Please Inform Your Rep - FDA tries to criminalize supplements

[Rodzilla01]

I share your sentiments but i really would like to see some sort of regulatory standards set on the supplement industry.I'm sure alot of the stuff out there is honestly and correctly produced,but alot of it too is just bogus garbage that could even harm people.A happy medium is neeeded.

I agree, but those are already going into effect. This is much more than just that...

[Macrobolic]

Sent emails. Pissed at FDA as usual

[Macrobolic]

I think 'fda seeks to criminalize supplements' is a bit strong.

It's not strong at all. It is EXACTLY what they are trying to do. They're a horrible government institution that is now under the pressure of the Big Pharma to drive out any and all food health claims, supplements, and basically anything grass roots.



FDA can suck my balls

[CognitiveNutrition]

I share your sentiments but i really would like to see some sort of regulatory standards set on the supplement industry.I'm sure alot of the stuff out there is honestly and correctly produced,but alot of it too is just bogus garbage that could even harm people.A happy medium is neeeded.

Self regulation and 3rd party orgs can easily confirm quality controls. The gov is not needed here or in most aspects of our lives. If you have a concern about a product or a company ask them for proof or test it yourself. Share your results and if they are bogus they will not stay in business long plus lawsuit heaven for you.

It's not strong at all. It is EXACTLY what they are trying to do. They're a horrible government institution that is now under the pressure of the Big Pharma to drive out any and all food health claims, supplements, and basically anything grass roots.

FDA can suck my balls

This.

[Anders0n74]

Sent. I'm so mad right now, it's unbelievable. I hate this current government, but more so I hate most of the American people for electing this government.

[lhockey]

this is bull****. sent.

[whitesox3223]

Done.

[UWBodybuilding]

Sent a message to Mr. Russ Feingold.

[JohnnyB21]

Yes but do you understand why healthcare costs so much?

The same reason divorces are so expensive....it's worth it.


For everybody who doesn't like Waxman, let me ask you this: Do you like your generic prescription drugs and their cost compared to brand name? Guess who was one of the men responsible for generics being introduced?

Google "Waxman-Hatch Act"

[Tyler44]

Done for sure! Screw the FDA

[AndrewCa]

Looks like we will have a black market for supplements pretty darn soon!

Knock Knock psst does anyone got any SP250 for sale???

[CapnKrunk]

Done

[legalgear]

I share your sentiments but i really would like to see some sort of regulatory standards set on the supplement industry.I'm sure alot of the stuff out there is honestly and correctly produced,but alot of it too is just bogus garbage that could even harm people.A happy medium is neeeded.

For sure, but the GMP standards go into effect for everyone next year and it will get cleaned up. We do need oversight like GMP, but not arbitrary rulings.

[EFizzle]

I share your sentiments but i really would like to see some sort of regulatory standards set on the supplement industry.I'm sure alot of the stuff out there is honestly and correctly produced,but alot of it too is just bogus garbage that could even harm people.A happy medium is neeeded.

That happy medium cannot be achieved by government regulation. Moreover it is not the governments responsibility to regulate these industries.

The free market (aka capitalism) does a pretty good job of weeding out the garbage.

[watchfan]

bump

[iForce Dave]

sending now

[AZPump]

F'n dems.. leave it to them to introduce a bill like this..

[TNote]

sent... I would say unbelievable, but it really isn't anymore which is just sad

[Robboe]

ttt

[superhombre2k]

Sent!

There are already plenty of rules and regulations regarding food safety, and ways to follow up on and enforce them. A bill like this merely pretends to remedy a problem that doesn't actually exist, because those things are already in place, rather than solve the real problems. It's a shame that current procedure isn't always followed, or worse yet, blatantly ignored to save money. This bill plays on the ignorance of the people in order to increase the power of government to suit the special interests (namely, pharmaceuticals) that line the pockets of many in our government.

Ugh.

And then there's the whole thing about giving the government more power to make ill-advised decisions to "protect" idiots...

[TNote]

ttt

[SHOWTIME]

What if I agree with it?

[CognitiveNutrition]

What if I agree with it?

With what you perceive to be the stated intent (as oppose to real purpose) or as it is with all the implications?

[Intellectural]

That happy medium cannot be achieved by government regulation. Moreover it is not the governments responsibility to regulate these industries.

The free market (aka capitalism) does a pretty good job of weeding out the garbage.

I've sent something to my congressmen, as I enjoy my supplements and don't think this is necessary considering the already vast jurisdiction of the FDA. However, I doubt an overreaching bill like this will pass. In many cases, Congress will put up an intentionally unconstitutional bill (to appease special interests) knowing that courts will strike them down later. A lot of blame going on in this thread, like the Obama admin is hellbent on big government. Realize that if they had stepped into an environment where the economy, health care and energy were running smoothly, it would most likely be a different scenario.

