This is pretty much what I was going to say. Long face, long pecs. Good physique, but different from the 'standard' fitness model look. And yea, you're not ugly OP, but you're also not quite a...
There was a gif floating around a while back with a chick (in a red shirt I think...) laying down with her eyes closed, then someone starts to grope her clothed funbags, and she opens her eyes and...
Girls have drooled over me since elementary school (srs, no e-brag), long before I ever even considered lifting weights. So I have known since I was very young that you don't need to be big/muscular...