Trade Advice

[NoCreativity]

Will rep whoever helps....

I've been offered Eli Manning and Chris Chambers for Fred Jackson. My QBs are Carson Palmer and Kyle Orton and my other RBs are Ray Rice, DeAngelo Williams, and Steven Jackson.

I'm leaning towards no, but I really do need a decent QB....

Thoughts?

[ezmac31]

make a counter offer and get something good...jacksons values drops dramatically in 2 weeks anyway

[frankky4fingers]

Will rep whoever helps....

I've been offered Eli Manning and Chris Chambers for Fred Jackson. My QBs are Carson Palmer and Kyle Orton and my other RBs are Ray Rice, DeAngelo Williams, and Steven Jackson.

I'm leaning towards no, but I really do need a decent QB....

Thoughts?

I am leaning towards yes, beast mode will be back in 2 weeks, i despise kyle orton and think Eli will help your team out.. your other rb's are studs too

[Hishiad]

You get Eli at a position you don't need.


And you get a WR who did NOTHING


for a RB that had a better week than any of your other RBs.



I'd counter offer and try to get a GOOD WR out of the deal.

[DL Addict]

Will rep whoever helps....

I've been offered Eli Manning and Chris Chambers for Fred Jackson. My QBs are Carson Palmer and Kyle Orton and my other RBs are Ray Rice, DeAngelo Williams, and Steven Jackson.

I'm leaning towards no, but I really do need a decent QB....

Thoughts?

Eli is steady, but Palmer has more upside...and if Orton and Marshall get in rhythm, he will be a serviceable bye week filler. I wouldn't do this trade. I do think you would be wise to move Fred asap though, with Lynch coming back...seeing as your other 3 RBs are studs. But, you can get a solid #2 WR for Fred right now, and that's what I would target.

[NoCreativity]

Thanks. Repped all for helping.

[frankky4fingers]

Thanks. Repped all for helping.

what did you end up doing?

[kethnaab]

scoring, your roster, and the other dude's roster would be nice to see