As to the above quote, I agree in some respects, but I get weary of people incessantly touting the "free market" like it's an infallible argument. The recent financial cataclysm happened because firms violated the most basic premise of free market capitalism- i.e. having the enlightened self interest to monitor your own risk exposure.

Lets all keep an eye on this and be vigilant, but the end of the world fearmongering is a bit over the top.

[Robboe]

What if I agree with it?

I think i'd find it quite ironic that you have 18k posts on a forum that exists to sell supplements.

[Al Swearengen]

What if I agree with it?

then we all hope you do not reproduce any offspring. lulz

[Anders0n74]

Bump. This seriously should be stickied!

I received two emails back. One email was from one of my representatives that I got an email shortly after sending out the email saying that it did not make it into his inbox. But sure enough, his either automated email or pre-written emails concerning this matter was sent back to me. That's funny. The other email was basically saying that this was necessary and he was proud of it. Go figure living in Massachusetts .

Here is the believed automated email:

Thank you for your email. Please know that I appreciate you taking the time to share your views on this important issue. As always, I will keep your comments and concerns in mind as this issue continues to develop in the 111th Congress.

Please note that if this is an emergency or a time-sensitive issue, please contact my Boston office at ***-***-****, and a member of my staff would be happy to help you.

Again, thank you for your email. Please don't hesitate to contact me in the future regarding this or any other issue.




And here is the second email:

Thank you for your letter on recent safety recalls of tainted food and consumer goods. I share your concerns and I appreciate this opportunity to respond.

It is the responsibility of the Food and Drug Administration to inspect and safeguard the nation's food supply, in order to prevent outbreaks of food-based illnesses and contain such outbreaks when they do occur.

To help the FDA accomplish these goals, the Senate has passed several measures to reinforce and improve the FDA, and I am proud to have been a sponsor of the FDA Revitalization Act, which strengthens the FDA's ability to inspect food and expand its notification process so that the public can learn sooner about outbreaks and recalls sooner.

Our people expect and deserve that their food supply and consumer products are safe. I strongly support the agencies responsible for inspecting food and goods, and when necessary, and I'm doing all I can to see that they have the authority and support they need to protect the American public.

Thank you for contacting me on this important subject.







God help us all.

[CognitiveNutrition]

Bump. This seriously should be stickied!

I received two emails back. One email was from one of my representatives that I got an email shortly after sending out the email saying that it did not make it into his inbox. But sure enough, his either automated email or pre-written emails concerning this matter was sent back to me. That's funny. The other email was basically saying that this was necessary and he was proud of it. Go figure living in Massachusetts .

Here is the believed automated email:

Thank you for your email. Please know that I appreciate you taking the time to share your views on this important issue. As always, I will keep your comments and concerns in mind as this issue continues to develop in the 111th Congress.

Please note that if this is an emergency or a time-sensitive issue, please contact my Boston office at ***-***-****, and a member of my staff would be happy to help you.

Again, thank you for your email. Please don't hesitate to contact me in the future regarding this or any other issue.




And here is the second email:

Thank you for your letter on recent safety recalls of tainted food and consumer goods. I share your concerns and I appreciate this opportunity to respond.

It is the responsibility of the Food and Drug Administration to inspect and safeguard the nation's food supply, in order to prevent outbreaks of food-based illnesses and contain such outbreaks when they do occur.

To help the FDA accomplish these goals, the Senate has passed several measures to reinforce and improve the FDA, and I am proud to have been a sponsor of the FDA Revitalization Act, which strengthens the FDA's ability to inspect food and expand its notification process so that the public can learn sooner about outbreaks and recalls sooner.

Our people expect and deserve that their food supply and consumer products are safe. I strongly support the agencies responsible for inspecting food and goods, and when necessary, and I'm doing all I can to see that they have the authority and support they need to protect the American public.

Thank you for contacting me on this important subject.







God help us all.

I think we need a new subsection called Supplements Law pertaining to all legal news and legislation about supplements. What do you guys think?

[VaughnTrue]

I think we need a new subsection called Supplements Law pertaining to all legal news and legislation about supplements. What do you guys think?

i think is a great idea

[SHOWTIME]

With what you perceive to be the stated intent (as oppose to real purpose) or as it is with all the implications?

none of the above. Just trying to get everyone all pissed off for nothing.

1 I am in a different country, and 2 I cannot remember the percentage now but a LOW percentage of your country (USA) can even take the time to vote for a presidential election, is it a surprise that things like this make to the fda and get approved.

I think i'd find it quite ironic that you have 18k posts on a forum that exists to sell supplements.

If i didn't have to go on tours I would have more.