Let's pick this apart bit by bit, shall we?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
Strength training is an important element in reducing the unsightly appearance of cellulite since it increases muscle tone and decreases total body fat.
|
Up until here, you're batting a thousand.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
But the way you strength train is even more important. A program that targets fat loss in the lower body, specifically hips, thighs, abdomen and buttocks is ideal for most women.
|
I have never seen any type of training that does this. Spot reduction remains in the realm of "fitness myth". If you have something peer-reviewed to refute this, I'm all ears. Until then, I remain unconvinced.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
Freestyle Fitness, A women's only program is a great way to train with these goals in mind. The very nature of a women's only program geared at training the lower body fatigues the muscle groups helping to promote a reduction in actual size of the area, while decreasing the percentage of body fat.
|
So, it will catabolize muscle while burning fat.
Okay - I can see how that would reduce overall size ... if you run a caloric deficit.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
The routines that I recommend for women with these goals in mind involve a 15-25-repetition concept, which also keeps the heart rate up.
|
Iron cardio. Yep, that'll burn off all that pesky muscle, to be sure.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
I also encourage that when training for shape,
|
How does one "train for shape" without "training for size"?
It's not like you can change the shape of a muscle.
???
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
not size, that the exercises are performed with no rest between sets, only for a drink of water. This type of training will create more fat-burning muscle
|
Nope. Unless we're talking about a completely untrained person, fat burning with muscle gain is unlikely in an unassisted female.
And muscle gain is unlikely to occur during iron cardio as described.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
while still giving you a longer, leaner and shapely, not bulky body and can also be considered as a two in one system. Resistance training and cardio in one.
|
If only it were possible.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
First, let's discuss some of the physical issues that plague many women regarding body shape and body composition. Most women have the same issues. They want to become more firm and leaner, they want delicate feminine cuts, and they want to defeat the battle with the hips, thighs and back of the upper arms. In many cases, women want to not only firm up these problem areas, but they want to reduce the size of these areas.
|
Hence, the muscle-catabolizing routines, yes, you've said this. But muscle-catabolizing routines don't BUILD muscle - they reduce it.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
Although nothing can replace the benefits of aerobic training for the heart, aerobic training does not tone muscle, and muscle tone is the only answer to the battle. Women need to incorporate lightweight training into their fitness routines in order to have the best body that they as an individual can possibly have.
|
Light weight training stimulates sarcoplasmic hypertrophy. It does NOT stimulate myogenic tone. For this, you need very heavy weights in very low reps.
Muscle growth (hypertrophy) happens through two different mechanisms: sarcomere hypertrophy, which increases the contractile portion of the muscle, and sarcoplasmic hypertrophy, which increases the stuff that DOESN'T contract.
High rep training stimulates this "bulky", soft muscle growth.
Low rep training stimulates sarcomere hypertrophy - the part that makes you strong without looking "big".
This is the really DENSE muscle hypertrophy. It makes you HARD.
With sarcomere hypertrophy, the muscle gets only a small increase in diameter because its density increases. With sarcoplasmic hypertrophy, the opposite is true: a larger increase in muscle diameter, and a decrease in muscle density.
But don't just take my word on it:
Read here for more
and here
I don't make the rules. I just kinda understand 'em.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
Let's explore some basic principals of how women should resistance train. First, as a general rule, women should perform exercises at a weight that allows them to complete 15 to 25 repetitions; with the last few repetitions feeling a bit challenging.
|
Why?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
Secondly, problem areas should be trained four to six times a week, following the 15 to 25 repetition rule.
|
Again, why?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sherry Gideons
Lastly, exercises should be done in a fairly fast paced cycle. This means for example, in a given workout if there are five different lower body exercises being performed in that particular workout session, exercises 1-5 should be performed once (15 - 25 times each), then exercise 1-5 should be performed again and when endurance permits, even a third or fourth time.
|
I look forward to some answers. This article sounds like all the toning myth dogma we've heard for years.
Which brings me back to my old standby phrase:
If high-reps worked, we'd see a lot of ripped soccer moms coming out of toning class at the community centre.
And I haven't even BEGUN to pick apart the recommendation of a low-fat diet. Maybe tomorrow ...