Massive, you'll look great when cut down. But I doubt you''re 12% now, I was actually thinking of 14%.
Very good chest, 'd like to see so more picture taken from a further distance.
Well that goal should't be to hard, that's not even a beach boy look imo. He looks a bit skinny to me and his arms are kinda small in comparence to the rest.
Saying it's possible you didn't train enough kinda says it all. Cause if you bulk you need to train hard every week, not just skip days every week etc and still be eating much.