OMG, Johnny Cash's rendition of Hurt is among the best songs I've heard in entire life. I absolutely love this song.
As far other songs go, I can think of a few. If you're open to it I can give suggest some sad rap songs. Good Die Young by D12. Their Eminem's group but this song was in dedication of one of their friends who died years earlier and it's actually really hearfelt.
If I Die Tomorrow by Joe Budden: About 6 minutes long and very good for a rap song I think.
You Never Know by Immortal Technique: If you like rap even a little bit then you have to listen to this song. It's very sad. It's about 7 minutes long and it's a love story with a depressing ending...
Hell Razor by 2pac is another great one. I almost cried toward the end of the song when he's talking about Latasha Harling. She's a girl who was killed by a shopkeeper who thought she was stealing. That incident was actually one of the pivotal moments leading up to the Los Angeles riots in the early 90s.
If you're not up for rap then I'll suggest a few of these
Dance With My Father by Luther Vandross. Very sad song.
Dumb by Nirvana: Get the Live and Unplugged version. It's actually alot better than the studio In Utero version I think.
Through Her Eyes by Dream Theater: You will love this song...
Danny Boy by Johnny Cash: This is from the same album as Hurt, American IV_The Man Comes Around. I'd suggest just download or purchase the album because every song is great and Danny Boy is another one of the standouts along with Hurt.
Something In The Way by Nirvana: Very depressing song... Get the studio version. The Live and Unplugged version pales in comparison.
Angel by Sarah Mclachlan: I actually don't even know what the song is about. I listen to it just to listen to Sarah's voice because it's so soothing and beautiful. The song does give off a depressing vibe though. Oddly enough, it sometimes plays during those abused animal commercials by the ASPCA. Lol... That's actually where I first heard it now I'm a huge Sarah fan.
Ben by Michael Jackson: written and recorded while he was a kid. Apparently it's supposed to be a love song to his pet rat. lol... nonetheless it's beautiful
Wears Tapout to weddings crew
Hairy asscheeks crew
Mind destroyed from porn crew
Can only fap if chick's head is being shoved down a toilet crew
No fap crew
Compulsive liar crew
Hope the paranormal exists but it probably doesn't crew
Can't tell if this is real life or virtual reality crew