Impact of nuts/veggies on thyroid?

[jg_girl088]

So I just came across something a little depressing - apparently nuts and some vegetables are bad for the thyroid? I know soy is, but I didn't know that it was also harmful to eat peanuts?

from this link - http://www.medicalonly.com/index.php/2007/04/

"Some of the culprits most frequently cited by experts include kale, cabbage, turnips, mustard greens, Brussels sprouts, cassava, pine nuts, peanuts, millet, and soy-based products. Although the exact extent of their thyroid-suppressing action remains unclear, experts suggest avoiding the consumption of large quantities of foods in the goitrogenic category."

I don't have a thyroid problem, but I eat a lot of nuts/veggies (within my carb allowance) and so I don't want to run into problems later!

[Minotaur]

If these vegetables are cooked (except millet... it gets worse for thyroid patients when it's cooked) they are not a problem. If you are euthyroid (no thyroid problem) they are no problem. They will not cause hypothyroidism. Soy is always bad for hypothyroid patients.

[jg_girl088]

so even if i eat a ton of almonds/peanuts everyday for the rest of my life, i would not have to worry about developing thyroid problems? I guess its good that I do like my veggies cooked (and I dont eat millet, whatever that is lol)

[Minotaur]

You should be OK... it doesn't come from diet. Hypothyroidism is usually an autoimmune disorder and tends to run in families.

[jg_girl088]

Oh ok, thanks for the info!

[Eileen]

Long term low calorie dieting (and we are talking years rather than months) can reduce thyroid function, but regular refeeds go a long way to preventing that.

Soy is all forms is a big No No when it comes to thyroid function. So there go all the low carb bars.....

[chodan9]

so your saying something like soy milk would affect a normal healthy thyroid negatively? how so if thats the case?

[Eileen]

Well, if three servings of soy a week can reduce the fertility of healthy men, I wouldn't be at all surprised to find soy can do nasty things to your thyroid.

I don't know the exact mechanism, but soy and thyroids are not a good mix.

[rusrious]

Soy is not good for your thyroid. My doctor told me so.. I have a thyroid problem, ( Hypo).. I take synthroid every darm day.. I hate it..

[gagi729]

I had heard that pistachios and pecans were not good for thyroid. Also someone just posted that low calorie dieting is not good either, what are the effects.