Navy SEALS vs. Marine RECON vs. Air Force Pararescue vs. Army Rangers

[Ultimus]

In a fictional war, who would win and why. Infantry only, and only weapons and equipment that infantry units would be able to carry around and use. no vehicles, missles, etc.

[Twist3dJok3r]

Well are numbers a factor? Manpower? I know the Recon Marines number about 1000, not sure about navy seals. But I think the Rangers have alot more man power than any other listed...

[sugicalmike]

Well.... I'm goig to have to say that the United States would probably win

[booopooo]

I've seen this thread make 1000000 times, yet never by anyone over the age of 21.


Random fact.

[Milamber]

How many in each team? because I thought that the rangers woudl out number the other groups like 5:1... yes unaware of US army personall

[EarlyHorns]

pararescue.....know how to fight, survive, and save lives in any condition....so basically the pj's respawn and pwn everybody else..

[foxtrot.uniform]

Doesn't matter. We all fight under the same flag, right? Just feel sorry for the sumbitches who oppose us and have all of these hardasses after them.

[Ultimus]

we'll just say a squad of 6 for each.

[usamarshal]

The Waffen SS...why you ask?

Because they walk the mother fukin line...thats why.

[rockchalk420]

gotta go with the Navy SEALs. I was actually strongly considering going into the navy and becomeing a SEAL...SEALs have the longest, hardest training in the world.

[Cell-Tech]

gotta go with the Navy SEALs. I was actually strongly considering going into the navy and becomeing a SEAL...SEALs have the longest, hardest training in the world.

Pararescue training is 2 years. Just sayin'

And no one is ever gonna be able to say something would definitively put one group above the other.

[mac1471]

but see the thing is that the success rate of the SEALS is 5%
that means that only 5% of the recruits get though boot camp

[TheWalrusold]

retards in dis here thrad?

yes

[sugicalmike]

SOCOM, GhostRecon, RainbowSix, COD4?.... what are we talking here? do we have any cheats?

[Cell-Tech]

but see the thing is that the success rate of the SEALS is 5%
that means that only 5% of the recruits get though boot camp

The average attrition rate of BUD/s is not 95%...

Please find a credible link if you're gonna say that.



EDIT: Boot camp is also completely seperate and not even close to SEAL selection training... You don't know what you're talking about.

[FltMech]

gotta go with the Navy SEALs. I was actually strongly considering going into the navy and becomeing a SEAL...SEALs have the longest, hardest training in the world.

congrats for considering(strongly)

[BeachBMW]

[SymphonyXXX]

The Waffen SS...why you ask?

Because they walk the mother fukin line...thats why.

the waffen SS got held off nicely by the soviet army.

[mac1471]

The average attrition rate of BUD/s is not 95%...

Please find a credible link if you're gonna say that.



EDIT: Boot camp is also completely seperate and not even close to SEAL selection training... You don't know what you're talking about.

ok then give me proof that more then 5% complete the training

[Hellbent1100]

gotta go with the Navy SEALs. I was actually strongly considering going into the navy and becomeing a SEAL...SEALs have the longest, hardest training in the world.

first off the be a "SEAL" u need to be invited to UDT basic underwater demo training ,then u have to be to 10% of you class to get the invite , and u need to be a E4 in rank and den u have to be in a combat type job b4 u go to UDT to go to BUDS , to be a overrated SEAL,

RANGER BABY, we do all the jobs they do and more , unless its SEAL team 6 or 7 then u got to be the top 10% all of SEALS , and screw them we got DELTA wich is the best of the best end of story ,

but i love all my SF bother

[SymphonyXXX]

first off the be a "SEAL" u need to be invited to BUD"S basic underwater demo,then u have to be to 10% of you class to get the invite , and u need to be a E4 in rank and den u have to be in a combat type job b4 u go to UDT to go to BUDS , to be a overrated SEAL,

RANGER BABY, we do all the jobs they do and more , unless its SEAL team 6 or 7 then u got to be the top 10% all of SEALS , and screw them we got DELTA wich is the best of the best end of story ,

but i love all my SF bother

Has Delta ever really been tested? I don't really know and would like an answer. I only know of ****lia (yes BHD) where they didn't show much alphaness and in being part of the hunt for bin laden, where they havent been much alpha either.

[Cell-Tech]

ok then give me proof that more then 5% complete the training

You're the one that made the claim. I shouldn't have to go back and google.

"Classes typically lose around 70?80% of their trainees ? either due to DORs or injuries sustained during training, but it is not always easy to predict which of the trainees will DOR during BUD/S. "

According to wiki though.

[Hellbent1100]

Has Delta ever really been tested? I don't really know and would like an answer. I only know of ****lia (yes BHD) where they didn't show much alphaness and in being part of the hunt for bin laden, where they havent been much alpha either.

there is a reason u don't here about DELTA, ...................... thats y lol

DELTA is put together from all SF , seal recon ranger, the best of the best go to DELTA

even the army has bad ass type SEAL dudes called SCUBA 1 , talk about bad mofo's wish i cud of did SCUBA 1,
then back in the NAM days u had tunnel RAT's talk about guys with huge balls.

and to top that off there are units we will never hear of , and **** like backwater who have a **** load of ex SF guys running the show , and bad MOFO's

[SymphonyXXX]

there is a reason u don't here about DELTA, ...................... thats y lol

true

[KIDRR]

A lot of these listed are for special missions, however the ARMY Rangers have the numbers to take over entire countries. They would win easily.

[sugicalmike]

[mac1471]

You're the one that made the claim. I shouldn't have to go back and google.

"Classes typically lose around 70?80% of their trainees ? either due to DORs or injuries sustained during training, but it is not always easy to predict which of the trainees will DOR during BUD/S. "

According to wiki though.

i dident get it from the internet i looked for it just know

i went in to the navy recruiting office and i asked about the seals andd the training and he was like the success rate is 5%

and like one of the task is you have to swim 26 miles strait out you rest for 20 mins then strait back

[Hellbent1100]

i dident get it from the internet i looked for it just know

i went in to the navy recruiting office and i asked about the seals andd the training and he was like the success rate is 5%

and like one of the task is you have to swim 26 miles strait out you rest for 20 mins then strait back

DON'T ever join the navy to be a SEAL, they will not take navy , the navy has no combat type jobs , its funny i know cus its the navy SEALS but they take marines and army , wen you join the navy , u don't train with a gun in you hand like the army and marines

[rockchalk420]

first off the be a "SEAL" u need to be invited to UDT basic underwater demo training ,then u have to be to 10% of you class to get the invite , and u need to be a E4 in rank and den u have to be in a combat type job b4 u go to UDT to go to BUDS , to be a overrated SEAL,

RANGER BABY, we do all the jobs they do and more , unless its SEAL team 6 or 7 then u got to be the top 10% all of SEALS , and screw them we got DELTA wich is the best of the best end of story ,

but i love all my SF bother

You sound pretty biased. Sure rangers are bad ass, but SEALs have got to be near the top. Theres only 2500 seals, how many rangers are there? I believe there is more...meaning its harder to become a seal than it is a ranger.

[rockchalk420]

DON'T ever join the navy to be a SEAL, they will not take navy , the navy has no combat type jobs , its funny i know cus its the navy SEALS but they take marines and army , wen you join the navy , u don't train with a gun in you hand like the army and marines

That is impart why I didnt go into the SEALs, because I had pretty much no shot at making it.

If your strongly considering going into any SF better to go into the marines first.