Search:

Live in Yonkers and can confirm these brownies are the shiznit.

B&J Coffee Heath Bar Crunch

Awesome awesome awesome. A. Not a huge coffee fan, but it's actually pretty mild for a B&J base. Heath Bars are my #1 mix-in, so I'm slightly biased.

Interesting. It just didn't work for me, but it was worth a shot. Too interesting a flavor to pass up, really.

Probably my favorite mint-based offering.

B&J Phish Food. Still an A. Haven't had a pint of this yet that hasn't left me 100% satisfied.

Recently had B&J Peppermint Cookie and HD Bourbon Pecan Praline

BJPC is really minty, so if you like that, it's a pretty good pint. The cookies are pretty fantastic, too. I'd give it a B.

HD...

HD Chocolate Peanut Butter. Had a bum pint last time; it barely had any peanut butter. This was about 40% peanut butter and a real pain to dig through, but it was blessedly good. B+.
...

Absolutely one of my favorites, too.

I like the PB swirls and base, but the clusters just don't do it for me. Would be better without them IMO.

B&J What A Cluster. I'm still missing what makes this pint so special. I like it, but if I'm going PB, I'm leaning much more towards PB Cup, HD PBP, Talenti Chocolate PB Cup, PB World. It's not...

Cinnamon Buns. A. The girl that looks good in anything. The Grand Canyon of B&J's. If I had one ice cream to eat for the rest of my life, it might just be Cinnamon Buns.
...

I didn't realize how much of a sucker I am for mix-ins untill I had Everything But The... Holy cow, might have gotten into my B&J's top 5. Loved the PB cups, the white chocolate chunks; could have...

Not sure it counts as a mix-in, but throwing ice cream between two pop tarts has been a go-to of mine for a while now. I just recently saw that Carl's Jr. was offering this, as well.

Happy to see Sundae School in Dennisport, MA on there. My parents have a house out there and it really is one of a kind, run exclusively by high school and college students. Will get a...

Talenti Chocolate PB Cup. A-. Right there with HD PBP.

http://i1179.photobucket.com/albums/x381/unflask/127CC8DD-D136-452A-91F2-0A14BAADBDDA-69613-000014E71237D63F_zpse67dea46.jpg...

B&J Milk and Cookies, a satisfying B+. Nothing really complicated, but a hard combo to screw up.

^^^ This picture should be on American currency

definitely one of the best non-premiums on the market (at least in the north east)

The B&J chocolate base can be a bit overwhelming, but really, it's not "awful" at all. All subjective and really depends on what you're in the mood for. I had Chocolate Therapy the other day...

B&J Pineapple Passionfruit
I don't know why this was in my freezer. I really loved this, though. Might not be as good as PB Banana, but it was damn close. Tart, sweet, light. Hit me by surprise...