Clayton South - Lab Reports: Can They Be Trusted?

[webmaster]

The newest battle between supplement manufacturers has resulted in an attack upon science and the consumer. Not surprisingly, false laboratory reports on nutritional supplements have caused confusion amongst consumers. What is the truth? Find out here...

http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/south95.htm

HOW TO REVIEW: Post Your Review Of This Article - CLICK ON POST REPLY BELOW! You do NOT need to be a registered member to post a reply in this section!

[BluSilver]

Good article and ain't it the truth. Too many lies and scandals these days. It's a terrible terrible world to live in

[EricS]

in regaurd to the creatine section. maybe I read it wrong, but I think what happened here is that they didn't list every product on the market because they tested the raw material from the only supplier of that raw material. Which means that the CEE HCL that they tested is the same stuff that is put into every product on the market.

It would be like going to a slaughterhouse that is the only supplier of beef to the USA and making a statement that all carriers and resellers of beef in the USA yadda yadda yadda. If the raw materials are bad then you can't make a good product out of it.

[Clayton South]

Originally Posted by EricS

in regaurd to the creatine section. maybe I read it wrong, but I think what happened here is that they didn't list every product on the market because they tested the raw material from the only supplier of that raw material. Which means that the CEE HCL that they tested is the same stuff that is put into every product on the market.

It would be like going to a slaughterhouse that is the only supplier of beef to the USA and making a statement that all carriers and resellers of beef in the USA yadda yadda yadda. If the raw materials are bad then you can't make a good product out of it.

Eric,

Thanks for your feedback.

You are correct. All American Pharmaceuticals conducted this test on the raw product, and therefore all products that utlize this source would be included.

Please keep an eye out for a VERY REVEALING Creatine Ethyl Ester Roundtable discussion that will be released on Monday on our website. I will go into more detail on what was wrong with both tests done by IBC at the bequest of All American Pharmaceuticals.

Let Layne know as well, I know he will love it and I'd be very interested in both your guys feedback.

-Clayton South
www.bodybuilding.com

[ravadongon]

Originally Posted by BluSilver

Good article and ain't it the truth. Too many lies and scandals these days. It's a terrible terrible world to live in

^
Word