Question on half brother/sister

My oldest sister was over my house for the week. We got to discussing family. She believes, if a brother/sister are from the same mother but different father they are considered full brother/sister. But if they are from the same father but different mother they are considered half brother/sister. I believe the only way they are complete brother/sister is if they are from both. If they are from only one parent, regardless if it is the mother or father, they are considered half brother/sister.

What do you guys think/believe?

[QUOTE=bodyhard;427926741]My oldest sister was over my house for the week. We got to discussing family. She believes, if a brother/sister are from the same mother but different father they are considered full brother/sister. But if they are from the same father but different mother they are considered half brother/sister. I believe the only way they are complete brother/sister is if they are from both. If they are from only one parent, regardless if it is the mother or father, they are considered half brother/sister.

What do you guys think/believe?[/QUOTE]

I would say from both to be full..

[QUOTE=bodyhard;427926741]My oldest sister was over my house for the week. We got to discussing family. She believes, if a brother/sister are from the same mother but different father they are considered full brother/sister. But if they are from the same father but different mother they are considered half brother/sister. I believe the only way they are complete brother/sister is if they are from both. If they are from only one parent, regardless if it is the mother or father, they are considered half brother/sister.

What do you guys think/believe?[/QUOTE]

different parents half bro/sis same parents full bro/sis

Full siblings share full genetic material from the SAME parents.

Sharing one parent (no matter which one) is half.

Sharing no parents, but related as siblings through marriage is step-siblings.

yep..half regardless based on genetics..but raised living together lots of sibs consider to be full no matter who sired them..

[QUOTE=eomrat;427952941]I say half for both scenarios. However, my oldest son is not my biological child and him and his sisters have never considered themselves anything other than just plain Brothers and Sisters. Just as I consider him my son and in fact, get very annoyed when people refer to him as my stepson. In fact, I refuse to EVER write the word "Step" on any form and write "Adopted Son" only on medical forms where our lack of shared genetics could be important.
So really it boils down to more than one definition for the words brother/sister. I am much closer to some of my "brothers" in uniform than I am with my own brother. But they are all still my "Brothers".[/QUOTE]

very nicely stated..and thanks for ur service!!

I have a number of half brothers and sisters, and my family also believes that those born from the same mother are 'full' siblings. I, however, believe that those sired from my father share equal status.

I also believe that if I adopted a child today, then that child would be my daughter's 'full' sibling.

Takes both SAME parents to be full blood siblings.(at least in the definition sense) That said I have a brother and sister and a step father and guess what I know no half people they are my dad and my brother and sister. I have issues with calling anyone half anything but thats just me. Hell I have a brother that isn't even related to me, lack of blood ties doesn't change the fact he is my brother.

Oh let mew clarify, I have 4 brothers and 1 sister from a different father and 1 brother and 1 sister from a different mother, they are ALL my full brothers and sister in my heart.

What my sister and I were arguing about, or should I said disagreeing on, was the factual act of it. She seriously thinks that if they are born with the same mother than they are FULL brothers and sister through DNA. She is even going to get a statement from her physician saying so as I told her it was NOT a fact. :D

[QUOTE=bodyhard;428051321]Oh let mew clarify, I have 4 brothers and 1 sister from a different father and 1 brother and 1 sister from a different mother, they are ALL my full brothers and sister in my heart.

What my sister and I were arguing about, or should I said disagreeing on, was the factual act of it. She seriously thinks that if they are born with the same mother than they are FULL brothers and sister through DNA. She is even going to get a statement from her physician saying so as I told her it was NOT a fact. :D[/QUOTE]


BH, you do realize that even when the doctor tells her she is wrong she will still be right? You are correct but that doesn't matter because she will be right in her mind.

[QUOTE=bigvin73;428054631]BH, you do realize that even when the doctor tells her she is wrong she will still be right? You are correct but that doesn't matter because she will be right in her mind.[/QUOTE]

LOL Man you are probably 100% correct with that statement :D

only in the Bronx could this debate occur.

[QUOTE=bodyhard;427926741]My oldest sister was over my house for the week. We got to discussing family. She believes, if a brother/sister are from the same mother but different father they are considered full brother/sister. But if they are from the same father but different mother they are considered half brother/sister. I believe the only way they are complete brother/sister is if they are from both. If they are from only one parent, regardless if it is the mother or father, they are considered half brother/sister.

What do you guys think/believe?[/QUOTE]

You are correct; full is sired and born of the same mother and father. For anyone that really wants to test this, try being involved in a paternity suit sometimes. And I certainly agree with step- and half- sibling "being like full" in our hearts, but there is a distinctive dna line there.

you are correct.

