscle.
07-23-2010, 08:11 PM #12
according to this web site -> http://www.freedieting.com/tools/cal...alculator.htm#
your BMR is 1817 cals a day and you should aim for 1453 cals a day to lose about 1lb a week. If you try to loose 3lbs a week then that means your eating 10,500 cal less a week then you would normally eat. It also says that starting to eat 1k below your BMR right off the bat is bad."If you think you understand quantum mechanics, you don't understand quantum mechanics" - Richard Feynman
07-23-2010, 08:20 PM #13
07-24-2010, 11:07 AM #14
"For attractive lips- speak words of kindness. For lovely eyes- seek out the good in people. For a slim figure- share your food with the hungry. For poise- walk with the knowledge that you will never walk alone."
- Join Date: Sep 2007
- Location: Texas, United States
- Age: 40
- Stats: 5'4", 114 lbs
- Posts: 72
- BodyPoints: 27138
- Rep Power: 10
07-25-2010, 01:21 AM #15
3lbs a week =O asking for severe muscle loss. you didn't gain all that weight in 6 so you can't take it off in 6 weeks either. Jeez I worry about muscle loss when losing 1lb per week, 1.5 is the highest I would ever go (unless just starting keto or something where you lose alot of water at first). If you were obese maybe you could swing 2, but not at sub 150
By Dave210 in forum ExercisesReplies: 19Last Post: 04-08-2008, 09:37 PM
By metaldrummer in forum ExercisesReplies: 21Last Post: 12-12-2007, 08:23 PM
By Massgainer456 in forum NutritionReplies: 7Last Post: 09-18-2007, 07:19 AM
By Pam_39 in forum Nutrition and SupplementsReplies: 18Last Post: 04-21-2007, 08:59 AM
By jehst in forum Teen BodybuildingReplies: 3Last Post: 03-09-2004, 07:01 AM