[QUOTE=bodyhard;427926741]My oldest sister was over my house for the week. We got to discussing family. She believes, if a brother/sister are from the same mother but different father they are considered full brother/sister. But if they are from the same father but different mother they are considered half brother/sister. I believe the only way they are complete brother/sister is if they are from both. If they are from only one parent, regardless if it is the mother or father, they are considered half brother/sister.

What do you guys think/believe?[/QUOTE]
you're right, ans 1/2 sis is kinda stupid.

Dictionary.com

half brother
n. A brother to whom one is biologically related through one parent only


Sounds to me like she's trying to make some weird matriarchal power play. ;)

[QUOTE=bodyhard;428051321]What my sister and I were arguing about, or should I said disagreeing on, was the factual act of it. She seriously thinks that if they are born with the same mother than they are FULL brothers and sister through DNA. She is even going to get a statement from her physician saying so as I told her it was NOT a fact. :D[/QUOTE]

If the physician agrees with her I would pray for her health.

[QUOTE=namtrag;428093531]only in the Bronx could this debate occur.[/QUOTE]

You do realize that we are meeting up at the Arnold? :D

I've always heard that 1/2 siblings have one parent in common, either mother or father, but adoption trumps the biology, at least legally. Adopted kids are considered full siblings regardless of who their birth parents are. I think that also applies if a step-parent legally adopts his/her spouse's biological children.

(Now I might be remembering an episode of "The Brady Bunch", so my answer may be full of crap. :D )

[QUOTE=bigvin73;428054631]BH, you do realize that even when the doctor tells her she is wrong she will still be right? You are correct but that doesn't matter because she will be right in her mind.[/QUOTE]

lol this x2

[QUOTE=bodyhard;428051321]She seriously thinks that if they are born with the same mother than they are FULL brothers and sister through DNA. [/QUOTE]
I'm sorry to say this but that's the most ridiculous thing I've heard.

[QUOTE=themyth2009;428315581]lol this x2[/QUOTE]

We PM'ed each other regarding this as it is a little deeper than that :D :D

But I want to show her this thread [i]just in case[/i] ;) :)

[QUOTE=Keltron;428317151]I'm sorry to say this but that's the most ridiculous thing I've heard.[/QUOTE]

My point exactly, but she is [b]so[/b] sure :)

i have a brother and sister who have a different dad than me, but i dont use half brother/sister, i consider them full.

[QUOTE=verycleansnatch;428319161]i have a brother and sister who have a different dad than me, but i dont use half brother/sister, i consider them full.[/QUOTE]

That's where personal preference and attitude come in. The whole full/half/step sibling thing is a matter of biology and geneology (i.e. your family tree), and a bit of legal language in some situations. However, within the family, people can be more flexible. If you think of them as brother and sister, then that's who they are to you, which is what counts in the long run.
At Christmas, my cousin was trying to figure out what type of "cousin" we are (she and my mom were "first cousins" so she says we are "second cousins" and her daughters are my "third cousins"). My response was "Heck, I just call all of you 'cousin' and end it at that. It doesn't matter much to me. We're all related somehow."

Well my sister spoke to her Doctor and he told her quote on quote, "Where did you get that ridiculous idea from" Where my sister then said "My mother" :)

Damn so my Moms fed that crap to my sister :(

Anyway another mystery answered :D :D :D

Thanks for the response guys.

Is this a question about incest??

Do not f*ck this person.

[QUOTE=KimberleyRN;427934771]Full siblings share full genetic material from the SAME parents.

Sharing one parent (no matter which one) is half.

Sharing no parents, but related as siblings through marriage is step-siblings.[/QUOTE]

that

[QUOTE=bodyhard;427926741]My oldest sister was over my house for the week. We got to discussing family. She believes, if a brother/sister are from the same mother but different father they are considered full brother/sister. But if they are from the same father but different mother they are considered half brother/sister. I believe the only way they are complete brother/sister is if they are from both. If they are from only one parent, regardless if it is the mother or father, they are considered half brother/sister.

What do you guys think/believe?[/QUOTE]

You are correct. :)

It's Christmas, a divine time of the year, half brother/sister, second cousin twice removed, family is just that, family. Someone you love, what's in a name or a qualifier? Make them know that they are loved, important, part of the whole! I know that was not the original question, but I'm in the mood! Tis a glorious season, one full of love, all encompassing love. One never knows nowadays just what simple family ties can do!